I had a few more more pluses and minuses to log between my Galaxy S4 and the iPhone 4S/5.
Galaxy S4 > iPhone:
App widgets. I really like this feature of Android. To have readouts of a clock, weather, sports scores and possibly news headlines visible at a glance without opening up an app is very handy, and showcases the much better multi-tasking on Android vs. iOS. And oh, yeah…
True multi-tasking between apps. It is potentially a battery drain, but I like to have the option of multi-tasking apps that run in the background unless I kill it, versus not having the option at all. The ability to carry 1 or 2 extra fully-charged batteries that I can swap in at any time also makes this a big win.
iPhone > Galaxy S4:
Charging and Audio Accesories. A lot of really nice accessories, like docks and car stereo adapters, only exist for iOS devices. Both of my cars are equipped with cords that can charge my iPhone 4S while simultaneously using it as a digital audio device, allowing me to browse playlists, albums, etc., using the car’s stereo controls (Which includes steering wheel mounted controls). No such adapters exist for the Galaxy S4, so I have to use a 12V cigarette port charging cable and an auxiliary input audio patch cable to plug into the headphone jack of my phone, using my phone’s controls to select music. The sound quality is not as good, and I don’t care for fiddling with the phone while driving, so my ability to change my music selection requires a passenger or for me to pull over.
Bottom Line:
The hardware and OS geek in me loves all the pluses of the more open and more flexible Android setup, but the three big core uses I have for my phone have wins on the Apple side that just about balance things out.
The S4 has a larger display, supports multi-tasking apps and app widgets, battery swapping, external storage, I can use it as a USB drive. With the widgets and the larger screen, my S4’s UI is (to me) much sexier and comfortable to use than the iPhone’s “square trays of square icons” filling up swipe screen after swipe screen. And instead of “race you to see who can open up a calendar appointment first”, I’d use a benchmark of “race you to see who can tell me the score of the Mets game going on right now first” or “Is it supposed to rain today or not?”, where the widgets are like a turbo booster.
On the other hand, my Big Three Functional Areas Of Use come out with the iPhone ahead:
1 - Using it as a camera (detailed review already given). In theory this could be fixed for the S4 with a firmware or other software update.
2 - Using it as a one-device media player in my pocket. The S4 should win this based on the external storage, but the accessory angle tips this in favor of the iPhone and the fact that I use the music aspect far more than the video aspect of my phone (i.e., a 64 GB iPhone can store all my music + a few videos is a 99% coverage solution). This could also be fixed with some third-party work, it’s not a problem with the phone itself, but clearly the market here skews strongly for Apple for whatever reason (probably because not all Android phones would “work the same” in terms of accessories, but all iOS devices would).
3 - Using it to communicate with my family. As long as they’re all still on iOS devices, let’s face it, it’s easier when everything is in the same ecosystem. In particular, “Find My Friends” as a free built-in service is something I used a fair amount, and now I’m severed from my family and friends set in that regard, as they aren’t going to use Google Latitude or something just for me.
I’m hoping the S4 or some other Android phone can close the gap in #1 and #2 by the time I upgrade again, the better to match up with the rumored 4.8" screen iPhone “XL” for next summer/fall. I will take a closer look at the HTC and Sony offerings in that light when that happens.