I actually asked almost the exact same question to my 8th grade religion teacher in my confirmation journal-does God love Satan? She answered in the affirmative.
How about:
If pre-marital sex is wrong, then why wasn’t Mary punished? I mean, God didn’t get married to her beforehand!
I was told that Judas’s sin was not the betrayal itself, but that he assumed he couldn’t be forgiven, and hanged himself in despair. If he had expressed remorse to God directly, then he would have been okay.
My friend and I got in trouble for giggling and saying that Jonathan and David were gay. My teacher heard us whispering and yelled out angrily, “NO THEY WERE NOT!!!” (The same teacher told me not to bring “dirty” magazines to school. Which dirty magazines? TEEN. :rolleyes: )
To my rabbi, in hebrew school: “You say that you don’t believe homosexuality is wrong, and that God loves everyone equally, etc. So why won’t you officiate gay commitment ceremonies or even (in terms of congregation memberships) recognize partners as spouses?” His response - kick me out of class.
Also -
-Mom, dad, you don’t really need to see my report card, do you?
-Theoretically, if I were to say that I got a tattoo, how would you react?
-(to my RA) So, say - completely and totally hypothetically - that someone in the dorm managed to start a small fire in their room, and then sort of accidentally broke the smoke detector when they were trying to get it to not go off, is there any way to get that fixed without getting in trouble? Or having anyone notice the, uh, scorch marks on the wall?
This one bothered me a lot too when I attended sunday school. I found Judas fate totally unfair. Someone had to do it, right?? Judas became kind of a hero for me, unjustly reviled for doing his duty.
That’s a bit like my question - Since Noah didn’t have any form of modern transport, how did he manage to collect up 2 each of every animal, bird and insect from across the globe? It would have taken a whole lifetime just to do that, and he still had to build the ark … he had to collect the animals first so that he’d know what size of Ark to build, Right!?
That’s a legitimate question. Betraying Christ was not the sin that damned him to hell; hanging himself and rejecting Christ’s forgiveness was. What kind of wuss priest couldn’t handle that one?
Nope. The http://www.newadvent.org/cathen/05573a.htm ]doctrine of transubstantiation covers that one. Basically, the bread and wine is literally transformed into Jesus’ flesh and blood but still looks and tastes like bread and wine - it still retains its molecular makeup. 'Cause it’s magic cannibalism.