My story seems like some of those above, in that my father was a good father in the important ways, but I never felt particularly close to him. My father is very hard-working and disciplined. He grew up poor – he lived in a house without an indoor bathroom until he was a teenager, which seems mind-boggling to me. He was one of seven children living on a small rural farm. In later life, it’s occurred to me that I know almost nothing about his childhood, and looking back I suspect that it wasn’t a very warm or loving environment. His parents did not seem to value education, but despite this, he put himself through school, eventually earning a Ph.D.
He’s a virtuous person. I’ve never known him to lie, cheat, or steal. He rarely curses. He’s unfailingly polite. He’s very much a “play by the rules” kind of person. As a child I thought this made him boring, but the older I get the more I respect his virtues, and have to concede that in many ways he is my better.
He provided for our family very well. We weren’t wealthy, but we never had to go without anything we really needed, and he paid for all of our college educations.
However, we’ve never been close. We’re very different people. I was extremely shy, and he is fairly outgoing. He’s athletic, and I was terrible at sports as a child, and avoided them. I devoured books, and I never knew my dad to read a book for pleasure (he educated himself for career reasons, and displayed no intellectual curiosity that I could see). He is extremely pragmatic and practical, and I was an imaginative and fanciful child. My dad was not an emotionally demonstrative person with anyone, but when it came to me, I think he was just baffled. I could never escape the feeling that I wasn’t the kind of son he’d wanted. (He never said such a thing, and never would; we just seemed unable to connect.)
Some of these “lessons” have symbolic value that is hard to explain. My dad has Parkinson’s now, and is losing his fine motor skills. I was visiting a few months ago, and he was having trouble tying his necktie, so I helped him. He was standing in the bathroom in front of the mirror, and I was standing behind him, reaching around to tie his tie (because that’s the only way I can do it – it’s all muscle memory). Suddenly it hit me that this was the exact reversal of how my dad had taught me to to do this as a child; I was the one standing in front of the mirror, watching him reach around from behind and tie the tie. At that moment, I decided that I would always tie my ties in precisely this way (as opposed to other kinds of knots).