I thought since this is a book suggestion thread I should maybe mention some of the other sea stories, fiction and nonfiction, I’ve felt were exceptionally compelling:
In Harm’s Way - Emotionally devastating nonfiction book on the sinking of the USS Indianapolis - went down in twelve minutes, nobody knew it was missing, and then the sharks came.
*Sailors to the End - * - Another sad nonfiction book on the fire on the USS Forestal in Vietnam - I guess I’m a sucker for punishment
Two Years Before the Mast - A nonfiction account from a Harvard guy who shipped aboard a merchanter bound for the pre-Gold rush California coast. He wrote it to draw attention to the awful conditions on board the sailing ships of the day, but accidentally convinced a bunch of young men to run away to sea because even though it really is awful it also kind of sounds like a great adventure. (Probably available in the public domain.)
In the Heart of the Sea - a nonfiction account of the whale attack that inspired Moby Dick, and a great look at the whaling culture in general. Also really sad. Are there sea stories that aren’t?
For fiction, Forester’s Hornblower books and O’Brian’s Aubrey/Maturin stories are indispensable. I’d start with Beat to Quarters for Hornblower, first written but not first in the chronology, and Master and Commander for Aubrey (first written and first in the timeline.)
Those are just the first few that come to mind, for the interested. Which there probably aren’t any, but oh well.