Could a mod fix the thread title? It’s buggin’ me.
I haven’t read that book, but I have taken part in just such SCA discussions, with folks who really believe that, come TEOTWAWKI (the end of the world as we know it; Google the acronym and you’ll find some strange folks), we’d be the ruling class because we have home-made armor and know how to fight with wooden sticks. (Which I’ve been doing for many years; but I tend to think that certain other skills would be more useful.)
I did read the passage where the bad, evil SCA guy shows how evil he is by arming prisoners and then, wearing chainmail and using a shield and sword, killing them. Seemed like bullshit to me; I could take that guy. And the writing was pretty bad.
Not only that, but Dies the Fire sounds to me like a ripoff of the 1981 novel Ariel, by Steven R. Boyett. It’s a fun read; a little rough, but quite good considering that he was 21 when he wrote it.
Edited to correct coding, and to wish Zsofia good luck with her cervix. Did you get the vaccine?
That is a thread I started and got a ton of good responses. I found some really great reads on it.
Oryx and Crake
I Am Legend
The Handmaid’s Tale
Parable of the Sower
Alas, Babylon -Probably still one of my favs and I went into the thread having read it.
Those were probably my favorites, but I’m still on the kick. It’s a fun one.
I’m just finishing Meeting at Corvallis–the last book in the “later” series. Not “fine literature”–but highly addictive. In alternative history, I can forgive less than subtle characterization if the world is built well. And Stirling’s stuff isn’t as macho as some. He’s got warrior women as well as warrior men!
Stirling’s The Peshawar Lancers shows a very different post apocalyptic world–several generations after a huge comet destroyed most of “Western Civilization.” Truly a ripping yarn & definitely in need of a sequel–or prequel.
(I agree with most of those here about the “classic” stories in the genre. You know, the artier ones.)
I was going to mention The Handmaid’s tale by Atwood as well, I had to study that for A-level and it was a great read - although it’s getting a bit too uncomfortable to reality for me at the moment.
No, no – I wouldn’t keep doing it if I didn’t like it. But there are many silly aspects to my chosen hobby.
ETA: I just realized you were talking about hating Dies the Fire; sorry. I haven’t read the whole book, but did in fact dislike what I read; both stupid and badly written. Kind of a personal wankfest for the author, I think.
Has anybody mentioned Lot’s Daughter? Actually, I think that was one of a series of short stories, by Ward Moore (and I may be wrong about the author, too). In the 1950s and '60s, the possibility of WWIII knocking civilization to smithereens overnight was a constant background for science fiction stories.
In the 1960s there was a remarkable series of novels by J.G. Ballard, depicting various world-ending (or at least world-changing) scenarios:
The Wind From Nowhere; involves a wind. From nowhere.
The Burning World, vt The Drought.
The Drowned World; heightened output by the Sun melts all the ice and turns much of the Earth into sweltering tropics. (It occurs to me that part of that book, where they’re blocking off and draining a section of a flooded city to recover some of what’s left of the past, is echoed in a passage in Kim Stanley Robinson’s Blue Mars.)
The Crystal World; really strange one involving some phenomenon that is crystallizing both plants and animals.
This is from memory; hope I’ve got it right. I guess these might be considered apocalyptic rather than post-apocalyptic.
I remember a novel called (if I remember) Riddley Walker, set in Britain; that was pretty good.
I liked it a lot, and I dabble in SCA-like things. I guess I have the ability to be vastly amused by the more obsessed folks idiosyncrasies, though. Or I find it easy to just nod and smile.
I agree with others that it’s not great literature, though. It’s just addictive, like potato chips. The beginning while they’re all trekking hither and yon on bicycles is pretty annoying, though.
If you recall, they weren’t just prisoners - they were cops and soldiers. Every time somebody said something like, “I’m involved in an organization where we do fighting that’s as close as you can come to hardcore medieval combat without getting killed!” I had to stifle my gales of laughter so the nurses wouldn’t think something weird was going on in Examining Room 4. One assumes the author has seen SCA combat?
And yeah, I guess that familiarity with the reenactor set does breed some dislike of the book - trust me, most of those Blessed Be types? They’re going to be the first ones we eat. (And there’s gonna be a lot of calories on 'em, too, so it will be a very efficient use of our time and effort.)
PS - yes, I did get the vaccine, but I’ll have to pay for it myself - I asked about it last year, when I was 26 (the last “recommended” year) and they didn’t have it yet, and I forgot about it, and now I’m too old and the insurance will probably not cover it. Also, my arm hurts, and I have to go back for two more shots. Worth it, though, if it does what it’s supposed to do.
Yeah, the Blessed Be types drove me absolutely wild. Both in real life and in the book, though I find them slightly more tolerable in real life. Maybe I haven’t run into the truly hardcore ones in real life though – or maybe I’m just really intimidating with my agnosticism. Yeah, that’s it.
Riddley Walker is pretty good, too, though many find it frustrating to read. It’s in a speculative version of what English could develop to after the apocalypse, and it’s written kind of stream of consciousness style. Reading the most challenging parts aloud helps, but it’s pretty slow going all the same.
A bit off topic, but if you didn’t like that particular series by Stirling, do give The Conquistadors a try. I couldn’t get through any of that stupid series, but I did like that stand alone book a lot.
Gwyneth Jones (not the opera singer) has written a fascinating series beginning with Bold As Love. This particular apocalypse has mostly damaged the (former) UK and Europe. And our main characters are trying to save the world–with love & rock & roll.
It’s about time for me to reread these fascinating books. I picked up a copy of the first one at Half Price Books & have diligently sought out the sequels. Perhaps they are considered “too British” for us Yanks?
One of the best such novels I have read is This is The Way The World Ends by * James Morrow*. One of the most emotionally affective books I’ve read. Highly recommended.
I guess you could describe After Worlds Collide as post-apocalyptic. But when it takes place, Earth has been totally destroyed and the book is entirely set on a different planet, so it’s really more a story of colonizing a new world.
