Make a case for a MLB player for the Hall of Fame (excluding obvious steroid omissions.)

The prohibition against gambling isn’t because it’s immoral.

Clayton Kershaw (as with Cy Young) is a product of his era and his management. That’s why he can say that without much pushback.

I mean, we could say the same about Whitey Ford. Sure, he didn’t win a lot of games, and yes, he played for the Yankees, but Stengel only used him against high-caliber opponents, he was never in a rotation. How many would he have won in a regular 4-man rotation with that career winning percentage? How many would he have won had he been on the Washington Senators? Would the circulatory issues he had have shown up earlier in his career with more work?

And we could play that game with any player. Bob Feller lost years to WWII, Ted Williams lost years to WWII AND Korea and played for the Red Sox. Imagine if he switched places with DiMaggio.

So stats are helpful and certainly confirm greatness, but they aren’t the absolute bottom line. Some players pass the eye test, their greatness is obvious even if their accumulated stats are not. Kershaw is one of them.

Cy Young is irrelevant to the modern game. Kershaw was better, hands down.

He probably didn’t have a long enough career in most voters’ opinion. But I can make a case for Ken Boyer. !964 MVP, 11 All-Star games, 5 Gold Gloves, 62.8 WAR, team Captain. He’s overlooked for three reasons

  • He played for the Cardinals, which were mostlty overlooked by the national sportswriters, and he played there at the same time as Stan Musial who (deservedly!) got the lion’s share of attention and affection.
  • Cardinals management didn’t know what to do with him. In his first four seasons with the team, Boyer played shortstop and all three outfield positions (he led the league in fielding as a center fielder one year) before management finally put him at third base and kept him there. Despite being moved around those first four seasons, Boyer still averaged to bat over .300 for that period.
  • His career wasn’t as long as some would like. Although Boyer played 14 seasons, his last three season in particular were subpar. After being traded to the Mets he shuffled from them to the White Sox to the Dodgers. In his last three seasons he played in 218 games total.

But from 1959, when the Cardinals finally parked him at third base, through 1966, he was as good as any player in the game. Is seven great years enough for the HOF?

Bobby Grich is another interesting case.

71.1 bWAR and 69.1 fWar.

His offensive numbers don’t zing, but a career .371 OBP is nothing to sneeze at. I never know how to rate guys who were more dominant defensively than on the other side of the ball. He must have been one hell of a second baseman to put up those kind of numbers.

In short, I wouldn’t protest at all if one of the committees voted him in.

When we were in high school, in the late '70s/early '80s, a group of us played APBA Football and APBA Baseball, a pair of tabletop sports simulation games (similar to the now better-known Strat-o-Matic). There was only four of us, so we drafted all-star teams to play against one another, and in that era, Grich was nearly always somebody’s starting second baseman. So, he must have been pretty good, at least. :smiley:

Looking at his stats now, on Baseball Reference, but bearing in mind that awards were more subjective back then, before sabermetrics:

  • He won four straight Gold Gloves early in his career, when he was with the Orioles
  • He received MVP votes in five seasons, and was in the top 10 in voting twice
  • For a middle infielder in the '70s and '80s (the era of the spacious multi-purpose ballparks), he had a fair amount of power; he averaged 18 home runs a year, and in the strike-shortened 1981 season, he actually led the AL in HRs (at 22).
  • As you note, not necessarily a great batter, but his scores on bWAR, peak bWAR, bWAR/162, and JAWS all compare favorably with the average numbers for HoF second basemen.

Pete Rose. If for no other reason, I have his rookie baseball card (1963 Topps #537) and I could use the extra money the Hall of Fame would give it should I ever part with it.

But seriously, he was one of the greatest ball players ever in the game. And there are plenty of other amoral jerks in the HOF. What’s one more?

Rose will eternally be a polarizing figure in any of these discussions, whether or not he ever makes it into the Hall. To my mind, his repeated lying about his gambling involvement, and crocodile-tears remorse later on, generate zero sympathy to me. Rose was absolutely obsessed with setting the career hit record, and then equally obsessed with getting into the Hall.

Kenny Lofton. Even TheRinger made the case

As gross a person as he is, Curt Schilling. Nothing about his obnoxious nature seemed to hurt his contributions to baseball teams. He was an excellent pitcher and helped many teams win.

80 WAR, 3000+ strikeouts, 2.23 postseason ERA in 133 innings. The guy probably should have been a first ballot hall-of-famer. It’s funny that he’s had to wait, though, being such a massive prick.

I wonder when he’ll get his first shot via committee.