[QUOTE=OtakuLoki]
And, worse, Herotodus was not what modern historians would consider devoted to truth. Am I wrong in this belief, or have I got it right?
[/QUOTE]
Well, he’s been called both “the Father of History” and “the Father of Lies”…
It’s probably fairer to remember that ancients, “writing history,” would never be expected to offer a documented and unbiased account, without interpretation. How boring! A competent writer would be expected to illuminate his source - among other things, it would be thought perfectly reasonable for him to invent conversations which illustrate the character of historical notables. You’d learn to do that in rhetorical school.
As we continue on this thread, it occurs to me that it might be useful to note the fragility of our chain of evidence for rather a lot of the ancient world. Except in odd cases such as dry Egypt, the Dead Sea caves, or a few carbonized papyri, little in the way of original papyrus or parchment manuscripts has survived from the Graeco-Roman world. If they were “unimportant,” they were long ago thrown away or simply decayed through neglect. If they were “important,” they were replaced with new copies; and while we may have the copies, the original is long gone. But some estimates suggest that only 1% of ancient literature has survived at all. And that’s not counting non-literary sources which would have been of enormous value.
One interesting illustrating is the Archimedes Palimpsest: http://www.thewalters.org/archimedes/frame.html
This is a collection of the writings of one of the world’s most famous mathematicians ever. One treatise survives only in this document; another, while also known to us through translations, survives in the original Greek only here.
It is the only surviving copy of this collection, and it is a palimpsest. That means that at one point the owner considered these writings to be of less value than the parchment they were written on; so the material was re-used.
So: here we have two important mathematical treatises from a major figure. They survive (in the original text) only because:
- One Byzantine dynasty thought scholarship was important enough to commission a copy of them.
- A few centuries later, somebody re-used the parchment rather than throwing it out.
Rather a lot of our knowledge of the past depends on links this fragile.