Poll on the SDMB community.

What first attracted you to the SDMB?
I’m smart, and I recognize intelligence in others quickly, and there is plenty of that around here. Plus, normal MB’s turn into flaming pits of ignorance and hate, people here are polite.

What do you keep coming back for?
I come back just for the chance to remind people not to end a sentence in a preposition. But seriously, folks, my brain craves exercise, and the quality of other posters keep me on my toes.

How important is the site to you?How much time do you spend per week?day?
I check it everyday, now, if I can. I could live without it, but it’s fun and I’m a hedonist.

Do you think it lives up to its stated goal of “fighting ignorance”? How?
It’s group intelligence without “groupthink.” There’s always someone there to call BS if you misstate facts or perpetuate an uban myth.

What do you think sets the SDMB apart from other message boards?
General politeness. There are geeks, then there are nice geeks. Nice geeks populate SDMB.

What other MBs do you go to?
Occationally the boards at iMDB.

Which forum do you go to first?
GQ, but i spend more time in Cafe Society, IMHO, and MPSIMS.

Do you lurk more or participate more overall? in any particular forum? on any particular subject?
If I don’t know or have an opinion, I keep my ignorant ass out of it. See interests below for topics.

Do you enjoy debating, and do you think you hold your own there?
I do and I can. Posters here seem to be willing to change their minds (about certain topics, anyway) so it makes it worthwhile.

Describe yourself - age, sex, location, occupation, etc. What interests do you have in real life?
27, male, Silicon Valley, animator/art-store-clerk/AV-production-nerd.
Movies, games, American Football, fencing, art, animation, SCUBA, music, dogs, photography, paintball, Ren-Faire, acting, I’m sure I’m missing some, I’m a Jack-of-all-trades.

What do you see as your standing in the SDMB community? Does that correspond to your standing in real life?
I’m a newbie. In real life I’m the smartest person I know, except my mother on certain topics. This is very different.

How honestly do you represent yourself online?
I have nothing to hide or fear. Everyone embellishes a bit, about as much as on a resume.

Do you think people here would be surprised by what you are like in real life?
I haven’t gained an online rep yet.

Do you find yourself agreeing or disagreeing more often with other members? On what subjects?
Again, too new to know.

Are there any rules (official or not) that you disagree with?
Nope, all seems OK.

Who do you see as the leaders of the board?
glee, Paul in Saud, any others that I see often, and with a huge post number.

Who on the board do you most look up to? Why?
The same. Like I said, I recognize high intelligence.

Have you made enemies?
Not yet.

Do you feel like you know the other members well?
Not yet.

How important is the anonymity of the board to you?
I don’t use my real name as a user name, but I’m not afraid. It’s not like we post our Social Security Numbers or anything.

Would you want to meet anyone here in real life? Have you?
Sure. Not yet, I keep looking for people I might already know.

What first attracted you to the SDMB?

Oddly enough, I found the dope because I had just watched a show about the guillotine on the history channel, and was a bit skeptical about some of the claims presented, which led me to Cecil’s article on how long a decapitated head would live. I took a look at the SDMB but wasn’t interested in it much, but I was hooked on Cecil’s columns immediately. It took me a while to warm up to the SDMB, but then I went from mostly disinterested to a complete addict in a short amount of time.

What do you keep coming back for?

I have no idea. But I’m hooked on the SDMB, and feel like something is missing if I don’t read it at least once a day.

How important is the site to you?How much time do you spend per week?day?

During the week, I read it pretty faithfully at least once a day at lunch. If I need to take a break from work, I’ll surf the dope for a bit, then get back to what I was doing. On the weekends, I read it in the morning, and usually again at night.

Do you think it lives up to its stated goal of “fighting ignorance”? How?

I’ve learned a lot here. I think others have as well.

What do you think sets the SDMB apart from other message boards?

A wide variety of subjects.

What other MBs do you go to?

None.

Which forum do you go to first?

GQ first, then MPSIMS, then IMHO. If one of Cecil’s columns or a staff report hits on a subject that I find particularly interesting, I may scan the comments on it. I never go to the pit or GD.

Do you lurk more or participate more overall? in any particular forum? on any particular subject?

I participate in a lot of techie threads, especially anything concerning cars, electronics, anything electrical, and computers. I’m definately not one of the more prolific posters, and am probably unknown to a lot of dopers.

Do you enjoy debating, and do you think you hold your own there?

I’m a fairly decent debator (engineers don’t survive long if they aren’t), but I don’t particularly enjoy it.

Describe yourself - age, sex, location, occupation, etc. What interests do you have in real life?

40 year old bald fat guy living in Pennsylvania. I design hardware and software for use in manufacturing plants. I like tinkering with cars, and like wood working too. I also have quite a few interests that aren’t so typical for an engineer techie type guy. I am very interested in music, and play the guitar, bass, keyboards, trombone, and a few other instruments. I hardly ever get a chance to play these days though. I always wanted to be a writer, though I tend to suck at it. I also am interested in art, and used to be decent at sketching, though I haven’t drawn anything in ages. Too many hobbies, not enough time.

What do you see as your standing in the SDMB community? Does that correspond to your standing in real life?

On the dope, I’m just another techie guy. There’s probably quite a few dopers who don’t really know me.

My standing in real life? Hmm. Well, at work, I’m about as high on the ladder as I’m ever going to get. I don’t want to go into management, and they don’t have higher engineer positions available. At home, I have a wonderful wife and three great children, and pretty much have everything I want. The only thing I want more of is time.

As far as social standing, I really don’t give a **** what people think about me. Never have. I’m never going to be the most popular guy around, and I don’t really care.

How honestly do you represent yourself online?

I’m a straightfoward honest person, in real life, and online.

Do you think people here would be surprised by what you are like in real life?

Nope.

Do you find yourself agreeing or disagreeing more often with other members? On what subjects?

I have some minor disagreements with other dopers from time to time, but usually nothing really noteworthy. About the only thing major that I recall disagreeing with is anyone who supports nuclear power.

Are there any rules (official or not) that you disagree with?

Nope.

Who do you see as the leaders of the board?

I don’t really get into cliques or anything. As far as I’m concerned, we’re all posters, we’re all pretty much equal. The only leaders are the moderators. Just because someone posts 4,000 posts a day and is popular on the board doesn’t give their opinion any more weight with me than a lurker who’s only making their third post. I take each post on its own merits.

Who on the board do you most look up to? Why?

See above.

Have you made enemies?

If I have, they’ve been pretty good about keeping it a secret from me.

I’m not the type of person to intentionally piss people off, and I don’t enjoy big arguments, and hence stay out of GD. Makes it harder for me to make enemies.

Do you feel like you know the other members well?

I know some better than others.

How important is the anonymity of the board to you?

Not very. I’ve posted enough information about myself that if anyone I knew read it they could probably figure out who I am.

Would you want to meet anyone here in real life? Have you?

I’ve met quite a few folks here, and look forward to Gettysdope every year. Lots of nice folks.

What first attracted you to the SDMB?
I first came here via a link to the legendary If LotR Had Been Written By Someone Else!? thread. I had no idea what I was getting myself into.

What do you keep coming back for?
The wealth of knowledge on what I think truly is literally every subject imaginable. It’s also a guaranteed laugh, every single time I visit.

How important is the site to you?How much time do you spend per week?day?
Important? It’s not important in the “can’t live without it” sense, but it is one of the few places on the Internet that I make a point of visiting on a daily basis. I probably spend an hour or two every evening browsing the fora, and perhaps a bit more on the weekends.

Do you think it lives up to its stated goal of “fighting ignorance”? How?
The community as a whole takes this bit very seriously. When I said “literally every subject imaginable” up above, I meant it (literally). No matter what the subject, there is someone here who knows something about it. And we are not shy about sharng that knowledge; not to try to feel superior, but to help share our unique knowledge, and our personal views and perspectives, with the rest of the world.

What do you think sets the SDMB apart from other message boards?
In a word, intelligence. You will find no l33t-speak here. No “OMG! U R teh l4m3st n00b!” Just a frank discussion of ideas, presented in a mature, literate manner.

What other MBs do you go to?
The only other board I frequent on anything resembling a regular basis is MousePlanet . I’m a Disney geek.

Which forum do you go to first?
I generally visit IMHO, MPSIMS, and Cafe Society, in no particular order. Less often I read ATMB and GQ, and occasionally go to the Pit (usually for comic relief). I stay away from Great Debates. It’s a scary place.

Do you lurk more or participate more overall? in any particular forum? on any particular subject?
I lurk more than I post. I have a little bit of knowledge in a very wide range of topics; I rarely have anything unique to contribute to most threads. I post mostly to the IMHO type threads, like this one.

Do you enjoy debating, and do you think you hold your own there?
I very much enjoy debating. In real life, I am quite good at it, and can hold my own against just about anyone. Here, it’s another matter. I DO NOT debate on this board, bcause I would get my ass handed to me in about six seconds flat.

Describe yourself - age, sex, location, occupation, etc. What interests do you have in real life?
Male, age 38. I am a Network Administrator living in Sacramento, CA. Married to another doper (Rhiannon8404) with a 7 year-old son. My hobbies involve computers (big surprise there!), reading, and travel.

What do you see as your standing in the SDMB community? Does that correspond to your standing in real life?
I think I pretty much stay almost completely under the radar here. I am probably the same in real life, with the exception of work, where I am rather high profile (due to the position I hold, and the fact that I’ve been at the same job for almost 8 years now).

How honestly do you represent yourself online?
I am completely honest. Since almost nobody here knows me in real life, I have no reason to need to deceive anyone. And if I did, the one person who does know me would definitely call me on it.

Do you think people here would be surprised by what you are like in real life?
Not at all. See previous question. Also, all of the personal details I revealed three questions ago have been made public on the boards here in the past.

Do you find yourself agreeing or disagreeing more often with other members? On what subjects?
I am a moderately-conservative Republican Catholic. As such, that puts me at odds with quite a few other Dopers on the subjects of politics and religion. But I tend to stay away from the more “dangerous” threads, so I don’t have much occasion to agree or disagree all that often.

Are there any rules (official or not) that you disagree with?
None that I have been on the wrong end of. Act like a grown up, and be polite (outside of the Pit), and you don’t need to worry about the rules too much.

Who do you see as the leaders of the board?
The obvious answer is, the Mods and Admins. Beyond that, there are certain posters who either seem to be everywhere, or who are almost guaranteed to show up when certain subjects are being discussed. For the most part, anyone with a post count over 10,000 is someone to be reckoned with.

Who on the board do you most look up to? Why?
See above. I’m not naming names, because everyone knows who they are.

Have you made enemies?
If I have, I don’t know it. I seriously doubt I’ve made that much of an impression.

Do you feel like you know the other members well?
Not really. I know a few things about quite a few people, but not much about anyone in particular.

How important is the anonymity of the board to you?
Not really important to me personally, because I don’t have anything to hide. In principle, though, it’s very important. Not so that people can hide their identities, but so that they have the freedom to speak their minds without feeling that they need to hold anything back.

Would you want to meet anyone here in real life? Have you?
I have not yet met anyone, but I have no qualms about doing so. We have planned to go to a couple Northern California DopeFests, but for one reason or another have never made one.

Not that you asked, but I have answered all of these questions without first reading any of the other responses. I didn’t want any of my answers to be in any way influenced by what others might have said. I now look forward to seeing how the rest of the community has responded.

What first attracted you to the SDMB?

My husband, Suburban Plankton introduced me to the board.

What do you keep coming back for?

Where else can I interact with so many different types of people with so many different perspectives.

How important is the site to you?How much time do you spend per week?day?

I probably spend 10 hrs/week. Just a guess really. I’m on and off all day so it’s hard to tell.

Do you think it lives up to its stated goal of “fighting ignorance”? How?

Well, I’ve learned a lot.

What do you think sets the SDMB apart from other message boards?

It’s different from my other boards because of the diversity of posters. All my other boards have a theme.

What other MBs do you go to?

MousePad at Mouse Planet (Disney related)
The Well Trained Mind General Board (homeschooling)
The Denim Jumper (homeschooling)
Eclectic Homeschooling
July 98 Playgroup (moms with kids born 7/98)
Class of 2016 (moms of current 2nd graders)
Catholic Online Forum
The Sims2 boards

There are more that I lurk on, but these I post to regularly. I am a message board junkie.

Which forum do you go to first?

Cafe Society

Do you lurk more or participate more overall? in any particular forum? on any particular subject?

I post mostly in Cafe Society, In My Humble Opinion and MPSIMS. I browse all the forums.

Do you enjoy debating, and do you think you hold your own there?

I do not enjoy debating.

Describe yourself - age, sex, location, occupation, etc. What interests do you have in real life?

Female, 37, Sacramento, CA. I’m “retired” after working 5 yrs in local radio and 8 yrs for E*Trade. Now I work part-time at the dressage training barn where I keep my horse. I homeschool my 7 yr old son. I’m married (almost 13 yrs) to Suburban Plankton. Real life interests include horses, running, traveling and Disneyland.

What do you see as your standing in the SDMB community? Does that correspond to your standing in real life?

I don’t really know about my standing. Nobody doesn’t like me that I’m aware of. IRL most people like me and get a long with me.

How honestly do you represent yourself online?

I believe that I do.

Do you think people here would be surprised by what you are like in real life?

No, not really.

Do you find yourself agreeing or disagreeing more often with other members? On what subjects?

I don’t know…neither really.

Are there any rules (official or not) that you disagree with?

Not really

Who do you see as the leaders of the board?

The Moderators

Who on the board do you most look up to? Why?

I don’t “look up” to anyone here.

Have you made enemies? I don’t think so…

Do you feel like you know the other members well?

Yeah, some. You know, as well as you can online.

How important is the anonymity of the board to you?

Meh…

Would you want to meet anyone here in real life? Have you?

I would gladly meet up with anyone on this board given the opportunity. I haven’t met anyone from the SDMB IRL yet. I have met lots of people from other boards in person, though.

What first attracted you to the SDMB?
The variety of topics covered (politics AND culture AND mundane pointless stuff), and the large number of users, the speed with which posts get answered, and the absence of spammers. I’d found MBs before that covered a similar breadth of topics before, but typically they had fewer members, and days would go by before without anything getting posted. Alternatively, there are some message boards that are simply overcrowded and threads develop and devolve in an instant. This place seemed to have a happy medium.

What do you keep coming back for?
The same as what first attracted me, plus the intelligence and diversity of the average poster.

How important is the site to you?How much time do you spend per week?day?
Realistically, I probably spend an hour or so on the site per day, approximately 5 days a week. The “importance” of the site depends completely on whether or not I’m heavily involved in a thread (especially if I started it), but that doesn’t happen too often.

Do you think it lives up to its stated goal of “fighting ignorance”? How?
For the people who use it, yeah. I think most people here have an intellectual integrity, and are willing to set the record straight, even if it’s unpopular.

What do you think sets the SDMB apart from other message boards?
Honestly, the lack of spammers. I guess that comes down to it being a pay service and to good work by the moderators.

What other MBs do you go to?
None that I post to regularly anymore, unless you account the occassional posting on IMDB.

Which forum do you go to first?
Great Debates or Cafe Society.

Do you lurk more or participate more overall? in any particular forum? on any particular subject?
I feel like I participate more than lurk, but on the occassions when I look at my list of recent postings I’m always surprised at how few there are. So maybe I’m more of a lurker and just don’t know it. I lurk more in Great Debates since I’m scared of exposing my ignorance, and post more in Cafe Society and IMHO since it’s more opinion-based.

Do you enjoy debating, and do you think you hold your own there?
I enjoy debating, but I hate being called out on mistakes, so I’m usually pretty cautious, which I guess kinda stifles things.

Describe yourself - age, sex, location, occupation, etc. What interests do you have in real life?
Male, 25, East coast, office-worker (though looking for a better job). I don’t usually give out much personal info. In real life I enjoy reading history books, movies, music…pretty basic stuff.

What do you see as your standing in the SDMB community? Does that correspond to your standing in real life?
I don’t think I have much of a standing here, one way or the other. I ask more questions than I answer, I’m not very good on any particular subject, and I don’t post regularly enough to have made much of a dent. I’m pretty unobtrusive in real life too.

How honestly do you represent yourself online?
I’ve never lied about anything biographical, if that’s what you mean. In other regards, well, it is of course easier to express strong opinions online than it is in person.

Do you think people here would be surprised by what you are like in real life?
No, because I don’t think anyone here has any real impression of me one way or the other in the first place.

Do you find yourself agreeing or disagreeing more often with other members? On what subjects?
Does it sound disingenuous to say that there’s no possible answer to that given the diversity of opinions expressed here?

Are there any rules (official or not) that you disagree with?
I sometimes get annoyed by the locking of threads before their time is up.

Who do you see as the leaders of the board?
The first names that come to mind are Sampiro, Shagnasty, and ExapnoMapcase.

Who on the board do you most look up to? Why?
Ditto above.

Have you made enemies?
Doubt it.

Do you feel like you know the other members well?
No.

How important is the anonymity of the board to you?
I guess pretty important. I’d have to be here a long time before I’d go to one of those meet-ups.

Would you want to meet anyone here in real life? Have you?
Never have; there are some interesting personalities here that I’d be interested to meet…

What first attracted you to the SDMB?
I don’t recall. I found the Straight Dope first, and then discovered the boards. I was a watcher for two or three years before registering.

What do you keep coming back for?
That’s hard to say. Sometimes I think I’m waiting for that one response of, “My God, you’re a genius.” Other than that, it’s definitely fun to sharpen my wit here.

How important is the site to you?How much time do you spend per week?day?
Per day: maybe 2-3 hours, so probably 20 or more hours a week

Do you think it lives up to its stated goal of “fighting ignorance”? How?
Yes. It has a staff devoted entirely to questions of fact or logic.

What do you think sets the SDMB apart from other message boards?
Hard to say, it’s the only place I regularly post.

What other MBs do you go to?
None.

Which forum do you go to first?
Either MPSIMS or the Pit. Those are the forums I post in rather than lurk in.

Do you lurk more or participate more overall? in any particular forum? on any particular subject?
I lurk in GD and GQ. I can’t hang with the big boys yet. I post in MPSIMS, IMHO and Cafe Society. I feel more comfortable there.

Do you enjoy debating, and do you think you hold your own there?
Not on the internet. I like arguing in person over drinks.

Describe yourself - age, sex, location, occupation, etc. What interests do you have in real life?
23, M, in Nashville. I’m a teacher at the moment, but an aspring videographer. I need extra cash and more practice.

What do you see as your standing in the SDMB community? Does that correspond to your standing in real life?
I’m not a major member of the SDMB. I doubt if I stopped posting it would be noticed. IRL, I’m not nearly as invisible as I feel here. Then again, if you get noticed here, it ain’t usually a good thing.

How honestly do you represent yourself online?
Very.

Do you think people here would be surprised by what you are like in real life?
Nope.

Do you find yourself agreeing or disagreeing more often with other members? On what subjects?
Politically? Agreeing. On other stuff, it varies a lot. I don’t fall in with the cult of child worship or animal worship that seems prevalent here. But I don’t like people much either, so I guess I’m one of the misanthropic heathens.

Are there any rules (official or not) that you disagree with?
Not really. I don’t encounter them often.

Who do you see as the leaders of the board?
Can’t really say. The mods, I suppose in some cases, but not much other than that.

Who on the board do you most look up to? Why?
The reserved ones. I wish I could restrain myself better at times.

Have you made enemies?
I don’t think so.

Do you feel like you know the other members well?
Nah.

How important is the anonymity of the board to you?
Not very. I’d say the same stuff to people in person.

Would you want to meet anyone here in real life? Have you?
I’d like to meet a few folks. Enough to count on one hand.

What first attracted you to the SDMB?
I don’t recall. I found the Straight Dope first, and then discovered the boards. I was a watcher for two or three years before registering.

What do you keep coming back for?
That’s hard to say. Sometimes I think I’m waiting for that one response of, “My God, you’re a genius.” Other than that, it’s definitely fun to sharpen my wit here.

How important is the site to you?How much time do you spend per week?day?
Per day: maybe 2-3 hours, so probably 20 or more hours a week

Do you think it lives up to its stated goal of “fighting ignorance”? How?
Yes. It has a staff devoted entirely to questions of fact or logic.

What do you think sets the SDMB apart from other message boards?
Hard to say, it’s the only place I regularly post.

What other MBs do you go to?
None.

Which forum do you go to first?
Either MPSIMS or the Pit. Those are the forums I post in rather than lurk in.

Do you lurk more or participate more overall? in any particular forum? on any particular subject?
I lurk in GD and GQ. I can’t hang with the big boys yet. I post in MPSIMS, IMHO and Cafe Society. I feel more comfortable there.

Do you enjoy debating, and do you think you hold your own there?
Not on the internet. I like arguing in person over drinks.

Describe yourself - age, sex, location, occupation, etc. What interests do you have in real life?
23, M, in Nashville. I’m a teacher at the moment, but an aspring videographer. I need extra cash and more practice.

What do you see as your standing in the SDMB community? Does that correspond to your standing in real life?
I’m not a major member of the SDMB. I doubt if I stopped posting it would be noticed. IRL, I’m not nearly as invisible as I feel here. Then again, if you get noticed here, it ain’t usually a good thing.

How honestly do you represent yourself online?
Very.

Do you think people here would be surprised by what you are like in real life?
Nope.

Do you find yourself agreeing or disagreeing more often with other members? On what subjects?
Politically? Agreeing. On other stuff, it varies a lot. I don’t fall in with the cult of child worship or animal worship that seems prevalent here. But I don’t like people much either, so I guess I’m one of the misanthropic heathens.

Are there any rules (official or not) that you disagree with?
Not really. I don’t encounter them often.

Who do you see as the leaders of the board?
Can’t really say. The mods, I suppose in some cases, but not much other than that.

Who on the board do you most look up to? Why?
The reserved ones. I wish I could restrain myself better at times.

Have you made enemies?
I don’t think so.

Do you feel like you know the other members well?
Nah.

How important is the anonymity of the board to you?
Not very. I’d say the same stuff to people in person.

Would you want to meet anyone here in real life? Have you?
I’d like to meet a few folks. Enough to count on one hand.

What first attracted you to the SDMB?
Humor and intelligence.

What do you keep coming back for?
Same.

How important is the site to you?How much time do you spend per week?day?
Depends on how busy I am at work. Usually, I use the site to kill my boredom.

Do you think it lives up to its stated goal of “fighting ignorance”? How?
It tries. Bullshit is not tolerated, and you better have a cite if you make a claim.

What do you think sets the SDMB apart from other message boards?
See above three answers.

What other MBs do you go to?
None.

Which forum do you go to first?
Pretty Even.

Do you lurk more or participate more overall? in any particular forum? on any particular subject?
Lurk more.

Do you enjoy debating, and do you think you hold your own there?
It’s okay. Can’t really hold my own on most topics, because these people seem to have been gathering more facts. So even if I’m right, I dont have enough evidence to articulate it.

Describe yourself - age, sex, location, occupation, etc. What interests do you have in real life?
Real Life?? What’s that?

What do you see as your standing in the SDMB community? Does that correspond to your standing in real life?
People listen to me more in real life.

How honestly do you represent yourself online?
Very honest. Even use my real name.

Do you think people here would be surprised by what you are like in real life?
Nope.

Do you find yourself agreeing or disagreeing more often with other members? On what subjects?
Agreeing mostly. Except when it comes to Iraq.

Are there any rules (official or not) that you disagree with?
Nope.

Who do you see as the leaders of the board?
Cecil.

Who on the board do you most look up to? Why?
No one.

Have you made enemies?
I dont think so. ::looks around::

Do you feel like you know the other members well?
Some.

How important is the anonymity of the board to you?
Not at all. I dont really like people being anonymous.

Would you want to meet anyone here in real life? Have you?
Met quite a few people. They’re just as nerdy and interesting as they are on here!

The intellegence and maturity level at that time.

Habit, mostly. Plus some of the cool people.

Almost every day, but with breaks from time to time.

No. Sometimes, but seldom.

Its simple interface.

Philosophy mostly.

Cafe Society, usually.

I stay out of the Pit now, and post mostly in GD. Some Cafe, GQ, and here obvioiusly.

On certain topics, I do well. On others, I’m weak.

Male, 50s, South, Senior Vice President of a small firm. Same interests I express here.

Some people love me; some hate me. Fewer people in real life dislike me.

Too much so, sometimes.

Physically possibly. (Someone once said they picture me as slim and leathery, smoking a pipe.) Otherwise, no.

Probably disagree on most things. I’m a Libertarian Objectivist Christian.

Yes. The so-called “hate speech” rule is asinine. Utterly stupid.

The admins and mods. Their grip is quite tight. Especially Tuba, Ed, and Arnold.

Spiritus Mundi, Sentient Meat, Otherwise, Cosmosdan, Philospher, Gaudere, Czarcasm, Triskadecamus, Phil Dennison, Washte, Rockle, and Gum. I admire their intellect, their honesty, and for all but one, their kindness.

Probably. Among members, Desmostylus stands out. And among staff, Giraffe and Frank.

Some of them.

Moderately. There are a lot of loose screws here.

I’ve met Tris and Polycarp. I’d like to meet those whom I look up to.

What first attracted you to the SDMB?
I really don’t remember. I believe I found it during a google search while at work.

What do you keep coming back for?
I’ve grown to enjoy it immensely.

How important is the site to you?How much time do you spend per week?day?
Important. Am I going to sell my firstborn to keep it? No, but it’s fun. I spend a few hours a day.

Do you think it lives up to its stated goal of “fighting ignorance”? How?
Yes. SDMB members don’t suffer fools gladly.

What do you think sets the SDMB apart from other message boards?
People

What other MBs do you go to?
Would rather not say.

Which forum do you go to first?
Pit. Because that’s just the order I check the forums.

Do you lurk more or participate more overall? in any particular forum? on any particular subject?
Lurk more.

Do you enjoy debating, and do you think you hold your own there?
No and no.

Describe yourself - age, sex, location, occupation, etc. What interests do you have in real life?
40 in two weeks, female, outside of chicago, secretary. I have no real life. Seriously - cooking, reading.

What do you see as your standing in the SDMB community? Does that correspond to your standing in real life?
I don’t have a “standing” either here or in real life. Perhaps I’m not understanding your question. If you mean do people like me? I don’t know, nor do I particularly care - I stay pretty well under the radar here and in real life-I’m pretty invisible.

How honestly do you represent yourself online?
I am what I am. I have neither the time, the ambition, nor the creativity to be someone I’m not just for a message board.

Do you think people here would be surprised by what you are like in real life?
No.

Do you find yourself agreeing or disagreeing more often with other members? On what subjects?
Hard to say - I sometimes agree, sometimes I don’t. I can’t “pick” any particular subjects.

Are there any rules (official or not) that you disagree with?
No

Who do you see as the leaders of the board?
The mods

Who on the board do you most look up to? Why?
I’m not going here.

Have you made enemies?
I doubt I’ve had significant enough of an impact to make anything, let alone enemies.

Do you feel like you know the other members well?
Not particularly.

How important is the anonymity of the board to you?
Important.

Would you want to meet anyone here in real life? Have you?
Not going here either.

What first attracted you to the SDMB?

The wide range of topics that are discussed and getting quick answers to unique and interesting questions.

What do you keep coming back for?

It passes the time at work and sometimes at home.

How important is the site to you? How much time do you spend per week? day?

Very important, probably 5 to 8 hours per week.

Do you think it lives up to its stated goal of “fighting ignorance”? How?

For the most part. Most of the people who frequent this site seem to be fairly well educated.

What do you think sets the SDMB apart from other message boards?

Stricter moderation, attracts people of higher intelligence.

What other MBs do you go to?

I used to frequent customerssuck.com and tommabe.com but don’t spend much time on these lately.

Which forum do you go to first?

Cafe Society. or IMHO, just depends on what kind of mood I am in.

Do you lurk more or participate more overall? in any particular forum? on any particular subject?

I lurk more than I post. I am most apt to start or respond to poll-type questions. I stay away from “hot-button” topics such as politics and religion.

Do you enjoy debating, and do you think you hold your own there?

I don’t even go to Great Debates, much less participate. I don’t have the patience or energy to defend my views on highly debated topics.

Describe yourself - age, sex, location, occupation, etc. What interests do you have in real life?

Age 35 (36 as of 2/25), male, location near Boise, Idaho, current occupation is travel consultant for a travel call center. My interests are music, movies, skiing, bowling and reading.

What do you see as your standing in the SDMB community? Does that correspond to your standing in real life?

I’ve been here for awhile and I have the post count to prove it, but I don’t consider myself to be amongst the more prominent members. I’m this way in real life as well.

How honestly do you represent yourself online?

I am honest about myself online. What you read in my posts is what you would get if you met me in person.

Do you think people here would be surprised by what you are like in real life?

Perhaps a few would be. My posts can only convey so much information about the type of person I really am.

Do you find yourself agreeing or disagreeing more often with other members? On what subjects?

For the most part I agree with what other posters have to say. It all depends on the topic.

Are there any rules (official or not) that you disagree with?

Most of the rules are agreeable and acceptable. The rules are good for keeping order here, and the mods are good about standing by such rules. I do wish the mods would ease up somewhat on publicly inquiring about a member being banned and the reasons why, since curious minds wnat to know.

Who do you see as the leaders of the board?

Q.E.D., Chronos, Guinistasia, Liberal are the first few names that come to mind, aside from the mods.

Who on the board do you most look up to? Why?**

Q.E.D. is a good “role model” for this site.

Have you made enemies?

None that I am aware of.

Do you feel like you know the other members well?

About as much as I know most of my co-workers. Beyond what we talk about as it pertains to the subject at hand I don’t really know much about others here.

How important is the anonymity of the board to you?

I consider it to be important. I value my privacy and respect the privacy of others.

Would you want to meet anyone here in real life? Have you?

If the opportunity presented itself, perhaps. Never actually met a fellow doper, though.

What first attracted you to the SDMB?

Cecil’s columns (which I encountered in book form, found on the shelf of my then girlfriend and now soon to be ex wife). I found the AOL forums and participated lightly; my first experience there was to ask a question that was, in retrospect, kind of dumb. I got in response both useful information and a mildly snarky (and amusing) spanking for the dumb question. It was a perfect fit for my mindset, since I don’t mind having my stupidities pointed out to me. I browsed a bit, but I hated the AOL interface; when the site moved to the web I became a much heavier user.

What do you keep coming back for?

The sheer variety of content, combined with a high standard for both writing and analysis. On any given day, I can find threads discussing manufacturing codes on the labels of beer bottles, healthcare policies of sub-Saharan Africa, the relative merits of Marx Brothers comedies, proposals for vote tabulation in Virginia, and whether or not it’s a good idea to feed one’s fish by jerking off into the aquarium. Then I can post a question about the logistics of safely flying a 747 into the Grand Canyon and receive detailed, interesting responses from pilots, engineers, and geologists. Show me someplace else on the web where I can get all of this, and I’ll check it out, but as far as I know it doesn’t exist.

How important is the site to you?How much time do you spend per week?day?

Very important. Per the above, I get an amazing amount of entertainment and edification here. On a daily basis, I learn, and I laugh. The quality of political, artistic, and personal interaction here is superior to damn near anywhere else, and because we’re populated with people who both agree and disagree with my views in equal measure, I learn a lot more than I would if I were hiding in an echo chamber. I can’t overestimate the value of this. As far as time, I’m probably here 2-3 hours a day, on average.

Do you think it lives up to its stated goal of “fighting ignorance”? How?

That depends on how you define “fighting,” I think. If you take it to mean “defeating,” then the answer is no, because that’s pretty much impossible. If you mean “resisting,” then yes. There’s a fair amount of nonsense here, but many orders of magnitude less than other places on the web, or in meatspace. The refusal to accept assertions without backup, and the awareness of minimal standards of debate even in the non-debate fora, have been quite influential on my thinking outside the boards. Ignorance will never be eradicated, but a safe haven for rationalism, an outpost for responsible thinking, is a very good thing.

What do you think sets the SDMB apart from other message boards?

As above, the quality of writing, the intellectual and analytical standards, and more than that the breadth of membership. That we can have teenagers and septugenarians mingling in the same threads is pretty remarkable. Plus the moderation, for as much grousing goes on about its heavy-handedness (which is occasionally warranted), is a major part of why the place is as civil and balanced as it is.

What other MBs do you go to?

None with this frequency. I drop in at a few specialty sites (TiVo Community, Scifi.com’s Battlestar Galactica forum, etc.), but this is home base.

Which forum do you go to first?

Depends on the planned duration of my visit. During my lunch hour, or on weekends, when I have lots of time, I start at the top and work my way down. If I’ve only got a few minutes, I start with Cafe Society and then go into the Pit.

Do you lurk more or participate more overall? in any particular forum? on any particular subject?

I read probably twenty threads for every one I post in. I have a lot of posts but I’ve been around a long time. I think this read-to-post ratio is pretty consistent from forum to forum.

Do you enjoy debating, and do you think you hold your own there?

I don’t enjoy debating for the sake of debating, i.e. taking up a contrary position simply to sustain a competitive back-and-forth. When I feel strongly about something, I’ll express my opinion, and I think I’m usually pretty good about being clear and thorough, although of course I can always be better. But my approach is to get everything out in one or two long and comprehensive posts, because for the most part I think debate on the perennial subjects is a waste of time. The players, generally, are pretty well entrenched, and argument isn’t going to change anybody’s mind. So I’ll aim my post at the silent readership, the people who are partly or entirely undecided, and make my points as best as I can, and then leave it alone. I’ll occasionally get a congratulatory response, a sort of “thanks for summing up exactly what I wanted to say,” most frequently in threads on atheism, so I think I do pretty well for the limited role I choose to play.

Describe yourself - age, sex, location, occupation, etc. What interests do you have in real life?

I am a 27-year-old Chinese-Hungarian woman who has spent over a decade in the deep-sea hospitality industry. I live in a soap bubble floating at thirteen thousand feet somewhere between Ankara and Schenectady. Instead of a head, I have a jumbo mayonnaise jar full of vodka and brine shrimp. My mother is a hand model and my father was Pope Pius the Ninth.

How honestly do you represent yourself online?

I do not really have a jumbo mayonnaise jar full of vodka and brine shrimp for a head.

Okay, okay. I’m a thirtysomething male. I live in the Pacific Northwest and I do high-technology work at an internet company you’ve all heard of. I have a fine arts degree from an exclusive arts college; although this degree does not serve as the literal basis for my income, it wasn’t a wasteful indulgence: indeed, it’s far and away the best investment I’ve ever made, as it’s influenced my thinking and life habits in every area of my life, and has made me a better person than I would be otherwise. It’s a practical source of enjoyment also: I’m currently acting in a play.

As far as I can recall, I’ve never deliberately misrepresented myself online, though I do avoid posting too many specifically identifying details.

What do you see as your standing in the SDMB community? Does that correspond to your standing in real life?

I have no real idea where I fall in the SDMB pantheon. Everybody knows my telemarketer thread, but at the same time I very infrequently show up in any “name your favorite Doper” threads or flirtfests or that sort of thing. (The mention by silenus above is a rare exception.) I’ve been around long enough that I’ve acquired a small reputation by sheer inertia, I think, which sort of goes along with my profile in meatland. Call me a middle-of-the-pack type.

Do you think people here would be surprised by what you are like in real life?

I don’t think I’ve ever before mentioned the mayonnaise jar full of brine shrimp. Also, I don’t know if people are really aware of how stunningly handsome I really am. Other than that, I don’t know how to answer this.

Do you find yourself agreeing or disagreeing more often with other members? On what subjects?

Varies by forum and topic and, hell, time of day. As I said above, the simple fact that opinions span such a wide range is one of the things I value most about the boards. As an example, I don’t expect many people to agree with my views on Paul Verhoeven and Showgirls in particular, and I usually don’t get into it when the subject is mentioned by others, but the fact that we can discuss our varying opinions cordially (mostly) is a big plus. And I think that the simple fact of my minority viewpoint is a demonstration of the value of the board’s diversity. The same can be said for all the other nut-bars out there with equally oddball opinions. :slight_smile:

In general, I’m not sure I can answer this with much accuracy, because I don’t really keep score. It’s the give and take, overall, that I find interesting and worthwhile.

Are there any rules (official or not) that you disagree with?

Not really. That said, we are, by dint of the board’s core statement of purpose, a population of inveterate nitpickers, and there are a handful of rather specific regulations that are clearly designed to handle the jackwipe yahoos who seek to excuse their obnoxious behavior by asserting absurdly narrow readings of common-sense principles. “Don’t be a jerk” is a perfectly useful standard of conduct for anyone with a modicum of intelligence and empathy; it’s too bad when the occasional socially-challenged exception forces the moderators to craft a legalistic variation on the general directive to cover some specific bit of stupidity that is obvious to those with basic social skills but that must be made explicit for the interpersonally feeble minority.

Who do you see as the leaders of the board?

I don’t see “leaders,” I see a highly vocal rabble, and I like it that way.

Who on the board do you most look up to? Why?

If I had to pick a single Doper who exemplifies what I think of as the best qualities of Doperdom, I would name Left Hand of Dorkness. He’s articulate, thoughtful, patient, curious, intellectually responsible, and in general a pleasure to read. That being said, the caliber of personality here is very high, and there are many people besides LHOD who make me aspire to be a better person than I am.

Have you made enemies?

I don’t think I’ve “made” enemies. I think that a handful of people have presented themselves and announced themselves as being in stark opposition to me and my point of view, and I’ve accepted them as being so opposed. If that makes them enemies, then so be it. I can’t say I’m necessarily proud of this, by the way.

Do you feel like you know the other members well?

Yes, absolutely.

How important is the anonymity of the board to you?

Interpersonal anonymity, not so much; see the next question. Cyberspace anonymity, absolutely. There are a lot of fruitcakes out there and I don’t want to wake up one morning to find “ATHEIST” painted on my front window in blood.

Would you want to meet anyone here in real life? Have you?

Yes and yes. I value the friendships I’ve made here, and I have expanded my social circle quite a bit. My offline activities (work and theater) tend to restrict me to fairly small communities, and many of the people I got to know here first before meeting elsewhere I never would have met any other way.

Is Michael Jackson a space alien or what?

Definitely a space alien.

What first attracted you to the SDMB?

As for many, the columns of the ever-glorious Cecil provided the portal. I just started reading the message board – don’t know why, really – and never stopped.

What do you keep coming back for?

That’s like asking why a nicotine fiend is at the convenience store at 4:00 A.M. That said, opportunity counts for something. I’m here in front of the computer anyway, in other words.

How important is the site to you?How much time do you spend per week?day?

I could live without it, but when you need to consult the collective wisdom of the 5,000 sages who make up the Teeming Millions, it’s invaluable. And I spend far, far too much time here – I don’t want to calculate, in fact.

Do you think it lives up to its stated goal of “fighting ignorance”? How?

Yes and no. Some people take the mantra seriously, and I don’t. So much “ignorance” is personal opinion, after all. But that said, if you need to know the answer to something you can’t readily find on Google, this is the place to come. So the SDMB is good for decreasing my own ignorance, but if I were to imagine that I was decreasing anyone else’s, except in a marginal way, I’d be fooling myself.

What do you think sets the SDMB apart from other message boards?

Not really sure, since I don’t visit many others. But I think this place maintains a greater degree of civility than most, and also has a higher caliber of poster. It’s also one of the few message boards that is both smart and not subject-specific. Also, it’s a little thing, but it counts – people here try to write correctly and readably.

What other MBs do you go to?

None consistently.

Which forum do you go to first?

Usually GQ, but it depends.

Do you lurk more or participate more overall? in any particular forum? on any particular subject?

I think I lurk and post in equal measure. Some days I participate more in one forum, some days more in another. I try not to be one-note about my posting, so I don’t just weigh in on one subject, nor is there one subject that will always draw a response from me. That said, some subjects more than others are likely to get a response from me.

Do you enjoy debating, and do you think you hold your own there?

Well, I think so, though maybe I’m not the most impartial judge of that. I suspect that most people who engage in debates think they’re cleaning the other party’s clock. It is a little true of debating that it takes more of an emotional toll than participating in IMHO or MPSIMS, which is a good reason for limiting it.

Describe yourself - age, sex, location, occupation, etc. What interests do you have in real life?

White guy on the cusp of middle age. White collar professional in Boston. Interests – multifarious. Same as the ones I post about here.

What do you see as your standing in the SDMB community? Does that correspond to your standing in real life?

That I don’t know. I’m not a long-termer, so if people don’t recognize my name, I wouldn’t be surprised. I also wouldn’t be surprised if a few people did. The people you tend to remember here are the ones who engage in epic flame wars, or whose posts invite a following. Don’t think I’m in either of those two categories. In real life, I have no particular standing. I’m not sure what “standing” even signifies, except that you haven’t been arrested.

How honestly do you represent yourself online?

I don’t represent myself dishonestly, and in some ways I’m more honest here than in real life. Most people are the same, I’d guess. That’s the real value of a message board, as I see it – anonymity equals openness, such that threads here don’t have much correlate in real life.

Do you think people here would be surprised by what you are like in real life?

I’d guess not, but I don’t really know.

Do you find yourself agreeing or disagreeing more often with other members? On what subjects?

There’s the usual right-left political divide here, along with divides about other incendiary topics (Israel, the Iraq war, well-done steaks, etc.), so naturally I sometimes agree, and sometimes disagree.

Are there any rules (official or not) that you disagree with?

Some of the Pit rules (don’t say “you’re pulling up a chair,” don’t mention that another poster is on your ignore list) I feel are unnecessary and silly, but at the same time, I don’t feel that they’re a big deal. If more rules like that proliferated, I’d be a little worried.

Who do you see as the leaders of the board?

The old-timers and the mods, and some of the people who have a following.

Who on the board do you most look up to? Why?

People who are civil, and people who can effectively argue a point. People who are funny get bonus points. I also admire people who have the goods, by which I mean specialized, in-depth knowledge of something. I’m reluctant to name names, because it can get embarrassing.

Have you made enemies?

I don’t think so, but you’ll have to ask my enemies.

Do you feel like you know the other members well?

Sometimes I do, only to be thrown for a loop. But in general, I know the political tendencies of some posters, I know some posters are always worth reading, and I know certain parts of the life histories of certain posters.

How important is the anonymity of the board to you?

It’s fairly important to me to maintain a decent firewall between the board and real life. I’m just shy, I guess.

Would you want to meet anyone here in real life? Have you?

I feel like I might want to meet people from the board, but anonymously, where they didn’t know I knew them from the board. And the only reason would be to find out how their real-life self meshes with their board persona. I don’t want to be recognized myself. I’m a closet Doper.

What first attracted you to the SDMB?

I was a fan of Cecil Adams & The Straight Dope from his books, which I’d picked up at the library.

What do you keep coming back for?

To interact with intelligent, funny, articulate people on a variety of important and mundane topics, and to alleviate boredom.

How important is the site to you?How much time do you spend per week?day?

On a scale of 1-10, with 1 being lowest and 10 being highest, I’d say 7. I would miss it, but not be devastated if it were gone (or I lost access). I spend between 2-8 hours a day, on an intermittant basis, 5 days a week (M-F).

Do you think it lives up to its stated goal of “fighting ignorance”? How?

Yes, to the extent that its members actually possess correct information and the ability to convey it in an understandable & palatible manner. No, to the extent that (to quote a member) “sometimes ignorance fights back.”

What do you think sets the SDMB apart from other message boards?

Good moderating, fair rules, insistance on standard written English (not leetspeak or AOL slang), lack of graphic images such as avatars, etc., and a generally higher-than-average intelligence demographic of its members (at least, judging by a survey of posts).

What other MBs do you go to?

Currently, none.

Which forum do you go to first?

Whichever one has the thread title that catches my eye the most; otherwise, I go to MPSIMS first.

Do you lurk more or participate more overall? in any particular forum? on any particular subject?

I lurk more than participate in The BBQ Pit, and Great Debates. I think it’s about an even balance for the rest.

Do you enjoy debating, and do you think you hold your own there?

It’s ok, but not something I seek out. I don’t care for it when it gets antagonistic. I’m nowhere near as good as many, and better than some, I guess.

Describe yourself - age, sex, location, occupation, etc. What interests do you have in real life?

I’m 42, female, live in suburban Portland, OR area, and am an accountant/controller (not a CPA). Some of my interests: outdoor activities (hiking, snowshoeing, golf, downhill skiing), reading (esp. history, biographies, humor, science, medicine; some nonfiction – esp. the works of Carl Hiaasen, Tim Dorsey, Jonathan Kellerman), music (mostly adult contemporary rock, some alt-country, folk, jazz, world beat, new age), TV (crime procedurals, quirky comedies, news & educational programming), surfing the net, precious jewelry & gemstones, domestic dogs & cats, art, crossword puzzles.

What do you see as your standing in the SDMB community? Does that correspond to your standing in real life?

I think my standing is that most people don’t know much about me or are only vaguely aware of me, some recognize me and a few might actually remember things about me and express an interest in me. I’m fairly new yet. I don’t yet have a real “group” or “friends” and I don’t think anyone really hates me, although I believe I may have pissed someone off at least once or twice. Sounds about like real life, I guess.

How honestly do you represent yourself online?

I tell the truth, but I keep certain facts to myself, to preserve my anonymity.

Do you think people here would be surprised by what you are like in real life?

I really don’t know. I try not to read others’ minds, as I suck at it.

Do you find yourself agreeing or disagreeing more often with other members? On what subjects?

I guess it’s an even balance. I know that I differ from most members in my religious beliefs and political affiliation, but I’ve not had problems with anyone so far because of either.

Are there any rules (official or not) that you disagree with?

No.

Who do you see as the leaders of the board?

The mods & the posters with highest number of posts/longest membership.

Who on the board do you most look up to? Why?

I don’t want to offend anyone by leaving them out, but there are some I can name:
Anaamika, Anastasaeon, What Exit?, ivylass, irishgirl, Bricker, siege – all seem to be really nice, even-keeled and cool people who seem to get along well with most everyone. I like that.
Left Hand of Dorkness, Tomndebb, Polycarp – have got to be the most logical debaters I’ve come across, can discuss anything without getting emotionally involved & seem very knowlegeable.
Sampiro – can write like nobody’s bidness.
Inigo Montoya, Shirley Ujest, Winston Smith – finely tuned senses of the absurd, make me laugh.

Have you made enemies?

Not that I know of. I hope not.

Do you feel like you know the other members well?

No, not really.

How important is the anonymity of the board to you?

It is critical to me – I could not be here without it.

Would you want to meet anyone here in real life? Have you?

Maybe (but it would be a risky thing, so I don’t expect to). No.

While I’ve only known you for a short while Ana, I’ve come to think of you as an illegitmate daughter by a Finno-Slavic concubine taken in war, and as such I would warn you that Cervaise is a liar. Pope Pius IX has in fact been dead for more than one hundred and twenty seven years, and while he did in fact leave a copious amount of motile sperm uncovered on his bed linens when the black lights were put into his chambers to make way for the Vatican Discoteque in 1940, it was all used in the creation of the Osmond Family (an odd experiment involving the Mormon Apostles, Opus Dei and the owner of a Chinese laundry in Rome).

What first attracted you to the SDMB?
Found a link through a search from Yahoo, I believe it was.

What do you keep coming back for?
The entertainment, the information, and the sense of community.

How important is the site to you?How much time do you spend per week?day?
It’s fairly important, in that I would be disappointed if it were to disappear. I spend about a two hours a day here, on average. Damn. It really goes by quickly.

Do you think it lives up to its stated goal of “fighting ignorance”? How?
Yes. Uninformed opinions/dogma/propaganda are not just swallowed whole, but questioned thoroughly.

What do you think sets the SDMB apart from other message boards?
No leet speak. :smiley: I would say that fools and the non-thinking are not tolerated gladly here.

What other MBs do you go to?
I have occasionally gone to the Fabulous Forums of Fathom, but that is usually just when the Dope is down. I don’t think I could be bothered to spend time on a message board of lower calibre than this one.

Which forum do you go to first?
BBQ pit.

Do you lurk more or participate more overall? in any particular forum? on any particular subject?
I read a lot, I post a little. I try not to force it; I post when I have something to contribute.

Do you enjoy debating, and do you think you hold your own there?
I like debating, but Great Debates is more work than I’m usually willing to do.

Describe yourself - age, sex, location, occupation, etc. What interests do you have in real life?
39, female, Calgary, accounting technician; I am currently working on starting a landscape design business.

What do you see as your standing in the SDMB community? Does that correspond to your standing in real life?
I am one of many useful contributors who don’t particularly stand out, but make this message board what is is. I think that corresponds well to real life.

How honestly do you represent yourself online?
Very. I couldn’t be bothered to try to remember any lies.

Do you think people here would be surprised by what you are like in real life?
Nope.

Do you find yourself agreeing or disagreeing more often with other members? On what subjects?
I usually agree, but there are some cultural differences with United Statesians that I will probably never agree with.

Are there any rules (official or not) that you disagree with?
Yes. You want to know what they are, too?:wink: I think we should be free to discuss medical issues. I think anyone who gets their medical advice off of a public message board gets what they paid for.

Who do you see as the leaders of the board?
Who on the board do you most look up to? Why?
Nobody, really. I’m not much for hero-worship.

Have you made enemies?
Not that I know of.

Do you feel like you know the other members well?
Not really.

How important is the anonymity of the board to you?
Moderately.

Would you want to meet anyone here in real life? Have you?
I have met people from here, and it was a great experience. I find that people who participate in a board like this share a lot of my characteristics.

Oops, forgot to answer Leaders of the Board - I guess I would say nobody. This is a very egalitarian community.

What first attracted you to the SDMB?
I’ve been reading Cecil’s columns since the eighties. One of the first things I did when I finally went on line was look for his website. After lurking for a while I signed up.

What do you keep coming back for?
Best discussions on the web, not that that’s a high bar.

How important is the site to you?How much time do you spend per week?day?
Very important. Probably an hour a day on average.

Do you think it lives up to its stated goal of “fighting ignorance”? How?
I think the phrase “fighting ignorance” was originaly a catchphrase of Cecil’s of no more real import than Avis rentals “We try harder.” I don’t take it seriously as a mission statement. Still you can learn a lot hanging out here.

What do you think sets the SDMB apart from other message boards?
The quality of the posters, and the substance of the discussions.

What other MBs do you go to?
A local neighborhood board.

Which forum do you go to first?
No real pattern. Depends where I posted last or what interesting thread I read.

Do you lurk more or participate more overall? in any particular forum? on any particular subject?
I’ll bellow about politics and philosophy and moral questions with the best of them. I talk about SF and music in Cafe society. I ask questions about math in GQ.

Do you enjoy debating, and do you think you hold your own there?
Yes and yes, though sometimes it seems pretty circular
Describe yourself - age, sex, location, occupation, etc. What interests do you have in real life?
I’m a 43 year old single Male in DC. My life isn’t that interesting.

What do you see as your standing in the SDMB community? Does that correspond to your standing in real life?
Average. I’m not one of the most admired posters nor one of the most hated. I don’t post enough to have a standing. No one’s pitted me yet.

How honestly do you represent yourself online?
I don’t talk about myself much. I don’t lie, but I don’t give out a lot of info either.

Do you think people here would be surprised by what you are like in real life?
I’m a lot looser in real life than here, especially when I’m at a bar. Probably pretty similar though

Do you find yourself agreeing or disagreeing more often with other members? On what subjects?
I don’t know. There are posters I often agree with and ones I don’t.

Are there any rules (official or not) that you disagree with?
I don’t disagree with the basic rules, but I don’t feel they’re always correctly applied. Overall the staff does a good job, but I don’t agree with them 100%

Who do you see as the leaders of the board?
Unless you’re talking about mods and admins, I don’t see this board as having leaders at all.

Who on the board do you most look up to? Why?
There are a lot of people on the board I admire. (For some reason I don’t like the phrase “look up to.”) I feel silly listing them. Several people have answered math questions for me and I’m grateful for that.

Have you made enemies?
One or two maybe. No one I’m broken up about. The people I can’t stand are often the jerks who get quickly banned.

Do you feel like you know the other members well?
No. I’m reluctant to say I know anyone well when I only interact with them on a message board.

How important is the anonymity of the board to you?
Pretty important.

Would you want to meet anyone here in real life? Have you?
Yes, and no.

What first attracted you to the SDMB?

I have memory problems and honestly don’t remember. But I suspect it was probably the subject matter being discussed and the level of discussion.

What do you keep coming back for?

It is one of the few places I feel needed. I enjoy the personalities and humor. There is a “realness” and a reaching out that has the feel of home. It’s a place to play when I want to do that. It helps me to figure out what I think. It’s a great source of information. Why would I want to leave?

How important is the site to you?How much time do you spend per week?day?

I probably average three hours a day.

Do you think it lives up to its stated goal of “fighting ignorance”? How?

Yes, it fights ignorance if the reader is open. Once I have respect for someone, I’m much more open to what she or he says in general.

What do you think sets the SDMB apart from other message boards?

It’s more person and more intelligent at the same time.

What other MBs do you go to?

I have now abandoned all others.

Which forum do you go to first?

The Pit

Do you lurk more or participate more overall? in any particular forum? on any particular subject?

I probably post in about 60% of the forums that I read all the way through.

Do you enjoy debating, and do you think you hold your own there?

I do enjoy debating, but I’m not focused enough to hold my own. I tend to hijack.

Describe yourself - age, sex, location, occupation, etc. What interests do you have in real life? I’m a 62 year old female from Nashville. I’m an essayist, a poet, a retired teacher, a musician and a grandmother. My interests are Asian design, the author Colette, cinema as art, political activism, my family, mental illness.

What do you see as your standing in the SDMB community? Does that correspond to your standing in real life?

Generally accepted. Liked by those who know me well. Unknown to many. (I’m somewhat of a hermit in real life, but I’m getting out more since I joined SDMB. People seem to react to be positively there too.) Those who don’t like me at SDMB don’t seem to like anyone.

How honestly do you represent yourself online?

Very. I’ve made a point of it. I’m too fuzzy-minded to maintain a front. :slight_smile:

Do you think people here would be surprised by what you are like in real life?

I look younger in real life – and shorter.

Do you find yourself agreeing or disagreeing more often with other members? On what subjects?

The question is really too broad. I agree a lot with liberal posters and disagree with very conservative posters. But there are always exceptions. I disagree with those who think that weight control and depression are a matter of will power. I disagree with those who think that rational thought is the be all and end all.

Are there any rules (official or not) that you disagree with?

Sexist comments are so common that most people probably don’t notice them. It would be interesting to see what would happen if there was a rule against sexist comments just as there is against racist comments. The only rule that I object to is the one that doesn’t permit me to remind people that they might not want to feed the troll.

Who do you see as the leaders of the board?

A cast of thousands

Who on the board do you most look up to? Why?

Now that would be telling, wouldn’t it?

Have you made enemies?

Someone may see me as an enemy. I don’t see anyone as an enemy.

Do you feel like you know the other members well?

Not as well as I would like to in some cases. So no, not really.

How important is the anonymity of the board to you?

In most situations it’s very important. But I have opened up to some and would to others.

Would you want to meet anyone here in real life? Have you? My husband participates at SDMB, but I haven’t met in real life anyone that I’ve gotten to know here. There are several that I wish were a natural part of my real life, but I’m content to leave them here.

What first attracted you to the SDMB?
The main site has always been one of the best resources on the 'net for all sorts of information presented in an accessible and amusing manner, and I was very pleasantly surprised by the warmth of the welcome I received when I made a comment one one of Cecil’s columns.

What do you keep coming back for?
Intelligent and interesting conversation on every subject under the sun, and a far lower percentage of political extremism and - shall we say - eccentric beliefs than most other on-line boards.

How important is the site to you?How much time do you spend per week?day?
Important? Difficult to say. I could live without it, I’d prefer not to. I suppose I spend about five or six hours per day actively reading the site rather than doing anything else.

Do you think it lives up to its stated goal of “fighting ignorance”? How?
Yes. Among the regulars there are true experts on every field of knowledge.

What do you think sets the SDMB apart from other message boards?
See above. :slight_smile: Also, for a US-based board, there’s far less political partisanship than usual. That’s not to say there isn’t any, but very few discussions deterioriate to the Republican/Democrat shouting match that’s so common elsewhere.

What other MBs do you go to?
Fark, The Panda’s Thumb, and various boards associated with a particular fandom which I feel it’s impolitic to mention in public. :wink:

Which forum do you go to first?
GD.

Do you lurk more or participate more overall? in any particular forum? on any particular subject?
I always like to participate in the various religion/philosophy debates we have; mainly because I don’t really have strong views on any other subjects, and my areas of technical expertise are limited.

Do you enjoy debating, and do you think you hold your own there?
Yes, I enjoy it. I don’t think I’m the best person to express an opinion on whether I “hold my own”, but I’ve never felt humiliated - so far.

Describe yourself - age, sex, location, occupation, etc. What interests do you have in real life?
40, Male, Europe (can’t really tie it down more closely than that at the moment), electronics/software. I spend rather more money on artwork than I ought to. :slight_smile:

What do you see as your standing in the SDMB community? Does that correspond to your standing in real life?
“Newbie” - perhaps “Irritating”, but I hope not “Clueless”. I can’t really see any way of comparing that with RL.

How honestly do you represent yourself online?
Hmm. I certainly don’t try and be deceitful on-line, but I know that I’m a completely different person here than I am RL.

Do you think people here would be surprised by what you are like in real life?
Yes.

Do you find yourself agreeing or disagreeing more often with other members? On what subjects?
I don’t think there’s anything I disagree with most other posters about.

Are there any rules (official or not) that you disagree with?
The fact that we can’t even mention A Certain Subject*
that - we can’t mention. :wink: I suppose I would prefer it if we could get medical advice, too, but I appreciate the reasons for that rule, and don’t go so far as to object to it.

Who do you see as the leaders of the board?
I wouldn’t say we had leaders, as such. There are plenty of well-respected individuals, but nobody that “rules”.

Who on the board do you most look up to? Why?
Making a full list of everyone I look up to would take rather too much time. :slight_smile: If I were forced to select one person from the entire membership, though, it would have to be cosmosdan.

Have you made enemies?
Almost certainly.

Do you feel like you know the other members well?
Hmm - I don’t really think I’ve been here long enough.

How important is the anonymity of the board to you?
Not at all.

Would you want to meet anyone here in real life? Have you?
No, and no. RL social interaction is not my strong point.

  • P2P