OK, on further review I should not have conflated those parties. Hadash is very emphatically in favor of two states, but my claim that Ta’al shares that position was based on an Wikipedia article which doesn’t cite a source.
In an image that indicated officials were on the same page, the head of Israel’s elections committee was shown sitting between Israel’s attorney general and the head of the Shin Bet intelligence service for a statement making clear that even if claims of foreign interference raised last week are substantiated, the vote would stand.
Netanyahu’s Likud party has said, without giving evidence, that Arab-led parties “stole” the elections in which Netanyahu’s bloc lost its majority of seats in parliament. By casting doubt on the vote, Netanyahu appears to be trying to block any potential alliance in the opposition with the Arab parties that could force him from office.
Let us hope Netanyahu is gone. You know if someone changed Netanyahu to trump, and Likud to Republican, etc, this would pass as a US story.
Trump in an interview on Fox News has apparently said that he’s ending aid to Israel after a discussion with Netanyahu where Trump claims Netanyahu told him Israel doesn’t need the aid anymore.
I don’t have an English link, but I’m sure someone can provide one, or Google translate can be used.
Since US involvement was the only reason that this topic got a disproportionate amount of attention and it had absolutely nothing at all to do with antisemitism, I expect that public discourse will now move on to the much more devastating conflict in Sudan. And that pigs will fly through rainbows while unicorns prance below.
The fact is that Netanyahu has been talking about this for a while now. The chump change Israel gets from America is a tiny fraction of the IDF’s budget, and Netanyahu’s coalition had begun to view US aid as an albatross that limits their actions rather than a benefit. Once again, this is a horseshoe policy. The Ben Gvirs and the Smotriches celebrate this decision no less than anti-Israel voices in the US.
WASHINGTON, Nov 3 (Reuters) - US President Donald Trump on Tuesday said he made a deal with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu that Washington would stop $4 billion in funding to Israel after the end of this year, but will still sell weapons to its close Middle East ally.
Speaking as US voters headed to the polls for midterm elections that will decide who controls Congress, Trump did not provide details and it was not immediately clear which funding he meant. He also did not explain how the funding would be stopped at the end of the year, given that the Memorandum of Understanding that provides $3.8 billion in US military aid to Israel each year does not expire until September 2028.
Oh, is that money coming out of Trump’s pocket? As I currently do not believe anything that he says, I have trouble believing that he can unilaterally make such a call. But then again, I don’t believe anything he says.
Per Google AI, Israel has spent $121 billion on its military since 10/7, and has received about $21 billion in US aid. So, about a sixth of their military budget. That’s not counting the money the US has spent fighting Israel’s war with Iran for it, much of which has been spent shooting down Iranian missiles aimed at Israel.
So, yeah, hard to imagine losing US aid wouldn’t force them to adopt a somewhat less aggressive stance toward their neighbors.
It seems to me that the truth is exactly the opposite. Limiting aggression is a luxury Israel can take because it has a much stronger military than its aggressive neighbors. If that luxury is removed, you can’t just sit back and rely on your advanced defences to protect you; it’s much more cost efficient to strike hard and fast and completely remove the enemy’s ability to attack you.
I don’t think there will be any issue with affording munitions and bombs. What could be in shorter supply is advanced and expensive interceptors like Iron Dome.
The big difference between the genocide happening in Sudan and the genocide being committed by Israel in Gaza is that nobody here on these boards is defending what is happening in Sudan. There is nothing to debate.
But this thread is about Israel, Gaza, and the West Bank. If people don’t want to discuss these topics, there are plenty of other threads they can participate in. I don’t see why we should have to stop this dicussion. That doesn’t make any sense.
And the reality is that things are still at a crisis point in Gaza and the West Bank. So of course we should keep on discussing it.
Except the big ticket item in US aid is Anti-missile defenses, which are purely defensive and protect innocent civilians from terror missile attacks.
Israel’s Military Budget is $48 Billion, with us military aid to Israel $3.3 Billion. So, no, not a sixth More like 10%, of which say half is the Anti-Missile, so in reality 5%, so the IDF could easily continue programs in Gaza without military aid.
…today the official Israel Twitter account posted this:
There is something seriously pathological at play here. Because if you don’t know, this is what is happening today in Gaza.
The problem:
Bolding mine.
No, Israel does not control the weather.
They do control the borders. And they have made the decision to firstly continue to heavily restrict aid and supplies from getting into Gaza and secondly to gaslight and make a joke about their responsibilities as the occupying power.
I don’t know how people can possibly still defend Israel’s conduct here. But this is indefensible.
The IDF gunned down “terrorists” who “intended to throw stones”. The IDF admitted this openly, as if automatic gunfire is the appropriate response to stone throwing (or even “intended” stone throwing, apparently), at the same time that the IDF is directly aiding and abetting terrorist settler violence.
The IDF is showing itself, once again, to be a murderous, supremacist organization. They are no better, and we shouldn’t treat them any better, than Hamas or the Iranian revolutionary guard.
It really is amazing that the IDF openly admits shooting people because they believe they “intended to throw stones”. Imagine what they’re doing that they’re not willing to admit!
Practically speaking, how can you proscribe a foreign official military organization, that you are not at war with? I suppose you can call off joint ops (see: Iran).
Stop funding them, denounce them publicly, sanction them and those doing business with them, declare they are a terrorist organization, at least to begin with.
IDF kills a journalist that worked for the Australian Broadcast Corporation, then declares he was Hamas, but when ABC asks for evidence, they refuse to provide it: