Payroll and playoffs in MLB

No, because the majority of those players will never reach the Major Leagues and the surefire AAA prospects are at least two years away.

Okay, playoffs are set, let’s see what we have. Rereading the thread to see what the claims were – great read, btw – I see that my stated hypothesis was this:

“I would suggest that on opening day, if your team’s payroll is in the top half of the league, your team has a significantly better chance of making the playoffs than those in the bottom half.”

2008 opening day payrolls.


1  $209,081,579  New York Yankees
2  $138,685,197  Detroit Tigers
3  $138,293,378  New York Mets
4  $133,440,037  Boston Red Sox
5  $121,152,667  Chicago White Sox
6  $119,216,333  Los Angeles Angels
7  $118,595,833  Chicago Cubs
8  $118,536,038  Los Angeles Dodgers
9  $117,993,982  Seattle Mariners
10 $102,424,018  Atlanta Braves
11 $100,624,450  St. Louis Cardinals
12  $98,641,957  Toronto Blue Jays
13  $98,269,881  Philadelphia Phillies
14  $88,930,415  Houston Astros
15  $81,004,167  Milwaukee Brewers

16  $78,970,067  Cleveland Indians
17  $76,904,500  San Francisco Giants
18  $74,277,695  Cincinnati Reds
19  $73,677,617  San Diego Padres
20  $68,655,500  Colorado Rockies
21  $68,239,551  Texas Rangers
22  $67,196,248  Baltimore Orioles
23  $66,202,713  Arizona Diamondbacks
24  $62,182,767  Minnesota Twins
25  $58,245,500  Kansas City Royals
26  $54,961,000  Washington Nationals
27  $49,365,283  Pittsburgh Pirates
28  $47,967,126  Oakland Athletics
[color=Blue]29  $43,820,598  Tampa Bay Rays
30  $21,836,500  Florida Marlins[/COLOR]

Even though neither the Yankees nor Mets made the playoffs this year, the playoffs spots are completely dominated by the teams that had high payrolls on opening day.