People defending Graham Platner are pathetic and intellectually bankrupt

Exactly. The lesson is that Progressives were right.

Moderate candidates outperformed progressives in neaely every swing state this election, so that’s almost certainly true.

https://www.washingtonpost.com/opinions/2026/11/04/winning-centrist-democrats-will-revive-american-dream/

Cite?

That article is behind the paywall. It starts with this:

It is tempting to attribute Tuesday’s historic blue wave to anger, affordability, tariffs, Iran, artificial intelligence, anti-Trumpism or the Democratic Socialists of America. But although all these forces played their roles, they do not explain the central lesson of this cycle.

So, I’m not sure how useful that opinion writer’s opinion is if he thinks the blue wave had nothing to do with anger, affordability, etc. I can only read the first paragraph, so maybe the rest of it makes up for this ridiculous initial take.

That’s a straight opinion piece, with no data supporting the assertion that moderate candidates did better. Further, who’s moderate? Who’s progressive? Who gets to decide?

This is the time in which every faction of Democrats will insist that the results confirm their preferred narrative.

“Success has many fathers; failure is an orphan.”

The two clearest progressives in Michigan and Florida both did okay. Maybe a little less wavey then the rest but not much so I’m really not sure what Babale is referring to. But my point wasn’t Mills would do better than Jackson. Rather that it is almost impossible for republican to win a senate seat in a plus 17 or so Democratic state.

It hasn’t even been 24 hours yet! Can’t we celebrate an incredible victory first before we tear each other apart? We all want Democrats to win can’t we just concentrate on that for a while.

Sometimes a person gets bored, digs up a long-dead horse, and starts fucking it.

Except for the part where he was never a Nazi.

My desire to stick with Platner was because the establishment were clearly ratfucking him because the Schumer-Jeffries-Pelosi wing of the party would rather be in the minority forever than share a majority with progressives. It’s a stroke of luck that another progressive managed to present themselves and get his spot.

Yes, I was wrong that ousting him would result in Collins being reelected, and I’m glad I was wrong about that, but it could very easily have wound up differently if Schumer had had his way.

If you mean Nixon (in Florida), of course she lost. Granted, it wasn’t a blowout in favor of the MAGA incumbent, but it was definitely a loss.

I agree with you that Mills would likely have had a fair shot of winning against Susan Collins in the current atmosphere. People nation-wide were in a ‘throw the bums out’ mood, and Collins is the quintessential Bum.

The Maine Democratic party heard that the voters had spoken, and looked for another progressive to replace him. Backroom politics sometimes works.

You should stick with “I was wrong”.

Just enjoy the Dem win.

Winning/losing is not a good way of evaluating candidate performance. Nixon is going to lose by about 3 which is about better 10% Harris did and a few points better than her polling. That is a bit less then the shift of the country but that also might have more to do with Florida than Nixon as other races in the state were similar including the definitely not progressive governor’s race. So I can buy that maybe being a progressive cost Nixon a point or two, but nothing substantial, and a different candidate would have been unlikely to win either.

Possibly true. Certainly the argument in the primary for choosing Nixon over Vindman was that her progressive credentials would ‘bring out people who don’t normally vote.’

DSA candidates did BETTER (slightly) as compared to moderate Democrats (“blue dogs”) according to election data analyst G. Elliott Morris:

If we’re going to have a serious discussion, could we maybe take it out of this zombie thread?

Why? Zombies crave braaaaaains.

Good idea. In the meantime, allow me to use this thread for its original purpose – fuck that guy (Platner). He sucked. I am glad Maine got a win despite his shenanigans.

Actually, we far left purity ponies accept 70% as a passing grade. We deduct 15% for each Nazi-adjacent tattoo, plus 10% for each credible allegation of sexual abuse, so he almost made the cut!