The Feud: Halloween 2010 by 42fish [game over]

[Rebo]

And the winner is… notfrommensa!!! Good job! ::flings fun size candy bars:: notfrommensa got all top ten answers!!! Magnificent!

Thanks for playing, everyone. Thanks for a fun Feud, 42fish!

New one up tomorrow.
**1. notfrommensa 447.62 **
2. labtrash 435.71
3. NDP 421.43
4. astorian 395.24
5. swampbear 388.10
6. ArchiveGuy 376.19
7. Sigmagirl 376.19
8. Simmerdown 373.81
9. MsWhatsit 371.43
10. Infovore 369.05
11. twickster 366.67
12. mkecane 354.76
13. Thudlow Boink 354.76
14. jsgoddess 354.76
15. Antigen 350.00
16. Little Nemo 345.24
17. Walkabout 330.95
18. 42fish 321.43
19. Elendil’s Heir 319.05
20. ChockFullOfHeadyGoodness 311.90
21. Sternvogel 309.52
22. Skammer 304.76
23. MissTake 304.76
24. zamboniracer 302.38
25. Sparky812 302.38
26. Wheelz 297.62
27. AppallingGael 292.86
28. kaylasdad99 290.48
29. Mahaloth 276.19
30. Asimovian 276.19
31. gonzomax 276.19
32. KennerTheGreat 259.52
33. AuntiePam 250.00
34. missred 247.62
35. anyrose 235.71
36. cmkeller 223.81
37. IvoryTowerDenizen 221.43
38. Freudian Slit 219.05
39. Intergalactic Gladiator 211.90
40. Chronos 209.52
41. brujaja 183.33
42. Snickers 66.67

[anyrose]

@Rebo

3. Name a geeky Halloween costume
   **3. Darth Vader 6
4. Mr. Spock 6**
5. Scientist 3
6. Star Trek outfit 3
7. Bill Gates 2
8. Jedi 2
9. Klingon 2
10. Stormtrooper 2
11. Superhero 2
12. Best Buy/Geek Squad uniform 1
13. Captain Picard 1
14. Doppler shift 1
15. Dr. Who 1
16. Harry Potter 1
17. Hobbit 1
18. LOTR character 1
19. Miss Marple 1
20. Nerd 1
21. robot 1
22. Spiderman 1
23. Star Wars character 1
24. Waldo 1
25. Yoda 1

Oh come now. Don’t you think “Mr Spock/Klingon/Star Trek Outfit/Cpt Picard” should be combined? Likewise “Jedi/Star Wars Character/Yoda/Darth Vader/Stormtrooper”; LOTR character with Hobbit; and Superhero with Spiderman?

[YogSothoth]

Nevermind

[notfrommensa]

@anyrose

Oh come now. Don’t you think “Mr Spock/Klingon/Star Trek Outfit/Cpt Picard” should be combined? Likewise “Jedi/Star Wars Character/Yoda/Darth Vader/Stormtrooper”; LOTR character with Hobbit; and Superhero with Spiderman?

No, I won dadgummit, don’t be adjusting the scores.

OMG, I won!!!. And i didn’t even cheat!

This is spooky.

[Rebo]

@anyrose

Oh come now. Don’t you think “Mr Spock/Klingon/Star Trek Outfit/Cpt Picard” should be combined? Likewise “Jedi/Star Wars Character/Yoda/Darth Vader/Stormtrooper”; LOTR character with Hobbit; and Superhero with Spiderman?

No.

You’re kidding, right?

[anyrose]

@Rebo

No.

You’re kidding, right?

not if you agree with me . . .

[Chronos]

Oh come now. Don’t you think “Mr Spock/Klingon/Star Trek Outfit/Cpt Picard” should be combined? Likewise “Jedi/Star Wars Character/Yoda/Darth Vader/Stormtrooper”; LOTR character with Hobbit; and Superhero with Spiderman?

Actually, I agree with this, even though I didn’t say any of those. Usually, when one answer has been a subset of another answer in the past, they’ve been combined.

[Elendil_s_Heir]

No, I’d leave the scoring as it is. Those are each characters with distinctly different costumes.

And I’d say that even if I hadn’t placed 19th, which is higher than I’ve been in a looooong time.

[Simmerdown]

I’d leave it, too. I had the LOTR answer, only because I couldn’t think of anything else. It could be a hobbit, an elf, a freakin’ walking tree, whatever. I don’t see a need to combine them.

[Rebo]

It’s hard to make these decisions sometimes. I go on a case-by-case basis. I know I’m not always consistent, but I do the best I can.

In this case, I believe the generic answer(s) should stand alone, and the specific answer(s) should stand alone as well.