The Most Misunderstood Book/Movie/Song Ever

There is indeed a fine line between honest love and creepy stalker-esque obsession. For example, is this song about a stalker or a lover?

HAPPY TOGETHER
written by G. Bonner - A. Gordon

Imagine me and you, I do
I think about you day and night, it’s only right
To think about the girl you love and hold her tight
So happy together

If I should call you up, invest a dime
And you say you belong to me and ease my mind
Imagine how the world could be, so very fine
So happy together

I can’t see me lovin’ nobody but you
For all my life
When you’re with me, baby the skies’ll be blue
For all my life

Me and you and you and me
No matter how they toss the dice, it has to be
The only one for me is you, and you for me
So happy together

Whaat? I Never knew that either!! Until now, that is. Gawd. Better sign off and go listen to Aftermath again…

Sadeness = sadomaschos…ahh…Can’t spell, but you know what I mean. :pI always thought she was saying it in a French accent too…do you have the lyrics to it, and how did you find out it its true meaning?

Far too many to list, but here’s a few songs.

The Land Down Under - Yeesh, and you thought Bruce Springsteen had it bad…anyway, this is not, repeat, NOT in any way patriotic. It’s a protest song about the crass appropriation of Austrailian culture by outsiders (something the music video makes clear). Anyone who sings this as sort of a tribute to the land down under isn’t quite getting the point.

Coming in the Air Tonight - As Phil Collins himself stated, this song is just a bunch of unpleasant thoughts brought on by his recent divorce. There was no drowning person, no callous onlooker who refused to help, etc.

Everybody Have Fun Tonight - One of those songs that gets played at sporting events way too much. Hey, Everybody…the band is singing about ITSELF, not simply having a good time. Just a simple piece of self-promotion (which apparently worked like a charm).

Dry Bones - Every time I’ve heard a snippet of this song played on TV, usually as a joke, the line “Now hear the word of the Lord” is invariably left out. No, this isn’t about anatomy, making the right connections, or whatever, it’s about a biblical prophet. Who’s instructed to connect long-dead bones. Which then walk around. You know, act of God? Omen?

Bohemian Rhapsody - A little reminder that the !!!ONLY!!! reason this 70’s song got so much play time in the 90’s was because it was in Wayne’s World (and they cut out more than half of it!). It’s not a happy, funny, or lively song and was never meant to be…it’s about a condemned prisoner lamenting fate, for crying out loud.

Mickey - Not a reference to Mickey Thompson, Dolenz, Rooney, Mantle, or Mouse. Honest.

We Didn’t Start the Fire - Written from the perspective of someone who’s absolutely disgusted by recent history. (The “fire”, BTW, is all the wrongs of the world…war, crime, political instability, repressive governments, and all those other things mentioned in the song…which everyone has to suffer through, even the ones not responsible.) Criminy, listen to the chorus sometime, people: “We didn’t start the fire / ** though we didn’t light it, but we’re trying to fight it**.” Pretty clear-cut to me.

And if I may add a TV show…

The Simpsons - The setting, people, and stoires have never struck me as even remotely realistic, and all the characters have gone through so many permutations that the sweeping generalizations made about the (e.g. Bart = the brat) are silly. What nobody seemed to realize is that this show isn’t about a real family, it’s about a PARODY of a real family. It uses many of the same sitcom elements as its supposed enemies like the Cosby Show, just a little differently. And there are many, many events which could not have taken place outside a cartoon.

Re: From a Distance. I never really liked this song too much, mainly because the message is so bland and the lyrics don’t really evoke anything meaningful. (God is watching us from a distance…wow, what a concept.). What I really think this is is an affirmation of the Christian love-thy-neighbor ethic. We’re supposed to look past our petty differences and accept each other as equals, because God does, and we are all created unto God…something like that. Again, not the most stirring message, but in the age of ethnic cleansing and politically expedient bombings, you take what you can get.

Connor, I agree. Perhaps I overstated my case when I said it wasn’t about politics. What I meant was that Plato wasn’t really advocating the society he described, a point which was missed by Karl Popper, among others.

I’m still confused by the book Jonathan Livingston Seagull, but then again I read that book when I was 9 years old…

betenoir, I second your nomination of Fight Club. If you read the book, it’s even more apparent that it’s not a glorification of violence. The narrator at first looks to fight club to solve his problems, but in the end it doesn’t solve anything.

I’d also like to mention the novel Bright Lights, Big City. It’s widely regarded as glorifying drugs. In fact, the main character uses drugs as a crutch for not dealing with reality, and in the end he realizes that’s not the solution.

Can someone point out the line in ‘Perfect Day’ which makes you think it has anything to do with using drugs? To me, it fits in with other Lou Reed love songs like ‘Pale Blue Eyes’ (which is about adultery) or ‘I’ll Be Your Mirror’ (where two imperfect people figure out what there is to like about each other). Perfect Day (before it was used so crassly in Trainspotting) seems to me to be about a real love, that might be about to fall apart or that has problems, but none of those count on one (perhaps only wished for) ‘Perfect Day’.

I think people have a stereotyped view of what Lou Reed writes about - he has many more songs about love than about drugs (although some of his drugs songs are among his best ;)).

To quote Nick Cave, someone who knows more about writing love songs than I do:

HenrySpencer

I think that Starship Troopers (the book, not the steaming pile of feces that went into the theaters) is commonly misunderstood, sepecially today. Heinlein said in the early 80’s that he wrote the book in the (50’s?) and it still produces more mail than anything else he’d written, clear up to that point. the mail was split, half hate-half fan…

I think that the movie Titanic is misunderstood… I think it was all about Kate Winslets breasts… but then again, that could be my redhead fixation…

For the record, I also think that I’m misunderstood, but I’m used to it at this point… heheheh

1984 not primarily a warning about a possible totalitarian future, but more of a satire on postwar England. Also, it is a response to Orwell’s overly radical Socialist friends (Orwell was a more moderate Socialist).

I remember when they banned *Go Ask Alice[i/] in high school, because it was all about teenaged drugs and sex and nasty things like that.

'Course we all went out and read it then, and found that it was resounding condemnation (duh) of drugs and sex.

That’s what they said on Pop-Up Videos (very informative).

What I got from it was that God is watching from a distance, and everything looks perfect from a distance, but it’s really not.

“The Fire” in ‘We Didn’t Start the Fire’ is simply the tide of history. We like to think that everything is about us, but Joel was pointing out that we didn’t start it, it was around a long time ago and it’ll keep going on after we’re gone.

If you think it’s about oppression or war or something negative, please explain references to Doris Day, Joe DiMaggio, Rock N’ Roll, Marilyn Monroe, Rock around the Clock, the space program, Cola Marketing, etc…

The Song is just a chronicle of the latter half of the 20th century. The ‘message’ is that we’re a part of history, no more, no less.

That’s my interpretation, anyway.

The song starts with events that happen in the year Billy Joel was born. It’s a chronology of the events that happened during his life that interested him. For example, there are several boxing matches referenced. (Liston beats Patterson, for example.)

We mapped it out in history class one day… ah, high school.

1984 was about the Soviet Union, not England. Along with Animal Farm and several of his essays it was part of Orwell’s socialist rebuttal of Stalinism. You’re right to say that it was not about the future, though: the title was obtained by reversing the last two digits of the year in which it was written.

The book does contain, in passing, a number of predictions. The most interesting is that Winston would be a popular name for boys born immediately after World War II. This turned out not to be true in Britain but true in the West Indies.

Your both wrong. I mean your both right.

It’s certainly about Stalinism- and all totalitarianism. But it was also directly inspired by conditions in 1948 England. I believe he had said as much.

Other than the shortage of material good, which was common throughout Europe in 1948, I don’t see how the conditions in 1984 reflect the conditions in postwar England at all.

Obviously there is a sense in which it is about England, in that it is set in England, and clearly parts of it (Airstrip One) are direct references the political situation of the time.

Sam Stone - Those things you mention are hardly what I’d consider to be unequivocally positive. I’m not sure what you meant be “we think history’s all about us” or something. I’m positive, however, that this wasn’t a simple history lesson, but rather the impact of history, and how people who are entirely blameless can get drawn into it (the Vietnam War is a good example).

I’ll get a headache if I discuss this song for another second, so I’ll stop here…

shimmery - I dunno…somehow, I have a very hard time believing that Bette Midler was being cynical when she sang this. If it were Peter Gabriel, Phil Collins, or Vertical Horizon, maybe.

Since television program was added, ala Simpsons, I believe that the most misunderstood program ever was “All in the Family.” I have had people tell me I am a racist because I love the show. What the heck are they talking about?

This common reaction is enough to prove that the US educational system has truly dumbed the citizenry down.