Mother and 4 year-old walk off subway platform-why?

My eyesight is terrible – nearsighted in the extreme. But I could see the difference between open and closed at that range – and if I couldn’t, I wouldn’t walk that fast, because I’d already be on crutches from walking into things.

Furthermore people do not walk at trains and hope they happen to be lined up with an open door. They look for the door, and determine whether it is open, and adjust their course accordingly.

I don’t find it even remotely plausible that she thought she was boarding the train.

Vacationing currently in Boston and I took the Blue and Orange lines just yesterday - and yes, you do head for closed doors of trains. Because you’re expecting it’ll open shortly and let you in.

There are doors on her side of the train, they just aren’t open. Trains actually enter the station with their doors closed. And then, after coming to a full stop and – after sometimes waiting with doors closed for no reason – the doors open. I go down onto the platform, and the train doors are closed, I don’t immediately assume there’s a problem. It’s a normal circumstance.

People hurrying for the train do not in fact wait to see if the train will open its doors – generally speaking the doors can be expected to open. Moreover, the people who were poised by those closed doors get the best seats, or the only seats if few are available. It actually makes complete sense to hurry towards closed subway doors, especially if you are burdened and would really like a seat.

I watched the video before I read the text of the linked article, or any of the replies to this thread, and my immediate impression was “she was rushing to catch the train that was actually on the opposite platform”. I don’t see what the problem is with that explanation.

I don’t think she misjudged the distance to the train - I assume she is not familiar with that station and thought that platform was wider, and that by the time she had crossed the few feet to the train (which unfortunately consisted of a gap and some tracks) the doors would be opening for her. I think she had clocked the train standing there while she was held up at the barrier (getting a ticket passed to her or something?) so when she turned round she just dashed for the train and fell.

Maybe she thought the doors had already shut but she might be able to open them again? I’m not familiar with the system in question - do they have a door open button or is it fully automated?

He wasn’t even close to touching the second rail, let alone the third one.

But you slow down or stop to allow them to open. You do not go right off the platform at speed into a closed door.

That’s what I said.

They absolutely do wait to see if they open before plunging into them.

If you guys are trying to say that she thought the doors would open exactly as she crossed the edge of the platform without breaking stride, well, I did allow for her to be a dumbass in my first remark, so in that case we’re in agreement.

I’ve been taking DC Metro for years, and while people do rush toward doors, they never, ever do so with the intent of passing through them at high speed when they’re closed. Because slamming into metal hurts.

Except for the occasional dumbass.

I’m not going to bend over backward to accommodate this woman’s excuse. Yes, she was trying to board the train, because she’s a fucking moron not paying attention to her surroundings.

Is it not at all plausible that she saw how far away the train was, but did not factor in that the edge of the platform was a lot closer?

She was rushing to the doors. She thought there was platform all the way to the door. If there were a platform floor there, she would have plenty of time to stop before reaching the doors.

Right. She couldn’t see her feet and as stated by Boston Dopers, the platform is more narrow than the standard T platform. She didn’t think she was stepping off the platform onto the train – she thought she had more platform still to go.

[del]Brain[/del] Train fart.

This right here. Rushing up to wait outside the train doors.

There isn’t a “standard” T platform. The Red, like all the others, was built in chunks; the line from downtown Boston out to Cambridge terminated at Harvard until the mid-1980s, when they built a newer, larger station under Harvard Square and added the northern branch going out through Porter, Davis, and Alewife. (The natives consider things beyond Alewife to be outside the immediate solar system, and speak of them only in hushed, secretive tones.) Harvard and Porter have split platforms, with the lower level outbound and the upper level inbound. The rest of the new stations have island platforms, where the tracks bracket the waiting area. Central and Kendall are split platforms on either side of the tracks, where inbound is accessed from one side of the street and outbound from the other; they’re obnoxiously narrow and if you wind up on the wrong side, the only way to get to the right one is to go all the way back up to street level, try not to get pasted by one of the infamous Cambridge drivers, and go all the way back down through fare control on the other side.

As Ferret Herder says, it’s customary here to plow right up to the doors of the stopped train and plant yourself until they open. Bostonians, shockingly, do actually wait until people have disembarked before boarding. It only took me a couple of months here to spot the tourists, especially the New Yorkers and the Europeans, because they tend to make like the train will leave without them if they don’t jet through the doors the instant they open. The doors are semi-automatic, I think; there’s a safety mechanism of some kind that prevents them from opening until the entire train has come alongside the platform, but they’re under control of the driver. Usually there’s a T employee at the non-driving end of the train with a flashlight signalling the control cab that everyone’s aboard. There’s also a large angled mirror at the forward end of most platforms, so that the driver can see back along the length of the train. The drivers are surprisingly nice about this – they can and will re-open the doors for you if you sprint at them from the fare gate in a suitably desperate fashion.

It’s unusual, but it is mechanically possible for the driver to open the doors on both sides of the train; the only station I’m aware of where they do this is Park Street Under, which as it happens is on the Red Line. They open the outboard doors first, then a few seconds later trigger the doors for the island in the middle.

As for why she did it, I can personally attest that an awful lot of people on the T are operating strictly on hive-mind autopilot. I’m pretty sure you could walk naked through Park Street and maybe the buskers would notice. It’s not like NYC, where there are a number of different transit grids all sort of interlocked; Boston subways operate on a sort of hub-and-spoke model, and for the most part you just plant it on the train until you get where you’re going or hit downtown and change for a different color. A southbound train from Kendall is heading across the Charles and into downtown Boston.

I missed chizzuk’s comment before – having moved here from Arizona, I have to say that the people in Massachusetts take the whole “commonwealth” thing very seriously. I’ve had random strangers and T employees ask me if I was okay while I was crawling onto the Red to get my sorry germ-ridden tuchus home from work before I fell over. Someone pitched off the subway platform, people would charge over to help.