[QUOTE=Malthus]
Not a sarcastic question at all, but are you familiar with the history of conflict in the region? A common pattern of warfare is for several of Israel’s neighbours to take on Israel at any one time - Egypt, Syria and Jordan being the prime canadates. The only sensible way of approaching power-balance in the region is “all of Israel’s potential enemies” on one side and “Israel” on the other.
[/QUOTE]
Sure, but that last happened in 1973 – a generation ago, and all the leaders from that day are dead, as is the kind of pan-Arabism that would even make a Syrian-Egyptian-Jordanian combo possible. Plus, countries don’t think of themselves in the way you’re suggesting. They never say to themselves, “Well, I’d look pretty good, so long as I throw my neighbor in with me” – as in Mexico saying, “Well, my infant mortality statistics are pretty bad… but if I include the U.S. in my calculation, I look pretty good!” What I’m saying is that Egypt and Jordan don’t consider themselves as getting as much as Israel – because they don’t, in plain fact.
[QUOTE=Malthus]
I myself do not have any way of knowing how “military” spending is allocated or accounted for, but I severely doubt that a country may simply spend it ony anything - military or non.
[/QUOTE]
What I mean is each dollar in “military” aid means one dollar less that a country has to spend out of its own resources on its military. So the dollar saved can be spent on anything.
[QUOTE=Malthus]
The question under analysis is whether the money is being spent on some legitimate foreign-policy goal, or simply provided to appease a domestic lobby.
[/QUOTE]
The goal of maintaining Middle East peace may be laudable, but there needs to be more discussion of the means to that end. For instance, one could discuss the price the U.S. pays for its clear favoritism toward Israel, not just in their being the number-one destination for our foreign aid, but in all the other ways we favor them, as pointed out in the article cited in the OP.
[QUOTE=Malthus]
In summary, if the US gave nothing to anyone, Israel would be exactly as militarily dominant as it is now (that is, parity would be achieved); but those friendly regimes (Egypt and Syria, but not Israel) would in theory be rendered more unstable, and potentially less friendly & more aggressive.
[/QUOTE]
So why not give Israel nothing, but keep giving to Egypt and Jordan (as I think you meant)? Save us a couple billion dollars a year, that would, and make us look a little friendlier to the people we’re trying to win over.
[QUOTE=Malthus]
While this theory may not be convincing to you, I note that it makes more sense to look for a reasonable explaination for a country acting in its own self-interest before assuming that it is motivated to behave irrationally by an unpatriotic domestic lobby.
[/QUOTE]
Quite – but let’s look at self-interest through a somewhat wider lens. Is our self-interest served by what’s happening in Iraq? How about Iran? How about Afghanistan? Does our unbridled support for Israel have any impact on those situations? Of course it does – and even if you don’t see it, the Arab Street, so-called, does.