Sitcom Madness 08: The First Round

I. Family Shows
Andy Griffith
The Brady Bunch
Home Improvement
The Fresh Prince of Bel Air
The Cosby Show
Roseanne
Good Times
The Donna Reed Show

II. Workplace Shows
MASH
The Bob Newhart Show
Frasier
Taxi
Newhart
(skip–never seen either)
(skip–never seen either)
Mary Tyler Moore

III. Buddy Shows
(skip–can’t stand Seinfeld, never seen Different World)
Bosom Buddies
Drew Carey
The Many Loves of Dobie Gillis
The Facts of Life
Welcome Back, Kotter
(skip–never seen either)
Three’s Company

Odd-ball/Surreal Shows
(skip–can’t stand either)
ALF
(skip–never seen either)
The Addams Family
Mork & Mindy
(skip–never seen either)
The Munsters
Bewitched

(In a few cases where people might be tempted to think I have no taste whatsoever, I probably have only seen one of the two choices and don’t totally hate it. When I hated both or didn’t see either, I just declined to vote)

I. Family Shows
Andy Griffith
The Brady Bunch
All in the Family
I Love Lucy
Malcolm in the Middle
Happy Days
Good Times
The Donna Reed Show

II. Workplace Shows
MASH
Cheers
Frasier
Taxi
Newhart
WKRP in Cincinnati
Barney Miller
Mary Tyler Moore

III. Buddy Shows
Seinfeld
Bosom Buddies
VS. Drew Carey
Will & Grace
The Odd Couple
Welcome Back, Kotter
That 70s Show
Three’s Company

IV. Odd-ball/Surreal Shows
The Beverly Hillbillies
Green Acres
3rd Rock from the Sun
The Addams Family
Herman’s Head
Sledgehammer!
The Munsters
I Dream of Jeanie

And there’s the horn!

After the first round, we have a few surprises, few blow-outs and several nail-biters.

Here are the results:

I.
Andy Griffith 34, Mad About You 25
Everybody Loves Raymond 22, Brady Bunch 37
All in the Family 40, Home Improvement 19
I Love Lucy 33, Fresh Prince 26
Cosby Show 33, Malcolm in the Middle 26
Roseanne 31, Happy Days 27
Leave it to Beaver 28, **Good Times 29 ** (a come-from-behind nail-biter!)
Donna Reed 17, **Arrested Development 40 **

II.
MASH 50, Sanford & Son 9
Cheers 32, Bob Newhart 27
Frasier 39, 30 Rock 18
Taxi 37, NewsRadio 22
Newhart 48, Frank’s Place 10
WKRP 46, Sports Night 11
Barney Miller 31, The Office 27 (another close last-minute rally)
Mary Tyler Moore 32, Scrubs 26

III.
Seinfeld 52, Different World 5
Friends 41, Bosom Buddies 11
Laverne & Shirley 13, Drew Carey 46
Will & Grace 34, Dobie Gillis 24
Odd Couple 49, Facts of Life 10
Welcome Back, Kotter 50, Martin 9
My Name is Earl 32, That 70s Show 25
Three’s Company 31, Golden Girls 28

IV.
Beverly Hillbillies 54, Small Wonder 3
Green Acres 36, ALF 23
3rd Rock 46, Mr. Ed 12
Addam’s Family 52, Sabrina the Teenage Witch 7
Mork & Mindy 43, Herman’s Head 16
Soap 43, Sledgehammer! 12
Munsters 43, Get a Life 25
I Dream of Jeanie 20, Bewitched 38

I’ll have the next round up shortly.

A couple personal comments and observations:

-Biggest disappointment is the early departure of ‘The Office,’ ‘Scrubs’ and ‘30 Rock.’
-Biggest surprise: The trouncing ‘Bewitched’ gave to ‘Jeanie.’ Who’d have thought a hot, subserviant and scantily-clad genie would beat out a head-strong witch of a housewife?
-Biggest blow-outs: ‘Beverly Hillbillies’ over ‘Small Wonder,’ and ‘Seinfeld’ over ‘A Different World.’
-Most surprising show not to score in double digits: ‘Sanford & Son.’ However, it was going up against powerhouse ‘MASH.’

The Good: Everybody Loathes Raymond is gone fast. Ditto Malcolm.

The Bad: Bosom Buddies and Dobie Gillis get no respect.

The Ugly: Lucy is still in it. :frowning:

Damn. Sports Night didn’t make it. :frowning:

If Taxi and The Addams Family don’t make the finalists, I will be severely disappointed.