(hey, by page 3 there’s no point in nominating what other folks have already acclaimed. OK, OK, the list has to have Physical Graffiti and Who’s Next. All right, Led Zep IV also. but you knew that)
Can we just acknowledge that no one wants to be confined to 5 albums, and start talking about what belongs in the top 15?
Oh, and Pink Floyd — Obscured by Clouds
and Melissa Etheridge — Yes I Am
and Julieta Venegas belongs in there, but no particular album
and Jefferson Airplane — Surrealistic Pillow, can’t forget your roots, folks
I don’t want to hijack this thread like your Beatles thread was with semantic debates, but I do have to say that most of the music listed here I’d call “rock” rather than “rock & roll” - it’s a useful distinction in my mind, but I guess it probably doesn’t matter to most people. Anyway, since most “classic rock” bores me stiff, the albums I crank up and scream along to are:
Hüsker Dü - New Day Rising The Replacements - Pleased To Meet Me The Clash - The Clash Gang Of Four - Entertainment! Buzzcocks - Singles Going Steady
Kinda surprised by how many people picked Who’s Next as a rocking album - aside from “Baba O’Riley” and “Won’t Get Fooled Again”, most of it seems pretty mellow to me. Their 60s stuff was a lot more aggressive.
What is all this talk of entire albums? No single album is full of decent driving tracks anyhow. No. What you want is one single song on infinite repeat. And that is: Roadrunner by Jonathan Richman.
Throw in Motorhead’s Ace of Spades when you need to do some overtaking.
Twickster. I caught the same tour, but at the Winterland in San Francisco! This one was memorable for two events: Roger Daltry spinning the mike around his head, getting it wrapped around his neck and clocking him in the side of the face… AND… Keith Moon passing out behind his drum set and the Who inviting a guy from the crowd to finish the set with some extended jams.
No doubt I show my age in saying this, but despite the different categories and sub-categories of music which have long existed, I remember all popular music of the younger generation being referred to as"rock 'n roll."
I mean, rockabilly, hard rock, glam rock, heavy metal, punk etc etc would be separately identified, but didn’t the expression “rock 'n roll” kinda/sorta encompass all that?
That expression “sex, drugs, and rock 'n roll” wasn’t just for Mick Jagger types.
(Or Keith Moon!)