Stereotype of the Jolly/Funny Fat Guy

Paul Johnson’s Humorists may be the worst book on humor ever written. And that’s not even getting into its million inaccuracies.

However, it is true that Laurel was the writer of the team. And also the funnier of the two.

Yeah, I don’t think Daniel Lambert is the kind of fat we’re talking about in this thread.

The article doesn’t say anything about him being teased or bullied, but it does say that he became rich and respected.

Exapno Mapcase:. And then there’s the title character of H.G Wells’s wonderful short story, “The Truth About Pyecraft.” An obese London clubman, desperate to drop pounds, implores the narrator to share one of his Indian great-grandmother’s magical “recipes.”

Weeks later he gets a message “Worked only too well — loss of weight almost complete. COME. Pyecraft.”

Narrator arrives at Pyecraft’s lodgings to find him bobbing about the ceiling “like a massive blowfly.”

Also: PUNCH cartoon c. 1900: (Obese woman trying to enter a narrow streetcar door)
“Sideways, madam! Sideways!”
“Bless ye, sor, I ain’t GOT no zideways!”

You left out those parts.

Also check out this article, which is somewhat gloomier.

Some people were impressed with his weight and with Lambert, but that certainly doesn’t mean that everyone was. People then were no different than today. Some were good people and many were assholes.

From the “somewhat gloomier” article:

From the post right above yours:

Dionysus/Bacchus wasn’t depicted as fat or even beer-bellied. Usually, in fact, he was … quite cut. See the Ludovisi Dionysus, for instance.

Somewhat dependent on the era in question.

( :smiley: )

Or do an image search on Bacchus for some not-at-all cut depictions.

Stories of his bulk… lol

I mean the Classical depictions, not a modern one that owes *much *more to Silenus than Bacchus.

Link to some Classical ones, then. All the fat Bacchuses I see are either later, or sometimes mislabelled sileni. Or infants, sure.

That’s not true of any culture where warriors gain wealth and power. Julius Caeser wouldn’t have been fat, nor William The Conqueror, nor any successful vikings.