[QUOTE=Diogenes the Cynic]
It might be illegal but whether it’s “ethical” is completely a matter of opinion. My opinion is that there is no victim so it’s not unethical.
[/QUOTE]
I’d agree with this. In fact, I used to get on pretty well (before we moved) with the owner of a local Video Library franchise (I won’t name it), who told me that they KNOW everyone copies the DVDs, and they didn’t care as long as they got paid for the film’s rental. The prices factored in the royalties to the film companies, the price of actually getting the DVD in the first place, and, of course, enough of a profit to pay the staff, overheads, and so on, with a bit left over.
In short, no harm is done by people burning rented DVDS for their own, private use. Naturally, flogging them off for $5 each a flea market IS unethical and illegal, and so it should be, but the appropriate people have received money for a DVD that John Smith rents and then burns a copy of so he can watch it later. As others have said, there’s no “Guarantee” that John Smith was going to actually buy the DVD when it comes out for $30 or so- but how is burning a copy he’s paid for any different from watching the film on TV? Cable? The “Artists” have been paid, and John Smith has a DVD he can watch, albeit one without a fancy box or cover.
I find all these comparisons to “Going to the Library and photocopying a book” rather odd.
Firstly, Libraries here don’t charge membership fees or borrowing fees- it’s all totally free. It also takes a LOT longer to read a book than watch a film or TV show, and most importantly, books, by their very nature, haven’t had major cinematic releases where people already paid a lot of money to watch or see it first time around.
Books are also considerably cheaper to make than films… Unless the Author has a major Hookers, Blow, and Gambling problem there is no way a Novel could possibly cost more than $150,000 or so to write, whereas the going rate on even a low-budget film these days is a couple of million dollars.
Finally, the Book format has been with us (as we know it) since late antiquity/early Middle Ages (and even earlier), really coming into it’s own in the mid-15th Century once a Mr. Gutenberg got involved (no, not THAT Gutenberg, the Bible one. Geez, kids these days…), whereas films have only been around for a little over a century and a quarter (and didn’t have sound or colour until the 1920s)- and even now, the format changes. VHS had 20 years of being the dominant format for home viewing, and now that’s gone, don’t all the complaints about Video Piracy seem not only moot, but more than a little silly? DVDs won’t be around forever, and once they’ve been replaced, all this jumping up and down about DVD piracy will no doubt be viewed with the same contempt we reserve for people who complained Elvis’ “indecent” pelvic gyrations in the 1950s…
On preview, I see that last paragraph is missing a point, so I’ll try and crowbar one in: Books have an aura of the Academic and the Scholarly about them. If you visit someone who’s house is overflowing with books, you’re most likely to think “Wow, smart guy/gal!”- Movies are seen as being pure entertainment (and less face it, everyone loves entertainment). Make of that what you will, but I just can’t agree with anyone who sees a problem with copying DVDs (which provide plenty of entertainment) that they’ve rented. As long as the “artist” has received some form of remuneration from the video library for each time the film was rented, I’d say there’s no problem. Besides, how many Actors from big-budget films are what you’d call impoverished? (Not counting those with drug problems or who made a choice to renounce material wealth, of course…)