Finished a re-read of one of my favorite novels - Time and Again by Jack Finney.
Si Morley, an advertising illustrator who is living in the Big Apple & feeling somewhat unfulfilled in life, is approached by a mysterious man who asks him to commit to a secret project. Not having much else to look forward to (even his relationship is somewhat desultory), he agrees. The project, under the aegis of the US government, is time travel by means of self-hypnotism & surrounding one’s self with the artifacts of that time. A mystery in the life of his girlfriend’s adoptive parents gives him the impetus to travel to the New York of 1882.
The puzzle pieces that Finney puts together in this novel are amazing, with actual historical events fitting in almost seamlessly to the narrative, including sketches and photographs from the time. The unraveling of the mystery and the thrilling climax were as compelling on a re-read as the first time. As before, I found myself wondering just how much of the story was true. Finney does admit to changing some of the facts - the Dakota hotel (where Si does his “traveling”) wasn’t complete until 1885, for example. But other elements appear to be faithfully researched.
I’d recommend this novel to fans of time travel who also have an interest in the world of the turn of the 19th century.
Thoughts after my Jan 2015 reread:
The more I think about it, this is really historical fiction with a thin SF wrapper. The 1882 portion of the story is still as gripping as the first time I read it, and holds up very well - not only the world building, but the plot and characters; however, the modern day elements feel a bit dated. That said, the idea that (at least an element of) the military wants to weaponize time travel is probably just as valid now as it was in 1970.
Speaking of which, while I am fascinated by the time travel mechanism; it really doesn’t hold up, even in-universe.
We have the perennial question of what else besides the time traveler him/herself. Si’s clothing and pocket contents obviously travel with him; as do Kate’s clothing & belongings when she joins Si in an excursion to the past.
However… the 1882 version of the apartment in the Dakota was said to have been empty. Even if it were furnished, there’s no way the Project could have gotten all the replica/vintage furnishings right… so did everything in the apartment travel with Si as well? Otherwise, he would have known instantly upon coming out of the trance whether or not he had succeeded…
The return trip from 1882 makes a little more sense to me, as the interior of the Statue of Liberty has probably changed very little since 1882 (even if its location did) , but again, should Julia have actually been able to make the trip back, even tho Si makes a point of “holding her very close, making her as much a part of me as I was able”. ? I’m on the fence, myself… 