Rank Your Top Ten Rock Bands

I did adjust a couple names like Bruce Sprinsteen was there as himself and as with the E Street Band and Elvis Costello as himself and as with The Attractions etc. If anyone has a problem with how I split it feel free to do your own tally. :wink:

I can post the whole list at some point but if I need to go through and do it again it will make it more difficult.

Thanks to those that followed the number dot space convention, it made it easier to tally. I had to go in and adjust those that didn’t and remove lists included in quotes.

David Bowie almost always had a band. The people he played with changed over the years, but they were hugely important. Mick Ronson helped make David Bowie the rock god he is. So when I listed David Bowie, I mean that to include the other musicians he’s played with over the years. He doesn’t count less than Nine Inch Nails or The Fall, other bands with basically one leader and a revolving door of backing musicians, except he uses his own name.

I know you said to just pick whomever you want, but I wanted to point out why it would be justifiable to include David Bowie anyway.

Hmm. Sure, the makeup of his current band was important. But remember he’s the “chameleon of rock.” He changed every time his band changed. He had a completely different lineup for almost every album. Trent Reznor may use different musicians on different tours, but NIN has always been more cohesive.

Again, not good or bad; just, it makes Bowie more of a “solo” artist in this context, IMO.

My hero!

Violin
Don’t Push Your Foot on the Heart Brake
The Wedding List
Babooshka

:confused:

I’ll have to look all these guys up. This is the first list in this thread that I don’t know a single band (at least by name). Maybe I’ll find someone new that I like. Thanks.

  1. Stevie Ray Vaughn
  2. Pink Floyd
  3. Five Finger Death Punch
  4. Grateful Dead
  5. Lamb of God
  6. Pantera
  7. Black Sabbath
  8. The Beatles
  9. Hatebreed
  10. Jimi Hendrix

You don’t know who Blur and Avril Lavigne are? I’ve never heard of the other 8 (okay, Josie and the Pussycats, but I thought they were fictional) but Blur and Avril Lavigne are massively successful top-40 types.

Well, Avril Lavigne is, Blur were, until Damon Albarn went off to start Gorillaz instead.

Nope…never heard of them.

My 15 yo son knew them though and sounded surprised that I didn’t.

I’ve heard of the Gorillaz before and am pretty sure I didn’t like them.

Damn I feel old right now.

Maybe it helps if you know Blur is pronounced “bluh.”

Blurrrr

  1. XTC
  2. Muse
  3. The Beatles
  4. Talking Heads
  5. King Crimson
  6. The Kinks
  7. The The
  8. REM
  9. The Smiths
  10. Pixies

I’m surprised you didn’t know Bad Brains. Great band, not on my top ten mind you but still great. They influenced a lot of hardcore/punk bands.

Top ten mostly guitar bands, in no particular order, but numbered to aid collation.

  1. Husker Du
  2. Loop
  3. My Bloody Valentine
  4. The Stooges
  5. Joy Division
  6. The Fall
  7. The Smiths
  8. Pixies
  9. Sonic Youth
  10. Buzzcocks

No actual order here:

Radiohead
The Smiths
Joy Division
The Cure
Neil Young
The Smithereens
The Chameleons
REM
Psychedelic Furs

Honorable Mention goes to:
CSNY
Traffic (and Steve Winwood)
Elvis Costello
Doves
Portishead
Massive Attack
New Order
INXS
Brian Eno
Echo and the Bunnymen
Talking Heads
Rage Against the Machine
Cake
Red Hot Chilipeppers
Beatles
Tears for Fears

Is this cheating?

Oh and Pearl Jam and Soundgarden

Clearly I am not in touch with other on this board. No love for Jackson Browne? a little love for AC/DC? and Boston?

scrolling through the list, I can see many other favorites (Talking Heads), and some that I don’t like at all, (which I won’t list). I am glad to see mention of *Uriah Heep *and the Dead Kennedys. And I relieved to see that The Vapors have not been mentioned.

thanks for starting the thread, RNATB.

Yah, I mostly just posted that list to shake things up, but they are all fairly well-known, and I DO like all of them. I would def look some of them up – they’re not all going to appeal to every taste, but I bet almost everyone would find at least one they like in it.

I was fairly stunned to see that Cream and The Pixies are both only nominated twice.

My list:

1-Def Leppard
2-Rush
3-The Beatles
4-Metallica
5-Genesis
6-Led Zepplin
7-INXS
8-Van Halen [DLR era]
9-Aerosmith
10-Helloween

Perhaps because Cream had a fairly short life and the Pixies don’t get heard very much any more. But you are right that those are great bands.