# Judge blocks Arizona "show me your papers" law

**URL:** <https://boards.straightdope.com/t/judge-blocks-arizona-show-me-your-papers-law/548345>\
**Category:** Great Debates\
**Created:** [July 28, 2010, 6:58pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/judge-blocks-arizona-show-me-your-papers-law/548345 "2010-07-28T18:58:03Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 20\
**Page:** 22

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![emacknight](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/e/3ec8ea/32.png) [@emacknight](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/emacknight)\
**Post date:** [August 3, 2010, 4:13am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/judge-blocks-arizona-show-me-your-papers-law/548345/421 "2010-08-03T04:13:20Z")

</div>

> [@Bricker](#):
>
> > [@emacknight](#):
> >
> > So first we have the fact that when asked a person can simply refuse to answer. Second, even if he can’t answer it will take too long to verify.
> > 
> > There is no \*reasonable \*suspicion concerning a person’s legal status. And there is no \*reasonable \*way to verify that information.
> > 
> > What is the point of this law?
> 
> Simple question, which you have dodged and ignored over and over:
> 
> Do you understand that the same thing applies to contraband searches now? “A person can simply refuse to answer.” And yet in huge numbers, they don’t?
> 
> Do you understand that? Yes? No?

Yes, I do understand that, I actually said that a few times.

You really shouldn’t keep accusing people of dodging questions while you yourself are dodging questions.

So to you: since you mentioned contraband searches, I assume you are aware of other factors that might give a cop reasonable suspicion. Aside from self incrimination, are you aware of any other causes for reasonable suspicion with regards to a person’s residency status?

And let’s be clear, I am not hand waving away self incrimination. It’s great, lots of people plead guilty. But surely you are aware of at least one person that plead not-guilty, that was later found to in fact be guilty.

So it seems to be you that is hand-waving away all the other work done in the process of a conviction. As if all that has to be done is wait for them to confess. Makes you wonder why cops need radar guns and breathalyzer. A guess search warrants are never issued either. All we need to do is ask.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![emacknight](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/e/3ec8ea/32.png) [@emacknight](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/emacknight)\
**Post date:** [August 3, 2010, 4:20am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/judge-blocks-arizona-show-me-your-papers-law/548345/422 "2010-08-03T04:20:27Z")

</div>

> [@Bricker](#):
>
> And for every reader still with us, let me ask you: what message do you take away when defenders of a point of view have to resort to tactics like these to try to persuade you?

Classy.

I wonder what happens when we look at the tactics used by those that support this law:

> [@bullrun](#):
>
> The federal government under obama simply refuses to help American citizens in Arizona defend their state and themselves from an onslaught from another nation. An onslaught that is costing them tons of money and the very lives of their citizens due to a great influx of illegal criminals.  
> (snip)  
> This aciton by a liberal judge has added more votes against the democrats in Novermber. People will not forget the plight of Arizona. Washington is hastening the time when people are simply going to quit obeying the dictates of left leaning activist judges.

> [@LonesomePolecat](#):
>
> > [@Diogenes\_the\_Cynic](#):
> >
> > The federal government is allowed to prioritize enforcement however it wants. It’s none of Arizona’s business.
> 
> So if the federal government decides that protecting the lives and property of the people of Arizona isn’t a priority, Arizona is just out of luck?

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Bricker](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/b/977dab/32.png) [@Bricker](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Bricker)\
**Post date:** [August 3, 2010, 12:15pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/judge-blocks-arizona-show-me-your-papers-law/548345/423 "2010-08-03T12:15:23Z")

</div>

> [@emacknight](#):
>
> The scenario you just described is EXACTLY what I’ve been talking about since page 1. Exactly as YOU just described, AZ law enforcement would decide weather (sic) to turn investigation over to ICE based on **probable cause**.
> 
> So other than self incrimination, what probable cause? Oddly enough, when I mentioned this happening, \*\*Bricker \*\*made it very clear that it can’t happen like that. I guess he’s okay with your version of things.

_sigh_

“Reasonable suspicion” and “probable cause” are two very different things. One is not a synonym of the other.

I don’t remember where I discussed what could happen with probable cause in any great detail, or even at all.

So I suspect that in your mind, you’re conflating “reasonable suspicion,” which I did indeed devote much discussion to, with “probable cause.” Is that what’s happening here?

> [@](#):
>
> That’s what opponents of this law expect to have happen–a lot, but not to white people.
> 
> This is the part of the law no one wants to talk about.

“Probable cause,” is the standard for an arrest. If there is probable cause to believe a person committed a crime, they may be arrested. That’s the law in every state in the land.

If the police do develop probable cause to suspect an immigration violation (again, a standard different than ‘reasonable suspicion’) then, yes, in Arizona it will probably not happen very often to white people. And that’s because the number of white people in Arizona guilty of immigration law violations is vanishingly small compared to the number of non-white people.

So what? Do you believe that the justice system has some obligation to enforce racial equality amongst their arrestees?

> [@](#):
>
> Does anyone know what happens when a person (either legal or not) is handed over to ICE, with probable cause or not? I know, and it’s not pretty. It is neither quick nor painless.

So what?

Wait, let me modify that statement. As to a person turned over with probable cause… so what? No arrest process anywhere in the country can be described as ‘pretty.’ But an arrest anywhere in the country can be made based upon probable cause.

Now, you slipped in “…probable cause **or not**.” I agree with you that if a person is turned over to ICE without probable cause, that’s not pretty. And more to the point, it’s not right.

Fortunately, this law does not permit that to happen.

> [@](#):
>
> When you hear people complain about this law, it is because even though they are legal, they expect to be treated like they aren’t.

Boo fucking hoo. They are free to ignore the officer’s inquiries, something that’s not true at border crossings. You may well be right – the opposition to this law may come from precisely that fear. But that’s not a constitutional problem. That’s a public policy problem. If the people of Arizona don’t like this treatment, they can vote out the legislators that crafted it.

But wait - they LOVE this law. So it’s only you, then.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Bricker](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/b/977dab/32.png) [@Bricker](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Bricker)\
**Post date:** [August 3, 2010, 12:46pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/judge-blocks-arizona-show-me-your-papers-law/548345/424 "2010-08-03T12:46:47Z")

</div>

> [@emacknight](#):
>
> > [@Bricker](#):
> >
> > Do you understand that? Yes? No?
> 
> Yes, I do understand that, I actually said that a few times.
> 
> You really shouldn’t keep accusing people of dodging questions while you yourself are dodging questions.

What question have I dodged?!?

> [@](#):
>
> So to you: since you mentioned contraband searches, I assume you are aware of other factors that might give a cop reasonable suspicion. Aside from self incrimination, are you aware of any other causes for reasonable suspicion with regards to a person’s residency status?

Asked and answered above, in great detail. To summarize: incrimination by one’s associates, prior personal knowledge of the officer involved, documentary evidence possessed by the person being investigated.

> [@](#):
>
> And let’s be clear, I am not hand waving away self incrimination. It’s great, lots of people plead guilty. But surely you are aware of at least one person that plead not-guilty, that was later found to in fact be guilty.

Who is talking about “pleading” guilty??

I am talking about making inculpatory statements at the side of the road.

> [@](#):
>
> So it seems to be you that is hand-waving away all the other work done in the process of a conviction. As if all that has to be done is wait for them to confess. Makes you wonder why cops need radar guns and breathalyzer. A guess search warrants are never issued either. All we need to do is ask.

In fact, inculpatory statements that give rise to probable cause are much more useful, numbers-wise, than breathalyzers are. I doubt you actually care about this, because your pattern is to studiously ignore facts that don’t help you.

But for the benefit of readers who might actually … you know… read… let’s discuss the breathalyzer and the radar gun.

So the radar gun gives the officer cause to pull over a car. (The analogy to our Arizona law is obvious: the cops have to have someone detained for another violation, non-immigration related, before the Arizona law even applies).

Once the car is pulled over, the officer cannot simply stick a breathalyzer tube in the car and say, “Blow into this.” He must have _reasonable suspicion_ that the driver is intoxicated. (The analogy to our Arizona law is obvious, and identical: he is not required to make an effort to verify the immigration status unless he has _reasonable suspicion_ that the driver has committed an immigration violation.)

So the officer looks for a way to develop that reasonable suspicion. He may well ask every driver he stops, “Have you had anything to drink this evening?” That’s somewhat of a joke amongst law enforcement, in fact, because so many people will respond, "Just a couple of beers. (The analogy to our immigration law is obvious, and identical: the officer asks everyone he stops, “Are you a U.S. citizen or legal resident?”)

The answer to the officer’s question may end the investigation, or it may develop further. The officer may smell alcohol on the driver’s breath, or the driver’s speech may be slurred, or the driver may admit to consuming alcohol, all of which can create reasonable suspicion. (The analogy to our Arizona law is obvious: the detainee may provide an inculpatory answer, one that incriminates himself.)

At this point, lacking reasonable suspicion, the officer can issue a citation for the original offense of speeding, but nothing more. (Analogy: the officer issues a citation for the original offense, but nothing more).

Or, if the officer has reasonable suspicion because of an inculpatory answer or external evidence, he may require a field sobriety test. This is a test that drivers, “even though they are legal,” can “expect to be treated like they aren’t.” The driver must stand at the side of the road and perform a series of physical steps at the command of the officer. You may be asked to take nine heel-to-toe steps forward, pivot, and then take nine heel-to-toe steps back to your starting point while counting out loud the number of steps that you have taken. You may have to raise one foot six inches off of the ground while keeping yours arms at your side, count out loud to 30, and then put your foot back down. You may be asked to watch the officer’s pen by moving your eyes while keeping your head still.

All of these are performed by the side of the road in full view of passing cars.

(The analogy to the Arizona law? Probably the brief detention while the officer attempts to confirm immigration status using the name, date of birth, and alien registration number if available.)

If the results of the field sobriety tests show intoxication, then the officer has _probable cause_ to believe the driver is guilty of that offense. At this time, the officer will arrest the driver and transport him to jail. (The analogy: the officer receives words that the person is an immigration violator, and now has probable cause to arrest him).

If the results of the field sobriety test do not show intoxication, then the investigation is over, and the driver is free to go (after being cited for the original offense). (Analogy: If the immigration information shows no violation, or is not returned in a reasonable time, the person is free to go).

At the jail, the person is required to submit to a breathalyzer test, the result of which are admissible at his trial for DWI. (Analogy: transportation to ICE for processing and eventual determination of action).

That was a lot of typing on my part. I hope it had some effect. I hope you can see I’m not claiming that confession, alone, is all that’s needed in either case.

I’m not sure if you’re just stubborn, or if you have vast gaping holes in your understanding of how the criminal justice system works.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Bricker](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/b/977dab/32.png) [@Bricker](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Bricker)\
**Post date:** [August 3, 2010, 12:49pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/judge-blocks-arizona-show-me-your-papers-law/548345/425 "2010-08-03T12:49:01Z")

</div>

> [@emacknight](#):
>
> I would EXPECT voters to strike down a politician that proposes and passes a bill of such caliber. (and by strike down I mean vote against, nothing violent, just turning a phrase).

What’s your explanation for the overwhelming popularity of this bill, then? The voters don’t seem to be following your expectations.

Guess democracy is sacred… unless the voters are too stupid to know what’s best. Then they must be forced to comply.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![emacknight](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/e/3ec8ea/32.png) [@emacknight](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/emacknight)\
**Post date:** [August 3, 2010, 1:56pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/judge-blocks-arizona-show-me-your-papers-law/548345/426 "2010-08-03T13:56:47Z")

</div>

> [@Bricker](#):
>
> _sigh_
> 
> “Reasonable suspicion” and “probable cause” are two very different things. One is not a synonym of the other.
> 
> I don’t remember where I discussed what could happen with probable cause in any great detail, or even at all.
> 
> So I suspect that in your mind, you’re conflating “reasonable suspicion,” which I did indeed devote much discussion to, with “probable cause.” Is that what’s happening here?

> [@Stratocaster](#):
>
> > [@Stratocaster](#):
> >
> > Wait a minute–are you under the impression that “reasonable suspicion” gives the cop cause and authority to delay the suspect indefinitely and subject them to any process the cop would like? You know that’s not the case, right? It is a standard less than probable cause, and it gives the cop much less leeway in terms of detaining someone. He needs to wrap it up quickly. Are you aware of that? The legal swamp you seem to be guarding against, the one where these false positives will create some shapeless “legal snafu” for an endless parade of innocents, doesn’t exist. Not unless the cop completely ignores the law or is incompetent. Reasonable suspicion gives the cop authority to briefly detain and question (Terry stops let them briefly search a person for weapons too, but that’s a different debate).
> > 
> > > [@emacknight](#):
> > >
> > > Here is something you aren’t aware of. The state I live in requires me, an immigrant, to verify my visa status with them every year. And every year they fuck it up. It’s not as easy as flashing a card or handing over a note from your mom. If the DMV can’t do it, how the fuck is a cop supposed to do it on the side of an Arizona highway?
> > 
> > **If he can’t, he has to cut the suspect loose. Such is the nature of “reasonable suspicion,” a notion you seem to be unfamiliar with. The cop doesn’t get to detain someone indefinitely, and if he can’t confirm the citizenship status quickly (meaning, he doesn’t know if the person is legal or not), tough shit, he has to let the suspect go.** “Reasonable suspicion” does not give the cop carte blanche. In fact, it doesn’t give him much leeway at all. And, again, this is all subject to judicial review, where the judiciary kicks the asses of cops who abuse their power. Or are they in on this conspiracy of abuse as well?

\*\*Bricker \*\*, here was the comment I was referring too. Since it passed by you unchecked, I assumed everything **Stratocaster** said was 100% true.

Am I correct to assume an officer should have reasonable suspicion before he’ll have probable cause?

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Bricker](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/b/977dab/32.png) [@Bricker](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Bricker)\
**Post date:** [August 3, 2010, 3:03pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/judge-blocks-arizona-show-me-your-papers-law/548345/427 "2010-08-03T15:03:25Z")

</div>

> [@emacknight](#):
>
> \*\*Bricker \*\*, here was the comment I was referring too. Since it passed by you unchecked, I assumed everything **Stratocaster** said was 100% true.

Not a fair assumption. But in this case, I don’t see where he’s said anything incorrect; he simply hasn’t laid out the minutiae of detail that is apparently necessary to explain the steps involved.

> [@](#):
>
> Am I correct to assume an officer should have reasonable suspicion before he’ll have probable cause?

Not necessarily. He may immediately have probable cause. “Reasonable suspicion,” is a level of suspicion below that of probable cause, but above a mere unparticularized suspicion or a hunch. An officer has reasonable suspicion when he can point to specific, articulable facts that together give rise to the reasonable inference that a crime may have been committed.

So… what **Stratocaster** said is:

> [@](#):
>
> If he can’t [develop probable cause after a brief investigation that was the result of reasonable suspicion], he has to cut the suspect loose. Such is the nature of “reasonable suspicion,” a notion you seem to be unfamiliar with. The cop doesn’t get to detain someone indefinitely, and if he can’t confirm the citizenship status quickly (meaning, he doesn’t know if the person is legal or not), tough shit, he has to let the suspect go. “Reasonable suspicion” does not give the cop carte blanche. In fact, it doesn’t give him much leeway at all. And, again, this is all subject to judicial review, where the judiciary kicks the asses of cops who abuse their power. Or are they in on this conspiracy of abuse as well?

The brackets I added were to fill in what may have been missing in your understanding of the statement. (And, obviously, if this is NOT what **Stratocaster** meant, I am sure he’ll correct me).

So the sequence of events is:

- stop, detention, or arrest for some other crime
- during that stop, officer develops reasonable suspicion of immigration violation
- officer investigates further to confirm or dispel suspicion of immigration

How long can this further detention take to investigate? Not long, as **Stratocaster** hinted. It can’t generally exceed the length necessary for the original detention.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![emacknight](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/e/3ec8ea/32.png) [@emacknight](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/emacknight)\
**Post date:** [August 3, 2010, 3:17pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/judge-blocks-arizona-show-me-your-papers-law/548345/428 "2010-08-03T15:17:46Z")

</div>

> [@Bricker](#):
>
> Asked and answered above, in great detail. To summarize: incrimination by one’s associates, prior personal knowledge of the officer involved, documentary evidence possessed by the person being investigated.

Good, adding self-incrimination, from this point on, that is what we’ll consider “reasonable suspicion.”

> [@Bricker](#):
>
> I doubt you actually care about this, because your pattern is to studiously ignore facts that don’t help you.

You can keep saying that, thus forming a pattern, but it doesn’t negate the facts that you so eloquently ignore. Pot meet kettle.

> [@Bricker](#):
>
> But for the benefit of readers who might actually … you know… read… let’s discuss the breathalyzer and the radar gun.
> 
> So the radar gun gives the officer cause to pull over a car. (The analogy to our Arizona law is obvious: the cops have to have someone detained for another violation, non-immigration related, before the Arizona law even applies).

That’s right, you agree there are lots of reasons to pull someone over.

> [@Bricker](#):
>
> Once the car is pulled over, the officer cannot simply stick a breathalyzer tube in the car and say, “Blow into this.” He must have _reasonable suspicion_ that the driver is intoxicated. (The analogy to our Arizona law is obvious, and identical: he is not required to make an effort to verify the immigration status unless he has _reasonable suspicion_ that the driver has committed an immigration violation.)

Good, we agree about this point too.

> [@Bricker](#):
>
> So the officer looks for a way to develop that reasonable suspicion. He may well ask every driver he stops, “Have you had anything to drink this evening?” That’s somewhat of a joke amongst law enforcement, in fact, because so many people will respond, "Just a couple of beers. (The analogy to our immigration law is obvious, and identical: the officer asks everyone he stops, “Are you a U.S. citizen or legal resident?”)

Now let’s keep this analogy tight. Lots of people say, “had a couple of beers” because you are legally allowed to do that and still drive. It’s also a fungible term to both tell the truth (drank alcohol) and hide the facts (drank a lot of alcohol).

But as far as our comparison goes, the people that answer “had a couple” are still legally allowed to drive, they are below the legal limit. They represent the group I am trying to discuss–false positives.

Does that make sense to you? Maybe you don’t have enough training in statistics. This group (people that had one beer) are legally allowed to drive, but they answer the question as asked truthfully, and give reasonable suspicion. We have now created a condition that makes a group of the population _suspected criminals_.

Let’s just outline that again in case there is a specific legal term I misused. There is nothing illegal about having 1 beer and then driving\*. We have DUI laws to catch the people that over 0.08, but in the process we have to make the people that are between 0.01 and 0.08 suspected criminals. That is a the group of false positives, that give “reasonable suspicion” but are in fact legally allowed to drive.

So for the AZ law, we have to consider what will count as “reasonable suspicion.” You mentioned above, the cop will ask, “Are you a citizen\*\*.” The suspect will truthfully say no–and still be a legal alien. Now by virtue of being both honest, and not a citizen, our suspect has given reasonable suspicion for further investigation. This is analogous to the people that “had a beer.” They are legal, but give reasonable suspicion.

\*\*Remember that we are looking for an analogous question to “have you been drinking?” Cops don’t ask, “Are you drunk?” Or “did you consume more alcohol than legally allowed before operating a motor vehicle.” They ask a very simple generic question as you pointed out, intended to get reasonable suspicion.

Can you see how this law can create a huge number of false positives? There is a grey area between citizen/greencard and illegal alien. According to wiki, United States Visas were issued to 6.6 million foreign nationals visiting the United States and to 470 thousand immigrants in 2008. So we are looking for the 12 million illegal aliens, but mixed up in the population of 320million citizens are about 7million legal immigrants.

What that means to me, is that for every 100 stops, 3.75 might be illegal, and 2.18 might be visa holders. Or said another way, for ever 3 people that give reasonable suspicion, only 2 of them are in fact illegal, but the third gives reasonable suspicion leading to probable cause.

> [@Bricker](#):
>
> The answer to the officer’s question may end the investigation, or it may develop further. \*\*The officer may smell alcohol on the driver’s breath, or the driver’s speech may be slurred, \*\*or the driver may admit to consuming alcohol, all of which can create reasonable suspicion. (The analogy to our Arizona law is obvious: the detainee may provide an inculpatory answer, one that incriminates himself.)

Notice that with a DUI there are other factors an officer can use to get reasonable suspicion? So both DUI and the AZ law involve a question, that may lead to self incrimination. Both could have a friend say, “dude just tell the truth.” Both could be known to the officer.

But the AZ law doesn’t have what we might consider “external clues.” Both groups could lie, “no i haven’t been drinking, yes I am a citizen.” In the first, the officer can find reasonable suspicion in other ways, in the second he doesn’t have any that are unique to this law. Does that make sense to you? All the reasonable suspicion examples you gave also be applied to DUIs, but the external clues for a DUI can’t be translated back to the AZ law.

It reminds me a lot of Rastafarians, who by virtue of their culture are suspected of being high and having pot. This is why a lot of people suspect that race/accent/appearance will be used as an external clue to provide reasonable suspicion.

> [@Bricker](#):
>
> At this point, lacking reasonable suspicion, the officer can issue a citation for the original offense of speeding, but nothing more. (Analogy: the officer issues a citation for the original offense, but nothing more).
> 
> Or, if the officer has reasonable suspicion because of an inculpatory answer or external evidence, he may require a field sobriety test. This is a test that drivers, “even though they are legal,” can “expect to be treated like they aren’t.” The driver must stand at the side of the road and perform a series of physical steps at the command of the officer. You may be asked to take nine heel-to-toe steps forward, pivot, and then take nine heel-to-toe steps back to your starting point while counting out loud the number of steps that you have taken. You may have to raise one foot six inches off of the ground while keeping yours arms at your side, count out loud to 30, and then put your foot back down. You may be asked to watch the officer’s pen by moving your eyes while keeping your head still.
> 
> All of these are performed by the side of the road in full view of passing cars.
> 
> (The analogy to the Arizona law? Probably the brief detention while the officer attempts to confirm immigration status using the name, date of birth, and alien registration number if available.)

Now, consider the field sobriety test. As we said above, the officer asks, “have you been drinking,” suspect says, “yes.” The suspect is legally allowed to drive, but now must submit to a field sobriety test that is both lengthy and humiliating. We have created a sub-population that is always considered a suspected criminal. For the AZ law, the cop now as reasonable suspicion to verify that person’s immigrant status.

Here is a case you might understand: If officers were to set up near a Catholic Church on Sunday around 11am, stop cars for a valid reason, and then ask, “sir, have you had any wine today?” Do you see the way all good Catholics driving that morning would answer “yes” thereby giving reasonable suspicion. Do you see the way that might make the law seem like it’s targeting legal drivers who happen to be Catholic? Officers now have reasonable suspicion to perform a field sobriety test on what amounts to every Catholic on a Sunday morning.

Secondly, you mentioned the field sobriety test. A small portion of the population has a problem with their inner ear making it difficult for them to pass the field sobriety test. Imagine for a second if that group was about 30% of the population. By virtue of being unable to pass the field sobriety test, that 30% will be suspected criminals, leading to probable cause for arrest.

We were trying to find people that were drunk, instead we caught people with an inner ear problem. The problem with the AZ law, is that there are going to be a lot of people in the analogous group. People that are legal, but fail the initial screening by virtue of who they are\*\*\*.

> [@Bricker](#):
>
> If the results of the field sobriety tests show intoxication, then the officer has _probable cause_ to believe the driver is guilty of that offense. At this time, the officer will arrest the driver and transport him to jail. (The analogy: the officer receives words that the person is an immigration violator, and now has probable cause to arrest him).

True or false: It is possible to fail the field sobriety test while legally under the limit.

[Here](http://www.madrunkdrivingdefense.com/things.htm) are 8 ways, and [here](http://www.ehow.com/how_4392831_fail-field-sobriety-tests-sober.html) are 4 others. So again, let’s have an officer validly pulling people over near a retirement home for fat people seniors. Do you see the way the test designed to catch drunk drivers would instead catch fat old people? Granted, they would all be cleared of charges, but they all ended up giving _probable cause_ by virtue of their demographics.

> [@Bricker](#):
>
> If the results of the field sobriety test do not show intoxication, then the investigation is over, and the driver is free to go (after being cited for the original offense). (Analogy: If the immigration information shows no violation, or is not returned in a reasonable time, the person is free to go).
> 
> At the jail, the person is required to submit to a breathalyzer test, the result of which are admissible at his trial for DWI. (Analogy: transportation to ICE for processing and eventual determination of action).

So do you see now the way a field sobriety check could lead to the arrest of a lot of innocent drivers?

The very last problem with the AZ law is that those innocent people are going to be sent to ICE for detention. Do you understand what is involved with that process? What you described as “eventual determination of action.” As I said before, it takes immigration officials over an hour to verify my visa documents. It takes the DMV over 6 weeks.

Wow, that as a lot of typing on my part. I hope it had some effect. I hope you can see I’m not claiming that confession, alone, is all that’s needed in either case.

I’m not sure if you’re just stubborn, or if you have vast gaping holes in your understanding of how the immigration system works. Maybe this cleared a view things up.  
\*Assuming a normal human that can consume 1 beer and hour and stay below the legal limit of 0.08.

\*\*\*It is still unclear what follow up screening will be involved. What is the “field sobriety test” equivalent for the AZ law?

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![emacknight](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/e/3ec8ea/32.png) [@emacknight](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/emacknight)\
**Post date:** [August 3, 2010, 3:32pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/judge-blocks-arizona-show-me-your-papers-law/548345/429 "2010-08-03T15:32:10Z")

</div>

> [@Bricker](#):
>
> > [@emacknight](#):
> >
> > I would EXPECT voters to strike down a politician that proposes and passes a bill of such caliber. (and by strike down I mean vote against, nothing violent, just turning a phrase).
> 
> What’s your explanation for the overwhelming popularity of this bill, then? The voters don’t seem to be following your expectations.
> 
> Guess democracy is sacred… unless the voters are too stupid to know what’s best. Then they must be forced to comply.

Ah yes, legislating by popularity polls.

Voters are really fucking stupid, can we agree on that point? Shouldn’t we, as the intelligent elite, make at least a semblance of effort to route out the facts? To question the merits of a new law?

As you just said with Aaron Spelling, popularity produces shit, sweet delicious surgically enhanced and sickeningly profitable shit. So should we give up trying to create quality? Should we lie to the masses and tell them the WB (or the new CW) is all Shakespeare?

Why are you so quick to report on popularity of laws you like, and then disregard the popularity of bills you’re against?

The result has been a political party that is emulating Aaron Spelling. This law is nothing more than T and A for the likes of \*\*bull \*\*and **lonesome.** Hell ya this bill is popular, because it’s candy for the ill-informed. Is that what you as an intelligent conservative want?

Is now the correct time to point out the unpopularity of the civil rights movement? Or the unpopularity of ending slavery? Hell, let’s throw Goodwin on the pile and point out the popularity of Hitler.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Bricker](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/b/977dab/32.png) [@Bricker](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Bricker)\
**Post date:** [August 3, 2010, 3:40pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/judge-blocks-arizona-show-me-your-papers-law/548345/430 "2010-08-03T15:40:04Z")

</div>

> [@emacknight](#):
>
> > [@Bricker](#):
> >
> > What’s your explanation for the overwhelming popularity of this bill, then? The voters don’t seem to be following your expectations.
> > 
> > Guess democracy is sacred… unless the voters are too stupid to know what’s best. Then they must be forced to comply.
> 
> Ah yes, legislating by popularity polls.
> 
> Voters are really fucking stupid, can we agree on that point? Shouldn’t we, as the intelligent elite, make at least a semblance of effort to route out the facts? To question the merits of a new law?

Well, this law isn’t exactly legislating by polls. It was duly passed by the state’s elected representatives, and signed by the elected governor. The fact that the people ALSO overwhlemingly favor it simply rebuts any notion that it’s contrary to the wishes of the people.

Of course we can question the merits of a new law.

But honestly: don’t you see that your “questioning” here has involved repeated recitations of points answered and disproved over and over? This isn’t neutral questioning – it’s an agenda-driven fight marked by an unwillingness to even learn anything that contradicts your starting position.

> [@](#):
>
> As you just said with Aaron Spelling, popularity produces shit, sweet delicious surgically enhanced and sickeningly profitable shit. So should we give up trying to create quality? Should we lie to the masses and tell them the WB (or the new CW) is all Shakespeare?
> 
> Why are you so quick to report on popularity of laws you like, and then disregard the popularity of bills you’re against?

When have I disregarded the popularity of bills I’m against?

> [@](#):
>
> The result has been a political party that is emulating Aaron Spelling. This law is nothing more than T and A for the likes of \*\*bull \*\*and **lonesome.** Hell ya this bill is popular, because it’s candy for the ill-informed. Is that what you as an intelligent conservative want?
> 
> Is now the correct time to point out the unpopularity of the civil rights movement? Or the unpopularity of ending slavery? Hell, let’s throw Goodwin on the pile and point out the popularity of Hitler.

Candy for the ill-informed?!?

Your opposition to this bill isn’t based on anything factual, but mere speculation about what abuses might ensue if it’s put into effect. And  
you have been the one consistently offering up non-factual information here. In this very post I’m replying to: “Why are you so quick to report on popularity of laws you like, and then disregard the popularity of bills you’re against?” Is that based on anything factual? When have I done that?

But you felt free to toss it out as an attack, despite the total lack of any factual basis. Didn’t you?

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Bricker](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/b/977dab/32.png) [@Bricker](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Bricker)\
**Post date:** [August 3, 2010, 4:00pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/judge-blocks-arizona-show-me-your-papers-law/548345/431 "2010-08-03T16:00:55Z")

</div>

> [@emacknight](#):
>
> Notice that with a DUI there are other factors an officer can use to get reasonable suspicion? So both DUI and the AZ law involve a question, that may lead to self incrimination. Both could have a friend say, “dude just tell the truth.” Both could be known to the officer.
> 
> But the AZ law doesn’t have what we might consider “external clues.” Both groups could lie, “no i haven’t been drinking, yes I am a citizen.” In the first, the officer can find reasonable suspicion in other ways, in the second he doesn’t have any that are unique to this law. Does that make sense to you? All the reasonable suspicion examples you gave also be applied to DUIs, but the external clues for a DUI can’t be translated back to the AZ law.

Yes. But so what? Who cares? The officer in Arizona won’t have any external clues, no other way to develop reasonable suspicion. The officer investigating a DWI does.

So what?

> [@](#):
>
> It reminds me a lot of Rastafarians, who by virtue of their culture are suspected of being high and having pot. This is why a lot of people suspect that race/accent/appearance will be used as an external clue to provide reasonable suspicion.

I don’t care what “a lot of people suspect.” That’s not what the law allows. The law explictly forbids the use of race in developing reasonable suspicion. The officer has to explain his reasonable suspicion to a judge. He can’t just say to the judge, “Well, judge, the driver looked a little… you know…? Like that. So I detained him.”

What “a lot of people suspect” is bullshit, since these “lot of people” don’t seem to understand that reasonable suspicion must be supported by specific, articulable facts. If the officer can’t ARTICULATE those facts, the reasonable suspicion will not exist.

So what are “a lot of people” worried about?

> [@](#):
>
> Now, consider the field sobriety test. As we said above, the officer asks, “have you been drinking,” suspect says, “yes.” The suspect is legally allowed to drive, but now must submit to a field sobriety test that is both lengthy and humiliating. We have created a sub-population that is always considered a suspected criminal. For the AZ law, the cop now as reasonable suspicion to verify that person’s immigrant status.
> 
> Here is a case you might understand: If officers were to set up near a Catholic Church on Sunday around 11am, stop cars for a valid reason, and then ask, “sir, have you had any wine today?” Do you see the way all good Catholics driving that morning would answer “yes” thereby giving reasonable suspicion. Do you see the way that might make the law seem like it’s targeting legal drivers who happen to be Catholic? Officers now have reasonable suspicion to perform a field sobriety test on what amounts to every Catholic on a Sunday morning.

If the driver answers, “Only the tiny sip that comes with communion,” then no reasonable suspicion would exist. If the driver simply answered, “Yes,” then sure, the cop might have reasonable suspicion. And that’s fine. That’s the law.

> [@](#):
>
> Secondly, you mentioned the field sobriety test. A small portion of the population has a problem with their inner ear making it difficult for them to pass the field sobriety test. Imagine for a second if that group was about 30% of the population. By virtue of being unable to pass the field sobriety test, that 30% will be suspected criminals, leading to probable cause for arrest.
> 
> We were trying to find people that were drunk, instead we caught people with an inner ear problem. The problem with the AZ law, is that there are going to be a lot of people in the analogous group. People that are legal, but fail the initial screening by virtue of who they are\*\*\*.

So your theory is that this law will lead to unacceptably high numbers of false positives, but you can’t quite explain why you’re sure it will happen?

> [@](#):
>
> True or false: It is possible to fail the field sobriety test while legally under the limit.
> 
> [Here](http://www.madrunkdrivingdefense.com/things.htm) are 8 ways, and [here](http://www.ehow.com/how_4392831_fail-field-sobriety-tests-sober.html) are 4 others. So again, let’s have an officer validly pulling people over near a retirement home for fat people seniors. Do you see the way the test designed to catch drunk drivers would instead catch fat old people? Granted, they would all be cleared of charges, but they all ended up giving _probable cause_ by virtue of their demographics.

True. Absolutely true.

And what of it? The situation you describe is true, right now, in all fifty states and the District of Columbia. Yet no one is marching with a demand to repeal probable cause laws or field sobriety tests, despite the fact that they suffer from **precisely the same flaws you find abhorrent in the Arizona law**.

Why is that?

> [@](#):
>
> So do you see now the way a field sobriety check could lead to the arrest of a lot of innocent drivers?

Well… a lot of “not guilty” drivers.

No shit. The standard for arrest is “probable cause.” The standard for a criminal conviction is “beyond a reasonable doubt.” To get a conviction, you need much stronger evidence than you need for an arrest. So naturally, as a consequence of this, people will be arrested but ultimately not convicted, because the standard of proof required to arrest them is much lower than that required to convict them.

Again: the situation you describe is true, right now, in all fifty states and the District of Columbia. Yet no one is marching with a demand to repeal probable cause laws or ‘beyond a reasonable doubt’ standards, despite the fact that they suffer from **precisely the same flaws you find abhorrent in the Arizona law**.

> [@](#):
>
> It is still unclear what follow up screening will be involved. What is the “field sobriety test” equivalent for the AZ law?

A call to ICE for verification of immigration status.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![emacknight](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/e/3ec8ea/32.png) [@emacknight](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/emacknight)\
**Post date:** [August 3, 2010, 4:53pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/judge-blocks-arizona-show-me-your-papers-law/548345/432 "2010-08-03T16:53:46Z")

</div>

> [@Bricker](#):
>
> No shit. The standard for arrest is “probable cause.” The standard for a criminal conviction is “beyond a reasonable doubt.” To get a conviction, you need much stronger evidence than you need for an arrest. So naturally, as a consequence of this, people will be arrested but ultimately not convicted, because the standard of proof required to arrest them is much lower than that required to convict them.
> 
> Again: the situation you describe is true, right now, in all fifty states and the District of Columbia. Yet no one is marching with a demand to repeal probable cause laws or ‘beyond a reasonable doubt’ standards, despite the fact that they suffer from **precisely the same flaws you find abhorrent in the Arizona law**.

Are you aware of the sentencing discrepancy between crack cocaine and powder cocaine? Pres. Obama just [repealed](http://www.commondreams.org/newswire/2010/08/03-3) the the five-year mandatory minimum for simple possession of crack cocaine.

Do you see the way a “get tough on drugs” law was set up that targeted two groups? Rich white men use powder cocaine, poor black men use crack cocaine. So there is a case where a law was repealed.

Each aspect of the law was both popular and constitutional, but when applied it was incarcerating a higher number of blacks than whites for the same crime–possession of cocaine.

I’m not sure, but there may have been marching involved.

Can you understand now why I might suspect that this new law might target non-whites disproportionately more than whites?

> [@](#):
>
> It is still unclear what follow up screening will be involved. What is the “field sobriety test” equivalent for the AZ law?

A call to ICE for verification of immigration status.  
[/QUOTE]

So here is a question I assume you’ll dodge. Where in the process of a lawful stop does this phone call fit in?

Remember when you said that the stop can not last longer than the original purpose. You said that if it takes too long for the drug dogs to show up the guy gets to leave?

Legally speaking, how does this phone call to ICE fit into the process? You are aware that I am not a lawyer and I do not have experience as a public defender. So as a result I may incorrectly put this phone call into the wrong part of the arrest process.

1. Valid traffic stop
2. question about immigration
3. reasonable suspicion
4. phone call to ICE?

The issue here is: how long can that phone call take? Is there a limit to how long the suspect can be reasonably detained?

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Damuri\_Ajashi](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/d/898d66/32.png) [@Damuri\_Ajashi](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Damuri_Ajashi)\
**Post date:** [August 3, 2010, 5:41pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/judge-blocks-arizona-show-me-your-papers-law/548345/433 "2010-08-03T17:41:48Z")

</div>

> [@Eva\_Luna](#):
>
> > [@CannyDan](#):
> >
> > actions like those of Sheriff Arpiao and mindsets like that of our friend \*\*Lonesome \*\*still give me reason to suspect a likelihood of abuse. But we shall wait and see.
> 
> [Looks like the fun is starting already.](http://www.ccrjustice.org/newsroom/press-releases/ccr-attorney-legal-observer-arrested-arizona-immigration-protests)

Just for taking down names? Yikes. Please tell me there is more to this story.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Damuri\_Ajashi](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/d/898d66/32.png) [@Damuri\_Ajashi](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Damuri_Ajashi)\
**Post date:** [August 3, 2010, 5:44pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/judge-blocks-arizona-show-me-your-papers-law/548345/434 "2010-08-03T17:44:51Z")

</div>

> [@Unregistered\_Bull](#):
>
> And as long as the ethnic profilling law enforcement officers pull over enough Whites,Blacks, etc., then their ethnic profiling won’t even be determinable statistically. And I’m sure that District Attorneys will sell their souls in order to defend them.

Wait. What? So the profiling cop is not only profiling against hispanics, he is profiling against everyone else too, then how is it profiling? is it because he is pulling over rich black and white guys and poor hispanics?

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Zoomer](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/z/bbce88/32.png) [@Zoomer](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Zoomer)\
**Post date:** [August 3, 2010, 5:45pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/judge-blocks-arizona-show-me-your-papers-law/548345/435 "2010-08-03T17:45:27Z")

</div>

Emacknight,

I think there still may be some confusion here. I do not always explain myself clearly (although I am trying). My point in bringing up the entire Border Patrol tangent is that law enforcement is already using the interrogation techniques described. The Border Patrol routinely conduct interviews based either on reasonable suspicion or at stationary check-points. They do this throughout the US. They are legal and demonstrably successful.

> [@](#):
>
> [Border Patrol](http://www.usborderpatrol.com/Border_Patrol300.htm) Agents can operate anywhere within the United States – including Hawaii and Alaska and even Puerto Rico (in their vernacular it’s the Ramey Sector). You might not normally see Border Patrol Agents in Kansas but that sure doesn’t mean they aren’t there; they are.
> 
> If a Border Patrol Agent stops you, your actions and reactions to the Agent’s questions can and will determine how long and how involved the interview will be.
> 
> The Agent will stop you because he has “reasonable suspicion” that you-the-pedestrian or you-the-occupant-of-a-vehicle is an illegal alien or is involved in “criminal activity”. The Border Patrol Agent must notice that you are different from “innocent persons engaged in similar but legal behaviour.”
> 
> But to the Agent, his “reasonable suspicion” is the “sole authority” for your “detention.” To the Agent, “reasonable suspicion” may be engendered by:
> 
> - Suspicious behaviour
> - Unusual reaction to uniformed officers
> - Nervous demeanor
> - Corroborated tips
> - Citizen calls
> - The Agent’s experience regarding the time and place and traffic and area in which the suspicious activity has been observed.
> - Electronic detection of your presence (yes, they have thousands of sensors along the border).
> - Physical evidence linking the subject to illegal border crossing (bits of your shirt hanging on the border fence will do).
> 
> When a Border Patrol Agent has “reasonable suspicion” that you are an illegal alien or that you were or are engaged in “criminal activity” then he can “stop” you. This “detention” can last for a reasonable time while the Border Patrol Agent conducts a lawful “investigative activity” to quickly confirm or dispel their suspicion.

Note: These are far broader powers than are being proposed in the AZ legislation.

The Border Patrol is not the same thing as ICE, USCIS, or even customs. When you are hassled coming into the US at a port of entry it is not the Border Patrol you are dealing with.

Now, if it’s the USCIS or customs that you have an issue with, you’ll get no argument from me. Dealing with either is a horrible process and I will line up with you to argue for changes. The bureaucratic nightmare that is US immigration would make even Terry Gilliam sit up and take notice. Dealing with customs when returning to the US is definitely not a breeze. But, none of that has anything to do with the US Border Patrol or their enforcement stops.

One important distinction between the two is the amount of time allowed for a stop. Immigration and Customs can detain you for as long as they like (It is up to you to prove that you can legally enter the country as opposed to them proving that you cannot). With the Border Patrol (as with normal police), this detention may only last a “reasonable time”.

So, it seems to me that your issue these types of stops extend to the already lawful stops conducted by the US Border Patrol and as such the issue is more with immigration enforcement in general as opposed to the AZ law. If that is the case, that’s fine, but just say that. If it’s not the case then please explain the difference, because I’m not getting it (which is probably my fault).

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Damuri\_Ajashi](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/d/898d66/32.png) [@Damuri\_Ajashi](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Damuri_Ajashi)\
**Post date:** [August 3, 2010, 6:03pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/judge-blocks-arizona-show-me-your-papers-law/548345/436 "2010-08-03T18:03:12Z")

</div>

> [@Stratocaster](#):
>
> > [@emacknight](#):
> >
> > We already told you the answer to the first part: everyone that passes through a point of entry is suspected of illegal entry. It is on the onus of the person trying to enter the country to prove their identity and the legality of their residency. This goes for everyone including citizens.
> > 
> > Secondly, it is perfectly acceptable to be suspicious of a person running from the border. That is reasonable suspicion.
> 
> I’m not asking about border checks. That occurs, and it should. I would have thought it was clear I was asking about enforcement focusing on those already across the border, say those wandering around Arizona. Are the Feds’ hands tied? Could they have reasonable suspicion of an illegal alien in Phoenix, or is it only Arizona cops who would be unable to fashion such a conclusion?How is this materially different from doing so during a traffic stop, if reasonable suspicion existed?No. Were you under the impression I’d like the Feds randomly questioning people?
> 
> > [@](#):
> >
> > And since you are trying to slide one way down the slope, perhaps you’ll consider the other side to the slope: do you see a point where we have random check points throughout the country with armed guards asking, “show me your papers.”
> 
> I don’t know what slope you thinking I’m sliding down. I thought I was taking the counter position. But to answer your question–no, I don’t see that happening.

Haven’t we determined that reasonable suspicion almost never exists during a routine traffic stop once the illegal aliens know to say “I’m not going to answer that”

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Damuri\_Ajashi](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/d/898d66/32.png) [@Damuri\_Ajashi](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Damuri_Ajashi)\
**Post date:** [August 3, 2010, 6:10pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/judge-blocks-arizona-show-me-your-papers-law/548345/437 "2010-08-03T18:10:13Z")

</div>

> [@Bricker](#):
>
> > [@emacknight](#):
> >
> > **Bricker’s** solution was to **ask** people on the street, and then hope they incriminate themselves.
> > 
> > Do we see where we are going with this? What reasonable suspicion would the Feds have? Or are they just asking people at random and hoping they confess?
> > 
> > If they are just hoping for confessions, what’s the fucking point? How long would that be a successful program?
> 
> Please answer these two questions directly:
> 
> 1. Do you understand that a huge number of arrests happen every week because police ask a driver for consent to search, and he gives it, even though he doesn’t have to and even though he knows he has contraband hidden?
> 
> 2. Why do you believe that illegal immigrants will become savvy enough to simply assert their rights when all the civics classes and ACLU “Know Your Rights” pamphlets are ineffective in helping the people from question #1?
> 
> You’re incredulous that simply asking stopped drivers if they’re a citizen or legal resident will produce reasonable suspicion, but the proof that it wll is in the fact that the analogous questions to drug smugglers reliably produce arrests, even after years and years for the “word to get out.”

OK so your position is that this law is designed to catch the illegal aliens that are stupid enough to tell a cop that they are in fact illegal aliens?

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Damuri\_Ajashi](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/d/898d66/32.png) [@Damuri\_Ajashi](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Damuri_Ajashi)\
**Post date:** [August 3, 2010, 6:29pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/judge-blocks-arizona-show-me-your-papers-law/548345/438 "2010-08-03T18:29:53Z")

</div>

> [@emacknight](#):
>
> > [@Stratocaster](#):
> >
> > I’ll ignore the fact that you continue to assert there’s no possibility of reasonable suspicion, despite the examples provided, since it seems a lost cause. You apparently have a lot invested in this erroneous belief, so who am I to upset that particular apple cart for you.
> 
> Holy fuck, seriously, what is wrong with you?
> 
> I asked repeatedly about what constitutes reasonable suspicion. Are you talking about the three examples that \*\*Bricker \*\*posted? If so, all three involve an officer asking, and a person incriminating themselves.
> 
> Is that the only cause for reasonable suspicion? There is no apple cart, it is not an erroneous belief. Other than self incrimination, what reasonable suspicion is there?

I think his point is exactly that. This law will catch all the people who confess to being illegal aliens. Sure msot illegal aliens won’t confess but you might catch a few who slip up and say something that provides reasonable suspicion.

Its beena while since I took criminal procedure but many cases we read involved a relatively stupid criminal who gave the cops the rope to hang them with. Its not some vanishingly small number, if every illegal alien was as well informed as the people on this baord, sure it would be a vanishingly small number but do you really think the discussion among drug dealers about how to deal with traffic stops is any different tahn the converstaion that will occur among ilegal aliens on how to deal with traffic stops? And yet for some reason, drug dealers get nervous and let cops search their trunks anyways.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Bricker](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/b/977dab/32.png) [@Bricker](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Bricker)\
**Post date:** [August 3, 2010, 7:34pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/judge-blocks-arizona-show-me-your-papers-law/548345/439 "2010-08-03T19:34:47Z")

</div>

> [@Damuri\_Ajashi](#):
>
> OK so your position is that this law is designed to catch the illegal aliens that are stupid enough to tell a cop that they are in fact illegal aliens?

Yes. In much the same way the drug smugglers are largely caught because they’re stupid enough to tell a cop that they are drug smugglers, and felons in possession of firearms are largely caught because they are stupid enough to tell a cop that they are in possession of a firearm.

I can’t quite figure out what you’re getting at, though? Do you doubt the existence of the many drug smugglers and felons I mention? Do you believe that illegal aliens will be better versed in Fourth Amendment law? What?

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Bricker](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/b/977dab/32.png) [@Bricker](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Bricker)\
**Post date:** [August 3, 2010, 7:37pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/judge-blocks-arizona-show-me-your-papers-law/548345/440 "2010-08-03T19:37:14Z")

</div>

> [@Damuri\_Ajashi](#):
>
> Haven’t we determined that reasonable suspicion almost never exists during a routine traffic stop once the illegal aliens know to say “I’m not going to answer that”

Yes, that’s a true statement.

But I am confident that despite the undoubtedly massive effort, funded by liberals, that will ensue to get the word out to illegal aliens, it won’t be that successful, and many aliens will be caught in contradictions and confessions.

[Previous page](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/judge-blocks-arizona-show-me-your-papers-law/548345.md?page=21)

[Next page](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/judge-blocks-arizona-show-me-your-papers-law/548345.md?page=23)
