New discussion thread for Israel/Gaza/West Bank (Hijacks tolerated)

It hasn’t been “their property” or “their own land” since 1967.

You don’t believe Palestinians in the West Bank have the right to own houses, vehicles, home furnishings, farm equipment, livestock, etc.?

But you still didn’t answer. Do you believe Palestinian civilians in the West Bank have the right to defend their property against violent settler terrorists?

Do you believe IDF soldiers should be actively defending settlers while they terrorize Palestinian civilians on their own land?

I believe Israel has the right to decide what the law is within the territory it governs.

Do you believe Palestinian civilians in the West Bank have the right to own houses, vehicles, home furnishings, farm equipment, livestock, etc.?

Do you believe Palestinian civilians in the West Bank have the right to defend their property against violent settler terrorists?

Do you believe IDF soldiers should be actively defending settlers while they terrorize Palestinian civilians on their own land?

I believe the West Bank is under a state of military occupation, and as the occupying power Israel has the authority to decide what rights the persons subject to its authority are entitled to.

Still not answering. What is it about these questions that you you find frightening or difficult to answer? Here they are again:

Do you believe Palestinian civilians in the West Bank have the right to own houses, vehicles, home furnishings, farm equipment, livestock, etc.?

Do you believe Palestinian civilians in the West Bank have the right to defend their property against violent settler terrorists?

Do you believe IDF soldiers should be actively defending settlers while they terrorize Palestinian civilians on their own land?

No, no, and yes.

Do you believe Palestinian civilians in the West Bank have the right to their lives?

As long as they’re not attempting to kill Israelis, sure.

But you said:

Doesn’t that mean their right to their lives (or not) is determined by Israel? So you’re okay that Israel sometimes decides they don’t have the right to their lives, like if they’re standing near stones, or on land that settlers want, or something like that?

From a practical standpoint, yes. From a moral standpoint, I don’t believe anyone should be killed if they’re not currently posing a threat.

But you think it’s okay if settlers and IDF members attack them, and then kill them if they’re angry about being attacked while standing near stones?

I think a stone is a deadly weapon if used correctly and the IDF are under no obligation to allow themselves to be killed.

So just to be extra clear, you think it’s okay if settlers and IDF members attack them, and then kill them if they’re angry about being attacked while standing near stones?

I think you shouldn’t bring a stone to a gunfight.

Is that a yes or a no?

I said what I said.

Is it wise to use stones to attack people armed with automatic weapons?

So this is another scary or difficult question for you. It sounds like you are unwilling to answer the question straight.

I’ve answered the question. What you do with that is up to you.

Is it wise to use stones to attack people armed with automatic weapons?

No you didn’t. Here’s the question, again - it’s a yes or no question:

Do you think it’s okay if settlers and IDF members attack Palestinian civilians in their homes, and then kill them if they’re angry about being attacked while standing near stones?