Little things about a Mac that are irritating

I truly love my MacBook Pro! I want no other machine. I would love to be able to use a Mac all day at work.

Well, since you asked…
[ul][li]Why the heck doesn’t the green widget maximize my window? I know that it’s supposed to size the window to fit content, but it behaves totally inconsistently across applications.[/li][li]Why does OSX have this beautiful brushed-metal theme, for some apps… Safari, for example, but then other apps such as Mail don’t match. Still others look like iTunes. Mac was synonymous with consistency; this doesn’t fit.[/li][li]Why the heck did I have to buy a text editor? TextEdit isn’t one – that’s like Wordpad. I just wanted something like Notepad, only a little better. I used vim for a while, since that’s my style, but I finally ended up buying TextMate.[/li][li]What’s up with QuickTime? MS gives away MediaPlayer, and it plays lots of stuff. You have to pay $30 to enable QuickTime Pro features if you want to see the darned thing in full-screen mode! Want MPEG2? Another $20 for that.[/li][li]I can’t watch many video formats – it seems that Windows Media Player can show them, but even with various bridge apps and such, QuickTime chokes on many media files.[/li][li]Once upon a time, AppleScript was one of the shining examples of consistency and extensibility of Macs – you could script amazing things. These days it’s sort of half-assed implemented, and it seems to not be getting the attention that other parts of the OS get.[/li][li]About scripting. What’s the right way to do it? I can write Unix scripts; I can write AppleScript; I can create Workflows, and there are probably half a dozen other ways to do a scripting job. At least the problem is too many rather than too few.[/li][li]Here’s a big one: Why the eff doesn’t my Mac seamlessly automount my network drives when I start it up? Windows does this perfectly! I have my MP3s on a Linux server running Samba. In Windows, the drive is available soon after boot. In Mac, unless I double-click the shortcut I made to the drive, iTunes will scream bloody murder. I have heard rumors that these drives can be automounted with great scripting and voodoo, but isn’t it supposed to “just work”?[/li][li]Why the heck did I have to buy a little tool called “Remote Buddy” just so that the included Apple Remote would actually do something useful? They went through great pains to make a beautiful little remote control, but it works with only a very limited number of apps. Remote Buddy is definitely worth the ten bucks.[/li][li]What about context help? When you are in a strange field in a property sheet in Windows, you can hit F1 and (hopefully) see some useful context help about that specific field. It just doesn’t exist on the Mac.[/li][li]In general, I find that the Mac help is less useful than comparable Windows help.[/li][li]What’s with all of the secret keyboard chords? You can do amazing things if you understand a list of magic key combinations that include “ctrl”, “option”, “command”, and perhaps “fn”.[/li][li]How about the other secret stuff: when I first brought it home, I had no clue how to find an application. No one told me that I have to either burrow down the folders or search for it in Spotlight.[/li][li]There is no such thing as installers/uninstallers for Mac, right? You just drag the “app” into your “applications folder” to install it and drag it to the trash to uninstall it. Here’s a dirty little secret: it’s a lie. Most apps work that way. Actually, most apps have an installer these days and can be dragged to the trash. I installed Divx, then wanted to remove it – I found out that I had to go chasing down individual codec files buried deeply in QuickTime folders. Not a clean uninstall. Other apps are like this.[/li][li]There doesn’t seem to be a clear-cut concept of “home” and “end” keys – it isn’t like Windows where you hit Home and the cursor goes to the beginning of the line; you hit End and it goes to the end of the line. At least on my MacBook Pro, I have to hit some strange combo of keys to do Home, End, Page up, Page down, or Top of doc (MS ctrl+home), Bottom of doc (MS ctrl+end).[/li][li]All Mac apps are not created the same: You got your basic Classic apps, then there are Carbon apps, then you find Cocoa apps, and then finally Universal apps. Each one means a different thing about what framework the app was written for. If you have old Classics, forget about using them on your fancy new Intel Mac.[/ul][/li]I’ll stop now. There’s more where that came from.

Here’s a few things I really like…
[ul][li]It’s running Unix! I can do great things from a command line![/li][li]The eye candy is cool. I like Exposé – if you hold Shift while hitting the hotkeys, you get to see it move in slow mo.[/li][li]Parallels is the dog’s bollocks! I think it’s totally awesome that I can drag a picture from my Mac desktop into a Parallels window with Photoshop running on XP, and Photoshop will open the picture. Gotta have Parallels.[/li][li]Spotlight is a zillion times better than anything I used in Windows.[/li][li]Macs talk PDF fluently. No Acrobat needed. A couple of weeks ago I made a simple workflow that would merge PDF docs – select ten in Finder, right-click, choose “Join PDF”[/li][li]When you print, you can print to PDF, out of the box. They even give an option to “Save to Web Receipts folder” so you can instantly print a web page to a PDF and store it, instead of printing it out.[/li][li]The Oxford Dictionary is built right into the OS: click on a word in any application and then press Ctrl+Command+D and you’ll see a popup with the definition.[/li][li]Dashboard is growing on me. I just hit a hotkey and it appears, with my selection of widgets. It goes away just as quickly.[/li]I shut it; it immediately goes to sleep. A little white LED throbs to show it’s alive. I open it; it wakes instantly, and may take a few seconds before the wireless connectivity is fully restored. Never seen that in a PC.[/ul]

In one week I am buying a MacBook Pro and this thread has just the kind of details I’d like to know about. Thanks!

Every OS has its annoyances. The only one that really bugs me about the Mac was mentioned in the OP–not being able to resize windows from the left or top. I get tired of making it a multi-step process: drag the window to where I want it, and then resize it. Oops - can’t make it quite wide enough. Drag a little farther left and resize again. sigh

Overall, though, I think the Mac is far ahead of Windows on UI. I much prefer OSX to Windows.

Yes, you can turn that off in the system preferences.

The standard has become multi-button now. Even the Macbooks have double buttons below the trackpads.

Looks neat, but they only report support up through Panther. I don’t see anything about Tiger support or binaries for the Intel hardware.

I’m using it under 10.4.9 right now. I actually use it more for MOVING windows from other than the titlebar than for RESIZING them from other than the right-corner widget (WindowDragon does both), but yes it works fine with Tiger. And people have reported that it works fine with Intel Macs.

Okay, this is both petty and quite possibly outdated since I haven’t touched a Mac in five years, but…do the CD drives come equipped with such modern bells and whistles as a frelling eject button yet?

I swear, the first time I ever tried to use a Mac, it took me a good thirty minutes to figure out how the hell to get my CD out of the drive. Turns out you had to click the icon for the drive (hey, at least there was no confusion over which button to use), drag it into the trash can, and release. Well, THAT’S certainly intuitive…not to mention the fact that my CD would become irretrievable should the OS decide to go on the fritz. The stupidity of that, combined with Apple’s stubborn and pointless refusal to add a second button to the mouse, pretty much ruined any chances the Mac had at making a good first impression with me.

Petty? Maybe, but when my reaction to two of the very first design elements I notice is “Wow, that’s pretty stupid”, it just doesn’t bode well for the overall package.

Who knows, though; maybe they’ve mended their ways…after all, they rectified the whole one-button thing a few years back. So, Mac-inclined Dopers, educate me: is the horror of “delete drive to eject” no more?

TextWrangler came free with my new iMac.

Dude, install the Developer Tools. The new Applescript Studio will blow you away!

Mix and match is what I do. I have Applescripts that call Unix scripts and vice versa.

Set your network volume alias as a “Startup Item”. ( it’s under the Accounts tab in Preferences)

You can still drag to the trash to eject, but there is an eject button on the keyboard as well.

They didn’t include it with mine. I looked at it, though – everyone swears up and down how great BBEdit is, and TextWrangler is BBEdit Lite. It seemed too HTML-centric for my taste. Anyway, it wasn’t included with the OS. Had they included it, I would retract my complaint.
The main gripe about the default text editor, TextEdit, is that it will open things in a rich text way if it can: drag an HTML file onto TextEdit and it will render it, rather than show you the HTML.

I’ll have to try it – you’re not the only one to tell me to install the Developer Tools. I know that the AppleScript editor that comes with the OS is the same darned thing they had on Macs ten years ago.

If only it were that simple. I tried that a few minutes ago, to verify my past failures, and it still didn’t work.

There is a more profound defect in this technique: it doesn’t “stick” if you close the laptop and reopen it. Come on, Apple, I have the same darned drives mounted in my XP installation in Parallels, on the exact same machine, and when I close the lid and reopen it four hours later, the OSX Finder connection is long gone, while the network drives mounted in Parallels just cough a little and then they are back in business.

Here’s a discussion about the fancy voodoo needed to get the network drives to really automount, and their techniques involve embedding passwords in urls and such. Shouldn’t it just work?

Well, I’ll give a shot.

I’ve got a G5, using OS 10.4.9.

I don’t have to power up or down too often, but when I do, I can’t *feel *the power button like I could with all my previous Macs. There’s that little white light, and you have to aim below it; but when the power’s off, you need a flashlight to find the button.

“View options”: I want ALL my windows to be exactly the same: List, no toolbar, showing date, size (including folders) and NO RELATIVE DATES!!! Why can’t I set this as the default? I never had this problem previous to OSX.

When I’m doing a “save as,” I want the new file to automatically go into the same folder as the original file, not the last folder I was in, and definitely not into a “documents” folder. This shouldn’t be application-dependent; it should be a system preference. I’ve been working on Macs for almost 20 years, and I have NEVER wanted a “save as” file to go into a different folder as the original.

When you open a window, the green resize button works correctly ONCE. Prior to OSX the resize button worked every time. Actually, there are lots of things that were better in OS9.

I’ve got my desktop arranged on a grid. If I’m moving something from a window to the desktop, I move it to an open spot on the grid. So why does it fly off to a different location, and I have to close all my windows and waste time looking for it? This is something really stupid and annoying. And why can’t I adjust the number of rows & columns on the desktop without changing the icon and text sizes?

There are certain things on my desktop that sometimes move to other locations. Especially Illustrator files and my iPod.

Sometimes I’m typing, and I have to wait till the monitor catches up with my fingers. I’m not a really fast typist, and it doesn’t seem to be application-dependent.

BRING BACK THE PAPER CLIP HOLE! Every so often, I have a cd or dvd that just won’t work and won’t eject, no matter what. Sometimes even restarting doesn’t eject, and the paperclip hole is exactly what I need. (For all you younguns: in older Macs, there was a tiny hole by the disk drive. When all else failed you could insert a straightened paperclip into the hole, and it popped the disk.) Sometimes low-tech is still the best solution.
And now for something I love:

My new 23" Apple monitor. It is so gorgeous, both the monitor itself and the screen. And finally a monitor with accurate, reliable colors!

I’m on my second keyboard with the G5; on both, the eject key stopped working.

Yeah, I stay away from TextEdit too. I’ve only played around with TextWrangler a little. If you’ve got the scratch, BBEdit is the way to go though. The coolest feature of BBEdit is the FTP open feature. It’s almost as good as directly editing on the remore machine. Has a great diff feature as well as regex searching.

Rest assured that Apple has not abandoned Applescript. It is a full-fledged member of the development suite installed with Developer Tools. Even if you just want to write command line tools, the XCode IDE has a lot to offer. I even found a Haskell plugin for it.

Hmm. I’ll be looking into that. I’ll have to admit that I haven’t tried the alias trick with the latest version of the OS.

While we are griping about Mac OS, I guess I’ll throw in my latest. In Developer Tools they included that latest and greatest version of CVS. Oddly enough, the latest and greatest CVS doesn’t support the cvswrappers that XCode needs to work properly. Thankfully, someone thought to include the older version of cvs, now called ‘/usr/bin/ocvs’. Getting CVS working now involves a bit of investigation and hair pulling until you’ve gotten all the incantations correct.

DefaultFolder was merely optional under MacOS 9; under OS X it’s indispensable.

www.stclairsoft.com

At school the Macs had a power button on the side of the monitor. I was forever accidentally pushing it when I would grab the edge of the monitor to shift it (either to turn it to show something to the person next to me, or to push it back so I could put my laptop in front of it or whatever. It was so annoying!

Yeah and it was really fun when I did the whole Bootcamp/Parallels/XP thing… you have to install it first then install the drivers… which makes it fun to deal with the XP disk before the drivers that make the eject button work have been installed.

If you have one of the dual core Intel machines and you aren’t doing extreme number crunching, I strongly recommend using Parallels instead of Bootcamp. It’s supposed to be 90% the speed of Bootcamp (since the instructions are being executed on hardware through Intel VM magic) – I can watch video in XP just fine. Since you are installing in a VM, XP thinks it has ordinary hardware and doesn’t need special Apple drivers (except, of course, for the toolset that allows copy/paste drag/drop between the OS’s). It’s pretty darned smooth.

Besides, it’s just too cool to hit Option-Return in front of folks and watch the machine completely transform from Mac to PC with the neat screen-rotating animation.

Of course, if I understood you correctly, you use OSX only under duress, and prefer to run XP the rest of the time. Bootcamp might be the way. It’s also the only way to go for gaming.

Well I use a lot of software that is very processor intensive (like multiple Adobe programs at once… say Illustrator and Photoshop, along with a bunch of other crap I’m doing) and I have literally no reason to be booting into OSX because I have no Mac software. The only thing I’d be doing on the mac side is surfing the internet, and I can run Firefox in XP just as easily as on the Mac side. Seems to me that unless I have a reason to need access to the Mac stuff, booting into it and running parallels is just using extra processor power for no reason whatsoever. (Also, I’ve had freezing up issues with Parallels, but never with Bootcamp)

I love my Mighty Mouse! It has 5 adaptable buttons.
The track ball does stick occasionally, but all you have to do is give it a little burst of air, heck, just blow on it, and it’s back. It sticks more if you mouse with dirty hands… :dubious:

I just don’t like the idea of a mouse in general. It requires a surface, etc. At work I’m always running into this problem: dragging a file to an application or to the trash, and SMACK the mouse runs into something, runs off of the edge of the table, etc and I can’t get the cursor to where it’s going. Plus on a Mac when I rest the weight of my hand on the mouse, I tend to accidentally click. (since I’m used to my trackball, I’m used to resting the weight of my hand there)

I don’t have room on my tray table at home for my laptop and a mouse anyway (and I hate hate hate hate hate touchpads. I disabled mine)

I tend to use the computer while at the couch, and I’ll have the trackball on the couch next to my leg. Or even under the throw blanket if it’s cold. Or if I need to stand up and do something, or show someone something, instead of standing in their way, hunched over trying to navigate around with the mouse on a surface, I can just hold the trackball against my leg and it works as well as always.

Not everybody likes trackballs, I know, but I don’t like anything but trackballs. And it has to be the kind with the big ball that you use with your fingers–the thumb trackballs suck.