I only just ‘discovered’ Revolver in September. I mean, I knew the most famous songs off it – “Good Day Sunshine,” “Yellow Submarine,” “Here There and Everywhere,” “Eleanor Rigby,” and “Got to Get You Into My Life” (although I was shocked by the latter, because I always thought it was a song from Paul’s Wings period – confused because of its release as a single in the mid-1970s when I was a wee thing). When I listened to the whole thing for the first time, I just fell. in. love. Especially with “Taxman,” “Tomorrow Never Knows,” “And Your Bird Can Sing” and “Love You To.” I don’t even know how I hadn’t heard “Taxman” before; I’d heard of it – I pretty much knew the title of almost every Beatles song, even if I’d never heard 'em – but somehow avoided the actual song.
What made me ‘discover’ the album was listening to a fabulous George Martin interview / analysis of the song production on the BBC in celebration of the box set release. The panel discussed “Taxman” and “Tomorrow Never Knows” in depth, taking them apart piece by piece from the drums to the incredible guitar work to the Leslie speaker effect used for John’s voice in TNK, and I was astounded.
Until September I’d have easily called Abbey Road my favorite Album. Now Revolver is tied. In both cases, I love every song, with the weakest songs in both for me being only “Yellow Submarine” and “Octopus’s Garden,” although they’re both enjoyable confections.
In fact I’ve even started to ration myself with Revolver: I don’t let myself listen to it more than once a week, because I don’t want to lose the freshness of my adoration for it.
By the way, I strongly recommend Everything Was Right: The Beatles Revolver, a two-hour radio documentary (available with a free account at PRX.org) by Paul Ingles and a panel of guests who dissect each song. Some of the Beatles experts here will probably find this all old hat, but I think many will find this analysis utterly fascinating.
To me, the Beatles didn’t have a peak. I think they started out as a remarkably high level, then built to a crescendo with Help and stayed there, with minor dips only for Magical Mystery Tour, The Beatles (some of the songs seem self-indulgent to me) and then a more significant dip with Let It Be (more self-indulgence–I can’t stand the “jokey” shtick they added in, not to mention Phil Spector’s ridiculous orchestral crap). But even on those, the jewels remaining would be the best from any other group. Considering their last recording was Abbey Road, I think they absolutely went out on a high.