Storage Wars vs. Auction Hunters

I have a relative that was interested in this stuff, so I’ve watched some blocks of Storage Wars in the past couple weeks and caught a little bit of Auction Hunters. (So I can’t really comment on the latter.) I DVR the show so I can skip thru the bidding and such which is boring and then some.

They are clearly seeding the lockers in Storage Wars. Darell’s son buys a tiny locker full of women’s clothes and in the middle of it are Shelley Duvall’s Olive Oyl shoes from Popeye, complete with certificate of authenticity. Yeah, right.

I know they are skipping over some of the less interesting lockers, but in some episodes the Dotsons opening mentions how many lockers are up for sale and they’ve been numbers as low as 4-6 and still a couple of the buyers find treasures. The odds just don’t add up.

(I also suspect the producers are subsiding their stars so that they win enough lockers to fill a show.)

The only thing about the seeding issue is that sometimes the item is visible before the auction. E.g., the pool cue stand that Barry won. OTOH, there is no reason to believe that the footage of the locker was actually taken before the auction and not staged afterwards.

While it might seem ridiculous that someone would leave hundreds of poker chips and cash in a locker, well, that stuff happens. There was even the locker with the Jaguar that was going to auctioned off at some other time. (Which still didn’t stop people from talking about how much it would go for. Uh, Laura said it wasn’t included so forget it you idiots.)

Yeah, the estimates of value of as they are cleaning out the units are stupid. They get excited about DVD players and even old video games. Most of these are worthless even if they power on, which they probably don’t. And don’t get me started on the claims for the value of 20-30 year old TVs.

And “That fridge is worth $300.” No it isn’t. It was a $300 fridge when it was new. It’s not a nice side-by-side or anything. And you have no idea if it even still works. Plus you have to put in a lot of effort to move it, check it out, etc. One thrift store in our area has a professional appliance guy who checks and fixes things before they put them out. Even then an ordinary fridge is like $150 and he’s donating his time. Sheesh.

Other annoyances: Hesert gets excited about finding a Strad and takes it in for appraisal and it’s junk of course. Clearly a plant and clearly he was acting. An experienced guy like him would know it was a fake and not start doing the retirement money talk.

Hesert is my least favorite. Phony braggart loser. If the others are right and his business is going under, well, that’s good.

Barry is my fave. Especially since he’s only it for the fun of getting something interesting. The money doesn’t matter.

Darrell is a multi-time loser and this show is going to put him thru another cycle. Oh well.

Jarrod and Brandi at least are not actually married so the divorce isn’t going to be messy. But there are kids involved which won’t be good.

Laura Dotson needs to do a calendar.

My concern is that these shows will tempt too many people with borderline finances into going into this business. Unless you have a cheap storefront where you can sell thousands of $1 items a week, you are going to lose your shirt.

And why doesn’t everyone bring a working flashlight with them? Good grief.

There were (I think) two specials, one an end-of-season-one special, and another one where they just talked about the show, introduced the spinoff people (apparently here in TX), etc. The one I didn’t watch was where they auctioned off a motorcycle - that’s still on the TIVO.

They didn’t exactly say that Brandi stripped, but they were very coy and hesitant about where they met… “Brandi was a… hostess… at a business that I managed”, then there have been a couple of comments in past episodes that hinted that she stripped, including one about “Brandi always has to bring the conversation about stripping” from Jarrod. You don’t necessarily speak like this if you met your wife while she was doing secretarial work for your Dad’s company. :wink:

The one thing I definitely think is staged on Auction Hung ers is the “Negotiation”. Not necessarily the final price, but the back and forth haggling. I gotta believe the saile is agreed to before the show the “negotiation”.

One show I always suspected of seeding was Scrapheap Challenge/Junkyard Wars. The show featured two teams of three or four people who were asked to build a machine to do something (throw an item, or crush a car, say) out of what they could find in a scrapheap/junkyard. I found it hard to believe that the teams could find some of the things they used to build their machine in a typical junkyard (although I can’t remember an example).

As for Auction Hunters, of course it is fake. Look at Allen Haff’s previous credits on IMDB and you’ll see that he’s an actor.

Brandi’s cute. So Storage Wars has a definite advantage over Auction Hunters.

Umm, lots of folks in Los Angeles who are actors do others things as well. Most likely his connections in the entertainment industry allowed him to make a show out of what he does to actually pay the rent.

He may well be an actor, and seems to have done a few very tiny bit parts, but it does seem he has the background for the Auction Hunters job: from the IMDB:

In real life, he’s a very nice guy - friendly, happy to discuss the show and pleased to meet fans. I was in Newport on vacation over the summer and decided to drop in his consignment store to see what it was like. I was surprised to find him working behind the counter, and he seemed really amused that someone from Ohio took the time to visit. He chatted with my teenage son and my stepbrother, and asked us if we wanted to take a photo.

Obligatory yuuuuuuuuuuuuup! (pardon my bedraggled appearance - I had been on a boat in the rain all morning and was sunburnt to boot)

I was amused about everyone hating Dave until Mark shows up with his huge bankroll and disco-era outfits. Then Dave gets the “He may be an asshole, but he’s our asshole” treatment, and everyone gangs up on Mark.

I’m still not entirely sure what Darrell does for a living. Jarrod and Dave run their stores, Barry pretty much junks anything that’s not interesting, but Darrell, when he does buy a locker, claims to be getting the same time of prices Dave/Jarrod are, but with no obvious means of selling. Where does he unload a pile of women’s clothes and a cheap mirror?

He talks on several episodes about “filling tables at the swap meet”, so I assume that’s at least part of the way he unloads junk.

I didn’t understand the motivation of that guy Mark. So what if he’s got a big bankroll and can outbid the others for storage units? The real question is whether he can make money when he bids up the prices that high.

My wife and I theorize that the guy isn’t really all there mentally and that he comes from a wealthy family that doesn’t mind humoring him. Anybody else see the $13,000 NES episode? He essentially saw some eBay bid for a NES that went for $13k and figured that (a) all old NES’s would go for that amount, and (b), the eBay bid was a legitimate bid. Nobody sane could believe that! :wink:

By that measurement every show is fake. California is filled with people who want to act and just might have a threadbare IMDb page.

hah! good find! he strikes me as a huge phony, must be that he’s just a bad actor. i’m going with that show being 100% fake, and i want to believe that storage wars is real. plus i don’t think brandi was a stripper, i swear jarrod said it was a restaurant or something like that. but, i would like to see brandi strip :slight_smile:

btw, it’s dave hester for those saying hesert. and i hate him, he’s so arrogant.

barry ticks me off (but i love him)how he just trashes everything in search of one special item…

and i’m pretty sure they are getting paid well since jarrod and brandi are sporting a new car or truck all the time. do thrift stores really make a huge profit?

lol i got to see him die in the trailer for altered species. yay!

I LOVE Auction Hunters. I cannot stop watching.

Storage Wars, not so much. Probably just because I don’t like wanting to punch people, and I want to punch Dave.

Seriously, there is no actual business advantage in being a dick.

And many of them end up in fake “reality shows”.

I am still watching and this is pissing me off.

Saw a repeat of episode where he bought a locker with several art pieces. There was one without a frame and he didn’t know the artist but said ‘I would ask $500 for that’ and the counter went up 500 bucks.

I was thinking ‘you may ask for 500 you ain’t getting 500’.

I saw that episode and I knew of the auction before the episode. It was a legit auction, but the big ticket item wasn’t the console. It was the mint copy of Bandai Stadium Events bundled with it, which is like the second rarest NES cartridge ever.