The people who get prosecuted for TV license evasion are seldom mavericks keen on testing the limits of state power.
The reality is rather sad. They are often mothers at home looking after the children who are poor, maybe living on welfare. Imagine the scene: the kids are watching Childrens BBC and then suddenly the TV licensing people knock on the door and ask their mother two questions: Do you have a TV? Do you have a license? If the answer is Yes and No they write it on their clip board and go away. Then a few weeks later a Court Summons will be delivered charging them with license evasion. If they ignore it, they will get a fine of about £200 or so for a first offence. If they don’t pay the fine the court has the power to jail them.
This happened to a friend of mine some years ago and he decided to have his day in court and explain the family circumstances before the magistrates. He went to a court house and asked the clerk. The clerk looked at him as if he was mad. Then simply said ‘Name?’ and then rummaged through a big stack of Court papers intended for the attention of the Magistrate until he found the one with my friends name on it. It held it up between his two fingers and then dropped it into the waste paper bin and smiled and said “Good day!” and that was that. He said it reminded him of a Monty Python sketch.
The way it seemed to work is that the magistrate just goes through the pile of papers stamping each one with a verdict and standard fine.
In the past the local newspapers would regularly list all the miscreants who had been fined in this way.
Harassment by bombarding people with letters written in intimidating language is obviously the most cost effective means of intimidating people into paying the license fee. Then comes the ‘detectives’ who knock on doors and ask the two questions. At the same time all the TV ads and propaganda about detectors vans stalking the streets with their ever so sophisticated technology to reinforce the message that there in no escape. They also now require you to log into BBC iPlayer and I expect they try to harass you by email suggesting they know you are watching via streaming so pay up.
Sure the BBC has some good quality TV and has editorial independence from the politicians. But it comes at the cost of collecting a tax that is regressive, penalising the poorest people in the community.
Eventually this will have to change.
Sadly, there does not seem to be a model out there that reconciles the need for a revenue stream for public broadcasting yet keeps the politicians off its back. We are stuck with this antiquated and oppressive licensing system that amounts to BBC’s dirty laundry.
The BBC gets £3.7 billion from the UK license payers out of £4.89 billion of total income.
I do wonder if it could be totally self financing if it tried harder to sell a streaming service around the world.
I guess the Britbox service is a step in that direction.
Though it would not be simple, as this article explains.
https://www.tvlicenceresistance.info/forum/index.php/topic,17669.0.html