Actually, the pet food recalls concerned mostly WET dog and cat foods, not dry. While some dry foods were recalled they were only a small minority of the items/brands affected (which did not, of course, make the owners of sick or dead pets feel any better).
Menu Foods of Ontario, Canada was where most (but not all) of the contaminated food came from in North America, but it would be a mistake to assume all affected pet food came from one factory. It was a world-wide problem, and linked to contaminated batches of gluten derived from wheat, rice, and corn (most of the corn gluten going to South Africa, for instance) Menu Foods did (and still does) produce pet food products for something like 100 brands in North America.
Eukanuba had Menu Foods of Ontario produce their wet dog food products, but the dry Eukanuba was manufactured separately, thus, only some of their brand was affected, not all of it.
I also understand that these “premium” brands were all implicated in the pet poisoning scandal of a year or two ago in which they were shown to cause the death of thousands of dogs and cats through induced kidney and liver damage.
As I pointed out, only some products were affected. It was by no means all product lines of these companies.
This fatal damage was caused by Melamine having been added to the food in an effort to boost the apparent protein content of the food.
Which was done by the gluten producers in China, not the pet food manufacturers, which is why melamine contamination was found in human food as well.
When the scandal broke in the USA, these products apparently had their formulation changed.
Yes. There was a recall and the factory switched to different suppliers.
However, I saw a recent news report which stated that these Melamine contaminated products are still sold in places like Australia and New Zealand where they routinely kill dogs and cats.
Yes - because the problem was by no means limited to North America. The contaminated gluten products were shipped to companies around the world.
As an addendum to the above post, I have found the following link regarding a recall of Eukanuba pet foods in Australia.
http://www.eukanuba.com.au/en-AU/product-recall.html
Note that it says this pet food is manufactured in the USA; so why is it being recalled in Australia and not the USA?
Also, I note that they are not explicitly stating why the food is being recalled. Is it due to the Melamine contamination that has been reported in Australia?
If it is true that the “premium” brands are all really the same stuff, but rebranded, why is only Eukanuba being recalled?
If the factory involved in the recall is actually in the USA then it’s not the same factory involved in the 2008 recall, which was located in Canada.
Note that this recall is concerning DRY foods, as opposed to the WET foods in the melamine contamination. It’s not the same factory. As I also noted, Eukanuba has it’s own factory for dry food so it’s NOT taken out of some massive factory churning out food for dozens of companies and rebranding it, it’s a factory that produces food only for Eukanuba. Hence, other brands are not affected.
As to why the food is being recalled - news reports in the US indicate that something went awry at the factory and bagged pet food was released for shipping and sale without being fully inspected as required by company rules. The concern is not melamine but possible salmonella contamination. No illnesses have been reported as of early September, this is really being done as a precautionary measure and has nothing to do with melamine.
By the way - the food was also recalled in the US