Poll: Will you buy the new 3G iPhone?

I found all this out the hard way. I’ve got a 3mp Samsung 990 and the price difference would have bought a real digital camera that does a lot more. The images are not as good as my old 3mp camera and it is way too slow to take normal pictures. The music player only reads WMA’s and the phone takes an adapter to use the headphones. I can’t store songs in different folders so it’s not a very useful music player. I guess I expected too much of the phone.

It would be great if they made a world phone with a real camera, a real GPS for geochaching, and a real MP3 player for $199.

I agree with all of your points, just wanted to clarify for others who were disappointed in the iPhone’s 2MP camera that a 5MP iPhone camera probably would not make it any better and, more likely, would actually worsen noise. As I’ve said before, the Nokia N90 takes amazingly good photos for a phone and is the best I’ve seen so far from a camera phone.

I was the one who first mentioned the 2MP vs 5MP issue. I should have mentioned that I would like to see 5MP camera phones with the commensurate increase in lens quality, post processing software, and other factors that improve image quality.

If just tacking on 5MP to the existing cell phone cameras will not improve quality, it would be a silly thing to do.

  1. Probably not, although I like seeing the lower price.
  2. No.

It’s not entirely the initial cost of the iPhone that puts me off, it’s the monthly cost, isn’t it like $60 a month for a plan with data?

  1. Yes - For the 3G alone it will be worth buying the new iPhone even if my current one is just a year old.
  2. Yes, but no idea what I’m going to do with it once I get 2.0. (G/F is on Sprint and my mom would never understand how to use it)
  1. No.
  2. No.

It looks really cool, but $200 + $70/mo over 2 years equates to almost $600/yr more than my current phone/plan. That’s a lot of change to spend on a toy. It’s enough that I could buy a new iPod for my music and a new gps every year.

Surely, I’ll get one (or a reasonable clone) in a few years, when they’re free with a 2-year contract and the plan is only $40.

  1. I will be there on launch date, unless I’m able to pre-order it online.
  2. I did buy the current iPhone, but I lost it at Wal-Mart on Sunday, and I’m sure I’ll never get it back. I was pumped to hear about the new ones yesterday.

That’s where I am right now–my ATT contract expires this month. Any more info on this, even if it’s rumor?

Note that the $200 price is already subsidized by AT&T and requires one to sign a two-year contract. (From what I heard, the market research done by Apple said that people were put off by the high cost of the iPhone, so they chose to sell this one cheaper, but let AT&T recover its cost over two years.)

According to this blog post containing an interview with the CEO of AT&T Mobility, the cost will not drop anytime soon, mostly because of the actual device cost.

This is the first phone that would convince me to walk away from 10 years of Palm OS devices. Except AT&T won’t sell service to me. In the majority of this state (pretty much west of Lincoln), AT&T phones work, but only by roaming. And if AT&T’s records indicate the majority of your usage is roaming, they’ll “release you from your contract,” meaning they’ll terminate your service. At which point I would have a non-functioning iPhone.

In the mean time, I’m enjoying my iPod Touch.

The AT&T coverage in my area isn’t very good. Sprint is a bit better, Verizon is the best.

Probably. I’ve been waiting for it to come out here. It has all the stuff I want, little that I don’t want, and has multi-lingual input and read support, which is pretty darn important to me. Contrary to popular belief, Japanese phones aren’t all that great. Smartphone features are not a priority; stuff like TV reception, being able to put shitty little icons on your phone photos, and accessing the internet ghettoes — like DoCoMo’s iMode — that are optimized for regular cell phone screen sizes and controls are.

The problem is that I’m on DoCoMo, which has better coverage than other carriers, and I’m on a family plan that greatly reduces my monthly costs and the cost of calls to family members. The rumors were correct: SoftBank is the carrier that will have the iPhone, which means I’m going to have to switch carriers to use it. I’ll probably wait a bit until the adoption rush dies down first. SoftBank hasn’t had good reliability in the past. I expect the uptake to be substantially less than most other countries, though.

iPods, for example, have less than 60% of the market in electronic music players here, while they’re around 85% in the US. The Xbox 360, while having an incredible game library, with more coming, and a kick-ass online service compared to the PS3’s mostly lagging and lackluster library and very basic online component, is still tanking overall in this market.

The Japanese tend to be very resistant to foreign devices in the first place, and the basic response that most Japanese have had to the iPhone features is, “Meh, there are other phones that have that.” Which of course totally misses the point, as is usual for Japan. The first iPhone didn’t have anything that other smart phones didn’t — if you compared based only on a list of features — but the interface and software design was so good that nearly everyone who actually used one, whether they like or detest Apple in general, has liked the hell out of using it. Customer satisfaction is at 80%* for this thing. That’s totally unheard of in the mobile market.

Still, I expect it to do only moderately well here. It’s not a native brand, and while well designed, it doesn’t have the laundry list of features that Japanese customers expect from a phone. Perversely, most of the stuff that does well overseas doesn’t get much play here. There are native video games and anime that are massively popular overseas that most Japanese have never heard of, while tech and other merchandise that dominates in the West struggles to get any traction at all.

*Rubicon consulting report (PDF) on the iPhone and implications for the mobile market.

  1. yes, when 3G coverage is in my area. it will be a while.
  2. no.