[QUOTE=Mr2001]
I have no idea how you could get that impression from anything I’ve written. It’s absurd and I’ve said no such thing.
[/QUOTE]
The impression you’re denying here is that you’re arguing that noone ever should write anything again. I’m not sure how you missed the reasoning, but I’ll give it to you again: from post #132:
[QUOTE=Mr2001]
The author was also being pretty stupid, spending two years on his life on something that there’s really no logical way to profit from. At best, he’d have to rely on a nearly unenforceable law to intimidate people into buying copies from him rather than making their own; at worst, no one would want to buy the book at all and his time would be wasted.
Would an accountant spend his own time and money to research a company’s finances, prepare their tax forms, etc. in the hopes that he might be able to sell his finished work to that company after the fact? I sure hope not.
[/QUOTE]
The “pretty stupid” think the author did was that he dared publish a book. You are extremely clear that the writing of the book itself was stupid, since you cover the case where copyright is inapplicable as well. To cement this perspective, you draw an analogy with the accountant. Let’s restore the original content back into that analogy you drew and see what you’re, shall we say, ‘strongly implying’?
‘Would an author spend his own time and money to develop a story for an audience, prepare it for publication, etc. in the hopes that he might be able to sell his finished work to that audience after the fact? I sure hope not.’
You’ve stated both explicitly and by analogy that you think that anyone who authors a book is stupid. I concede that I made the leap from there to the idea that you thought they shouldn’t do the stupid act.
[QUOTE=Mr2001]
I have no problem with anything producing books, movies, songs, or whatever, and in fact I’m willing to pay them to do it. I am not willing, however, to be strong-armed into paying them for making copies of something that’s already been written, because I can easily do that myself.
[/QUOTE]
So you’re happy to pay for material if you commissioned it, but if it doesn’t have your name on it, you’re unwilling to pay for it, but will take it anyway? What interesting “morals” you have. It’s a good thing that not everybody shares them, or everybody would just be waiting for somebody else to commission that art, and then you’d have nothing to rip off! (Unless you want to try and convince me that you’ve financed a major motion picture lately.)
[QUOTE=Mr2001]
Indeed. There are rare exceptions, such as for personal medical and financial information. The issue is not that the information “belongs” to someone else, but that its distribution would be so harmful that limiting freedom to prevent it is justified.
[/QUOTE]
The example that this is actually responding to is acquiring naked pictures of people against their will, which I will note is not covered by your list of ‘rare exceptions’. I really do hope this was an accidental ommision on your part, though the way you wrote it it doesn’t sound like it. I also note that you don’t seem to think that a person has an actual right to keep anything private; you merely concede that there are limited cases where the potential for criminal acts against them is so blatantly high that you haven’t a snowball’s chance of supporting the idea that distributing the information is ethical.
I would say that if you actually believe that that taking pictures of that woman through the crack in her blinds and handing copies out to their friends is ethical, then I would argue that you wouldn’t know a moral if it bit you on the butt. The same thing holds if you think it would be ethical to xerox somebody’s unpublished manuscript (and/or their diary, same difference) and post it on the internet. Good grief.
[QUOTE=Mr2001]
But I find it ridiculous to think that putting a buck in someone else’s pocket, or maintaining some company’s profit margin, is a legitimate reason to set aside such an important principle. If we could magically replicate food, and feed every starving person on the earth for nothing, would we choose not to because that would undermine the companies that’d like to sell them food instead? I sure hope not. Entertainment might not be as vital as food, but I think giving everyone access to information, entertainment, and culture is a noble goal as well.
[/QUOTE]
That’ll be a good analogy the minute that people start dying of star trek deficiency. Heck, you’re pushing you’re luck by comparing your desire to rip an illegal copy of Jay and Silent Bob Strikes Back with ‘giving everyone access to information, entertainment, and culture’. The noble goal you’re pushing for here is “rob from anybody, keep for myself”. Kind of like Robin Hood. Or maybe not.