Hmmmm…let’s see if I can reach into my brain for some of this stuff…
Freshman year: [The Chocolate War, Morgan’s Passing, Our Town, Roll of Thunder Hear My Cry, Let The Circle Be Unbroken, Object Lessons, The House on Mango Street, and a lot of short stories. I’m pretty sure I’m forgetting stuff.
Sophomore year: Beowulf, excerpts from The Canterbury Tales (something of a life-altering experience!), Romeo and Juliet (my first Shakespeare – this was another!), Much Ado About Nothing, A Christmas Carol, Wuthering Heights (bleargh), Jane Eyre, Dubliners (some of it), The French Lieutenant’s Woman. The first semester was far more fun than the second.
At my high school upperclassmen could pick their English classes, so here’s what I did…
Junior year:
Myth, Tale, and Legend: Watership Down, Frankenstein, and a whole lot of folk tales and fairy tales. Obviously. 
Shakespeare: A Midsummer Night’s Dream, 1 Henry IV (another of my formative Shakespeare moments), King Lear, The Tempest, Much Ado About Nothing
Senior year:
Major American Authors: The Scarlet Letter, Ethan Frome (spew!), Daisy Miller, The Great Gatsby, numerous short works and poems
Writing About Literature: Ghosts, Hedda Gabler, Master Harold…and the boys, various poems, various short stories (mostly by Flannery O’Connor), The Wedding
This is probably incomplete – high school was a while back – but close enough. The best class was the Shakespeare one, by far. 