Who?
The title card in Temple of Doom says that it is 1935. However, in Raiders of the Lost Ark, the film begins in “Peru, 1936”.
As far as plot, logic, and continuity holes, Raiders of the Lost Ark has more of them than any three random books of the Old Testament. Even the minor details, like the San Francisco bridge being fully constructed, is wrong. If you actually sit down and think about the movie, not only does it not really make much sense, the hero is actually totally unnecessary. Had he stayed home grading term papers and reading a H. Rider Haggard novel, the result would have essentially been the same; either the Nazis (who followed Jones to Marion Ravenwood) would have never found the Ark at all, or they would have dug it up and been destroyed when they impenitently opened the Ark. And despite Brody’s final protest that the Ark has to be studied, storing it in any anonymous crate in an enormous warehouse where it will no doubt be forgotten is probably the next best thing to burying it back in the sands of Egypt. (The Bond film, Goldfinger, has similar problems.)
Some or much of this is, if not consciously intentional, at least in keeping with the blasé attitude of adventure serials toward factuality and realism. That the film works despite enormous leaps of logic, deus ex machinas, and other absurdities is part of its charm, and is entirely due to the unrelenting (but not overamped) pace of the story and the quality of characterization brought to the roles by the actors. Indiana Jones is clearly indestructible, and yet, you never get the impression in Raiders that he is without fear, even when he is doing things that are beyond foolhardy. Much of the humor comes from his overconfidence leading him into a situation where he suddenly finds himself in unanticipated peril. And the fact that his plans work, if but barely (“I’m making this up as I go along,”) is really his only edge against his opponents.
A preponderance of plot holes and unlikely coincidences doesn’t keep many people from raving about Casablanca being one of the greatest films ever made; again, the quick measured pace, snappy dialogue, involving characters, and a memorable score all make it a crowd pleaser despite its significant story problems.
As far as spotting plot holes, permit me to add a few more. [ul][li]How is it that Jones is traveling to the Peruvian temple with porters and mules though Hovitos territory, but his escape plane is a short run away from the temple?[]Why doesn’t he just climb down from the opening up top (which we can see when he swings across the pit) rather than deal with spiders, spring traps, and a rolling boulder?[]Why did the temple builders make all of these traps (out of bamboo technology, no less) which would have made it risky even for them to enter the temple? []Why and how is there a big statue in the Well of Souls that is just conveniently placed to fall through the wall, even though practically nobody is allowed in there?[]Notice that the Well of Souls is vacuum sealed when the open it up, and yet the snakes are still alive?[/ul][/li]
Stranger