# Monty Hall

**URL:** <https://boards.straightdope.com/t/monty-hall/368152>\
**Category:** Cecil's Columns/Staff Reports\
**Created:** [August 10, 2006, 2:18pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/monty-hall/368152 "2006-08-10T14:18:18Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 13\
**Page:** 2

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Chronos](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/chronos/32/134_2.png) [@Chronos](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Chronos)\
**Post date:** [August 10, 2006, 7:24pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/monty-hall/368152/21 "2006-08-10T19:24:26Z")

</div>

> [@](#):
>
> The problem with the inumerable threads on this topic is that the underlying assumptions are typically not stated, not understood or people are fooled by complex but inherently flawed arguments.
> 
> If you start from a simple assumption, which in fact may be a requirement of game show fairness, Monty Hall has no more idea as to what is behind each panel than the contestant and the position of the good prize is random, the the following is true.
> 
> The odds are always 1/3.
> 
> The initial choice is 1 of 3 doors.
> 
> After choosing, the 2nd choice is often stated as “stay with your choice or choose one of the other two doors.” Of course, this is still (remember my assumption), choose one of 3, just stated differently.
> 
> You could be offered to change infinite times and the odds would not change so long as the randomness assumption remains and no door is opened between subsequent choices. Why??? Because NOTHING HAS CHANGED so the odds cannot change. Until something has changed, this remains a question of logic not math.
> 
> Now, if you put all sorts of other assumptions into play, the odds will change. But, I’ll leave others to argue the specific mathematics.

In this varient of the problem, you should also switch. If Monty opens a goat door, then it doesn’t matter at all whether you keep your own door or switch to the other unopened door. But if Monty opens the door with the new car, then you should absolutely switch, _to the door that Monty just opened_.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![crimsonkng](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/c/f19dbf/32.png) [@crimsonkng](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/crimsonkng)\
**Post date:** [August 10, 2006, 8:43pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/monty-hall/368152/22 "2006-08-10T20:43:56Z")

</div>

[http://math.ucsd.edu/~crypto/Monty/montybg.html](http://math.ucsd.edu/~crypto/Monty/montybg.html)

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![CandidGamera](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/candidgamera/32/2878_2.png) [@CandidGamera](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/CandidGamera)\
**Post date:** [August 10, 2006, 9:13pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/monty-hall/368152/23 "2006-08-10T21:13:09Z")

</div>

Hm. Thanks for the extra input.

I guess I’m having trouble because I’m conceptualizing it as two separate games… in the first game, you have three doors to pick from, and choose one. In the second game, you’re down to two doors to pick from, and choose one. That model doesn’t seem to apply.

Cecil’s brother and sister example likewise hurts my brain, because it’s conflicting with the fact that the gender of the first child doesn’t affect the gender of the second, if one were to predict the second child’s gender before birth.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![John\_W.Kennedy](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/john_w.kennedy/32/1031_2.png) [@John\_W.Kennedy](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/John_W.Kennedy)\
**Post date:** [August 10, 2006, 10:56pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/monty-hall/368152/24 "2006-08-10T22:56:02Z")

</div>

[QUOTE=CandidGamera]  
Cecil’s brother and sister example likewise hurts my brain, because it’s conflicting with the fact that the gender of the first child doesn’t affect the gender of the second, if one were to predict the second child’s gender before birth.  
[/QUOTE]  
No conflict. If the question is stated, “The eldest child is a girl,” then the odds are 50/50. It is only when the question is stated, “One child is a girl,” that it changes to 33/67.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![CandidGamera](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/candidgamera/32/2878_2.png) [@CandidGamera](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/CandidGamera)\
**Post date:** [August 11, 2006, 1:06am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/monty-hall/368152/25 "2006-08-11T01:06:55Z")

</div>

[QUOTE=John W. Kennedy]  
No conflict. If the question is stated, “The eldest child is a girl,” then the odds are 50/50. It is only when the question is stated, “One child is a girl,” that it changes to 33/67.  
[/QUOTE]

It’s conflicting IN MY BRAIN. 😉

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Chronos](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/chronos/32/134_2.png) [@Chronos](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Chronos)\
**Post date:** [August 11, 2006, 1:33am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/monty-hall/368152/26 "2006-08-11T01:33:52Z")

</div>

> [@](#):
>
> Cecil’s brother and sister example likewise hurts my brain, because it’s conflicting with the fact that the gender of the first child doesn’t affect the gender of the second, if one were to predict the second child’s gender before birth.

What do you mean, “the first child”? Presumably, you mean “the one we know is a girl”, but that’s not **a** child. If they happen to both be girls, then saying “the one that’s a girl” isn’t really saying anything.

That said, similar to the questions about Monty’s motivations (does he always open a door, or only when he feels like it?), it depends on how you get the information. The puzzle basically assumes that you asked “How many children do you have?”, and “Is at least one of them a girl?”, and that the answers you got were “two” and “yes”, respectively. But this is somewhat of a contrived way of gaining information, and it’s a lot easier to come up with plausible situations where you do find out about one of the kids in particular (in which case the answer is the intuitive 50-50).

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![PBear42](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/p/ecccb3/32.png) [@PBear42](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/PBear42)\
**Post date:** [August 11, 2006, 4:42am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/monty-hall/368152/27 "2006-08-11T04:42:37Z")

</div>

To recap, the key assumption in the problem is how often Monty opens another door. If he only does so when you’ve chosen the big prize, you should never switch. If he always opens another door, you should switch because you have twice as high a chance of winning (for the reasons stated above). If he opens another door, say, half the time, then **Stranger** is right, this ceases to be a probability problem and becomes instead a game theory problem.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Crafter\_Man](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/crafter_man/32/458_2.png) [@Crafter\_Man](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Crafter_Man)\
**Post date:** [August 11, 2006, 12:44pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/monty-hall/368152/28 "2006-08-11T12:44:18Z")

</div>

To recap:

In the classic Monty Hall game, where Monty opens one of the other doors (after you pick a door), **your chance of winning the prize is 2/3 if you switch**. Your chance of winning is 1/3 if you do _not_ switch. This is a fact.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![CandidGamera](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/candidgamera/32/2878_2.png) [@CandidGamera](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/CandidGamera)\
**Post date:** [August 11, 2006, 8:34pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/monty-hall/368152/29 "2006-08-11T20:34:38Z")

</div>

[QUOTE=Crafter\_Man]  
To recap:

In the classic Monty Hall game, where Monty opens one of the other doors (after you pick a door), **your chance of winning the prize is 2/3 if you switch**. Your chance of winning is 1/3 if you do _not_ switch. This is a fact.  
[/QUOTE]

To recap : **I can read.** What I was asking about was reconciling the truth with the more intuitive answer.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![CandidGamera](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/candidgamera/32/2878_2.png) [@CandidGamera](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/CandidGamera)\
**Post date:** [August 11, 2006, 8:35pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/monty-hall/368152/30 "2006-08-11T20:35:50Z")

</div>

[QUOTE=Chronos]  
What do you mean, “the first child”? Presumably, you mean “the one we know is a girl”, but that’s not **a** child. If they happen to both be girls, then saying “the one that’s a girl” isn’t really saying anything.  
[/QUOTE]

The generic “first child” of a couple who has two children. Its gender does not have any effect on the probability of the gender of the second child.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![CandidGamera](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/candidgamera/32/2878_2.png) [@CandidGamera](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/CandidGamera)\
**Post date:** [August 11, 2006, 8:59pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/monty-hall/368152/31 "2006-08-11T20:59:16Z")

</div>

Ah, I tumbled to it, finally, from seeing the parallel thread : [Boy/Girl probability in Monty Hall - Cecil's Columns/Staff Reports - Straight Dope Message Board](http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?t=383492)

An already-born child getting a sibling has a 50% chance of either gender… and yet, if we know the gender of one child, we can predict the other with 66% probability… _because in the first case I implicitly know the birth order of the children, and in the second, I do not._

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Stranger\_On\_A\_Train](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/s/13edae/32.png) [@Stranger\_On\_A\_Train](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Stranger_On_A_Train)\
**Post date:** [August 11, 2006, 9:04pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/monty-hall/368152/32 "2006-08-11T21:04:59Z")

</div>

[QUOTE=CandidGamera]  
I guess I’m having trouble because I’m conceptualizing it as two separate games.. in the first game, you have three doors to pick from, and choose one. In the second game, you’re down to two doors to pick from, and choose one. That model doesn’t seem to apply.  
[/quote]  
Think of it this way; in the first round, you get to pick from three doors. In the second, you get to pick from a group of one door (#1, your original pick), or a group of two doors (#2 and #3, one of which Monty has already opened to display a goat). Going with the second group results in (effectively) getting to open two doors; hence, 2/3 likelyhood of success. (This isn’t the case when sticking with Door #1 because you still have the same probability that you started with – 1/3.)

Or think if it this way; if Monty didn’t open a door, when you switch you’d have a 1/3 chance of selecting the wrong door. By opening, say Door #2 with the goat, Monty has prevented you from switching to the _wrong_ door; therefore, he gives you the chance to switch, but (assuming that the gold isn’t behind #1) not to make the wrong choice; effectively, you get to open both #2 and #3 without being penalized.

> [@CandidGamera](#):
>
> Cecil’s brother and sister example likewise hurts my brain, because it’s conflicting with the fact that the gender of the first child doesn’t affect the gender of the second, if one were to predict the second child’s gender before birth.

You are correct; the gender of one particular child doesn’t affect the gender of another, and the knowledge limits the number of [permutations](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Permutation) to 2, giving a 1/2 chance, i.e. if the younger child is female, it has no effect on whether the older child is male or female; the chance is 1/2 either way. However, if you only know that one of the children is female, this limits the number of permutations; out of the four possibilties (MM, MF, FM, FF) you have to eliminate the MM permutation, leaving three other choices of equal probability, and giving a 2/3 preference to a MF [combination](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Combinations) of children. Since our answer in the latter case is only concerned with the combinations, not the order, MF and FM have an equal likelyhood with FF.

Does that help?

Stranger

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![wolf\_meister](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/wolf_meister/32/15202_2.png) [@wolf\_meister](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/wolf_meister)\
**Post date:** [August 11, 2006, 9:09pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/monty-hall/368152/33 "2006-08-11T21:09:06Z")

</div>

Of all the explanations of the Monty Hall probelem, I think **borschevsky** ’s is the clearest. So, I’ll expand on it to muddy up the situation. 🙂

Seriously, let’s approach it from the car’s perspective.

The **car is equally likley to be behind door 1, 2 or 3**. (p=1/3 for each)  
So there are only 3 possible situations **if you pick (for example) door #1**.

Situation A  
**Car behind door 1** - you switch and **_always_ loose**. (Happens 1/3 of the time)

Situation B  
**Car behind door 2** - you switch and **_always_ win**. (Car is behind an unchosen door and Monty can _only_ pick door #3) (Happens 1/3 of the time).

Situation C  
**Car behind door 3** - you switch and **_always_ win**. (see above) (Happens 1/3 of the time).

Adding up the probabilities, we see that by _always_ switching, you win 2/3 of the time and loose only 1/3 of the time.

[Previous page](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/monty-hall/368152.md?page=1)
