TWDuke
May 15, 2008, 1:16am
41
But Frodo and “the Eye” see each other several times. Frodo even hears a voice say “I see you” in the tavern.
Not sure how it worked in the movie, but in the book I think if Sauron actually did see Frodo at any point–not just being vaguely aware of him–Frodo would have been toast.
CalMeacham:
Mty mistake. For some reason I thought The Four Feathers (no version of which I’ve seen) was set elsewhere.
The Four Feathers (2002 film) - Wikipedia
Actually, it depends on the version:
The story is rich in characters and sub-plots,which the filmed versions perforce trim, along with making major changes in the story line, with the best known 1939 version centered on the 1898 campaign and battle of Omdurman, only hinted as a future event in the novel.
<snip>
This novel’s story has been filmed several times with all films retaining much of the same storyline (i.e. young Feversham disgracing himself by quitting the army followed by his redemption of manhood by various deeds in the Sudan).The enemy forces, Islamic rebels called Dervishes, of The Mahdi, are the same, as are the geographic settings, England, Egypt and the Sudan). The films also feature a British square broken, only mentioned in the novel in a battle in which the square recovered. The various film versions differ in the precise historical context. For example, the celebrated 1939 cinematic version, produced by Alexander Korda and Ralph Richardson its chief star, takes place during the 1898 campaign, with its climax the Battle of Omdurman when British soldiers wore khaki uniforms. The more recent 2002 version with Heath Ledger takes place during the 1884-1885 campaign, when some British still wore red coats and when some of the novel’s action occurs, and features the Battle of Abu Klea, January 17, 1885, fought by the Desert Column that included the Camel Corps dressed in gray jackets and khaki trousers, but not in red coats. While the square was briefly broken, unlike the movie version, the British won the battle, but their advance was delayed. The battle is more accurately treated in the movie “Khartoum” (1966). In the 1929 silent version of “Four Feathers”, a square of Highlanders is broken, but saved by Feversham and the Egyptian garrison of a besieged fort. Set in the 1880s, its great moment comes when wild hippos in a river attack the Dervishes pursuing Feversham. The many versions also differ in the racial ethnicity of the local Sudanese guide, Abou Fatma, who assists young Feversham in his desert adventure. For instance, this local guide is an Arab man in the 1977 version while he is a Black man in the 2002 version.
But in none of them does Feversham meet or face the Mahdi.