Should I buy expensive cat food?

Where is Michelle to answer this question?

I read several startling facts concerning pet food in America, especially the cheaper and cheapest brands, in that there is no regulation as to what goes in them. Read the label and the higher up the list of contents SALT is, the higher the salt content in the food to make it tasty for the pet, who probably would not eat the shit without it.

In the last 30 years, the increase in cancer in pets has come from something like 1 in 200 to 1 in 3 because pet food makers add things forbidden in human foods. PLUS, several places buy up discarded meats from grocery stores, run this stuff through a process cooking and rending it. The meat is ground up and dumped into the petfood – no problem there. Things like diseased beef goes in it because it cannot be sold to humans, along with horse meat, diseased unsalable pork, chicken, fish remains and anything else food producers cannot convince congress is not really poisonous to humans. (The meat industry, idiotically, started grinding up beef neck meat for hamburger. There is a gland in the cows neck with produces hormones – thyroid – and hormones do not get destroied when cooked. Being too cheap to dispose of this meat, they used it and, some years back, people started popping up with thyroid problems and were put on pills. It took a while for disease control to discover what was going on and make the meat producers stop using that gland.)

**WHAT IS A PROBLEM, THOUGH ** is that they often ‘forget’ to take off the plastic wrappings the meat is still in when the grocer dumps it out. Plus, several companies accept road kill from counties and euthanized pets from vets. So, your sweet, furry, loving, fluffy and well loved cat is probably eating parts of Fido down the street who died from cancer, or poor, old Kitty, who was euthanized because of leukemia – and the chemicals remain in the meat. (Real cheap places don’t bother to skin the donations either.) Plus, that chicken-flavored food is probably 25% chicken parts --(DON’T ASK WHAT PARTS) – 25% squashed, rabid raccoon, squashed, aged squirrel, squashed Opossum, and squashed bird. Then the rest will be filler – third grade corn, wheat, rye, bone meal, organ meat (NICE dose of pituitary gland hormones included to screw up your pet), flour and assorted salts, preservatives and human proscribed color dyes.

Many fish cat foods, if you take time to look, have large chunks of bone in them, which most cats will spit out. Cats do have a tendency to get bladder problems and this extra calcium contributes to bladder stones.

You can have your pet food custom made – which the maker will cheerfully charge you about 4 times it’s value but it is, with a good maker, the best. You can have your vet suggest pet food, and safely take his advice, but you will pay more, especially for the Science Diet – which few pets like because it is GOOD for them and has less salt and flavor additives. The top brand pet foods are best, second grades are OK, and the cheap-o’s are the worst.

For a cat, it would be best to rotate it’s flavors because they tend to be affected by calcium and a high seafood, steady diet is not all that good. A bit of top grade dry food for them to crunch on in-between meals is good for them also. Unlike most dogs, they will eat until full and snack a little if it is there – not wolf it all down and beg for more.

Since there is no pet food regulations, the food is mostly carcinogenic, though you’d have to threaten to cut the balls off of the corporate owners to get them to admit it. Pet foods with high vegetable content are good also, but only in the high grades.

You want your pet to live longer and better without having to pay enormous vet bills? Write to congress about regulating the pet food industry. Until you do, several major companies will continue to sell you pet foods which will more than likely shorten the life of your pet.


What? Me worry?’

And while you are waiting for the proper regulations to kick in, cook your cats’ food. THANK YOU Rainbow, for all that information! This info is exactly what my sister found on the internet, and what prompted us to cook the cats’ food. We have had more cats die of cancer or other weird and scary diseases in the last few years. Our family has always had lots of cats, and never before have so many died in such awful ways until recently. Something is not right.

See the recipe I posted above. It’s not a hard recipe, or terribly expensive. For one cat, that recipe should last longer than a week. (Just put each portion in a little tupperware container - or any little plastic container - and put it in the freezer until it’s ready to serve.)

My sister’s very ill cat got immediate relief after he started eating this food made from recipe. It really is commercial cat food that is making our kitties ill. It isn’t some inconcievable thing for you to cook a batch of cat food up once a week - especially when the alternative is that your kitty will quite possibly get ill, be miserable, and cost you lots in vet bills.

We went from Purina Mature to Iams when one of our three cats developed idiopathic feline hepatic lipidosis. What a mouthful. The switch got him eating and he bulked back up (otherwise it’d likely be lethal without stomach tube intervention) but the other cats have certainly gotten chubby. We’re now transitioning them to Iams’ older cat formula, so the “too yummy” weight gain problem should take care of itself in a while. We definitely notice less litter box contents, as previously mentioned. Worth the extra price, personally (without addressing all those disease and hormone issues, though).

An important thing about changing your cat’s diet though: make sure they eat the new stuff!! After having to look up hepatic lipidosis, I was amazed to find that a 3-day fast, regardless of cause, is enough to bring on the condition. The cat then looses the urge to eat and it just spirals down from there. Overweight cats are especially susceptible for some reason. :frowning:


Sure, I’m all for moderation – as long as it’s not excessive.

**Rainbowscr</b< writes:

No, you’re wrong.
In the last thirty years, due partially to the fact that veterinary medicine has improved, and due partially to the fact that people no longer view a cat being squashed by a car or killed by a raccoon as an inevitable end, the lifespan of cats has increased greatly. In 1970, 12 years was considered a good age for a cat; now, 17 or 18 is considered normal, and 20-year-old cats are far from uncommon.
One thing that we know is that cancer, in both animal and humans, is due to an accumulation of biological insults to the cells’ DNA. Oh, there are a (very) few cancers that seem actually due to viruses, and perhaps we’ll change our minds about some others, but carcinogenesis is actually well established. Extending the lives of our pets as we have, it’s no wonder that they are dying of acute diseases, same as people do now that the average person can reasonably expect to outlive childhood.
I’ve heard the same figures, incidentally, with regard to human carcinogensis. Those figures are pure nonsense; I don’t have the numbers at my fingertips for animals as well as people, but I strongly suspect that they’re nonsense as well.
Is canned or bagged cat food perfect nutrition and free of all toxic substances? Of course not; neither are human foodstuffs. They tend to be a darn sight that the alternatives, though. I recall the scandal when it was discovered that many cat foods contained insufficient taurine, an animo acid which is necessary for sight in cats. The major cat food manufacturers corrected that deficiency quickly; ideologues promoting home-prepared vegetarian diets are still dragging their heels over it.


“I don’t just want you to feel envy. I want you to suffer, I want you to bleed, I want you to die a little bit each day. And I want you to thank me for it.” – What “Let’s just be friends” really means

Well, I think Cecil has addressed this, but you cannot make a cat vegetarian!! Dogs, yes apparently, but cats NO!

It will be detrimental to your cat’s health, if it doesn’t outright kill the poor thing, if you make it vegetarian!

here is the link to Cecil’s column: http://www.straightdope.com/columns/960426.html


“I celebrate myself, and sing myself, and what I assume you shall assume, for every atom belonging to me as good belongs to you.” --Whitman