I’ll agree with this, but tweak it from my own experience. I was a teacher for 10 years, but departed for another career more than 15 years ago. To me, it was never about the money. It wasn’t even really about “respect”, exactly. I came to feel more and more micromanaged, with my discretion for actual teaching eroded over time. Nobody intended to disrespect me as a teacher, they just took away my ability to do the job.
One of the problems is how schools utilize research and data. Numerous times I saw a push for changes to curriculum and teaching technique based on new research that was aggressively pursued for a while, and then dropped for various reasons. Whereas individual teachers who were good at what they did were sometimes prevented from doing it their way.
I think it’s important to realize that teaching isn’t a “science”. It can and should be informed by science, research and data. But in the end it’s adult humans interacting with little humans, which is closer to an art (for the people who are good at it). In my mind this makes teaching a “craft”, and it’s hard to scale that up.
So I believe there should be a form of “best practices” that teachers should get trained on, but largely leave the details up to them. Whereas the current system prefers to take away that sort of discretion and try to make it uniform. That’s a failing strategy, in my opinion.
I was one of the people trying to do it well, and doing it differently from certain traditional models that were no longer useful. For a while I felt supported doing that, but over time my freedom to act was curtailed.
I found myself saying to a principal one day, “I have ten years experience, a master’s degree and I’m published in my field. At what point are you going to trust me to use some of my own judgement?” There was no good answer to that question, and I soon exited for another career.
It’s sad, the way I see it - they convinced a pretty good teacher that it would be better to go do something else. I didn’t expect complete autonomy, or for administration to cater to my every whim. But if I’d been given more discretion to be the professional I was, I might still be there.
Edit: I have no doubt everything is much worse these days. Even then, shortly after I quit, I would run into former colleagues who each told me I got out “just in time”.