# The power of creative destruction, in 1 picture

**URL:** <https://boards.straightdope.com/t/the-power-of-creative-destruction-in-1-picture/563387>\
**Category:** Great Debates\
**Created:** [December 8, 2010, 7:26am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/the-power-of-creative-destruction-in-1-picture/563387 "2010-12-08T07:26:17Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 20\
**Page:** 9

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![emacknight](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/e/3ec8ea/32.png) [@emacknight](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/emacknight)\
**Post date:** [December 31, 2010, 6:38pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/the-power-of-creative-destruction-in-1-picture/563387/161 "2010-12-31T18:38:16Z")

</div>

Right now, Target is selling an [Apple iPod touch® 32GB]([http://www.target.com/Apple-touch-Player-Generation-Screen/dp/B001FA1O18/ref=sr\_1\_2?ie=UTF8&searchView=grid5&keywords=ipod](http://www.target.com/Apple-touch-Player-Generation-Screen/dp/B001FA1O18/ref=sr_1_2?ie=UTF8&searchView=grid5&keywords=ipod) touch&fromGsearch=true&sr=1-2&qid=1293820225&rh=&searchRank=target104545&id=Apple touch Player Generation Screen&node=1038576|1287991011&searchSize=30&searchPage=1&searchNodeID=1038576|1287991011&searchBinNameList=subjectbin%2Cprice%2Ctarget\_com\_primary\_color-bin%2Ctarget\_com\_size-bin%2Ctarget\_com\_brand-bin&frombrowse=0 ) for $294.99.  
If tomorrow Target had them on sale for $25, do you think they would sell more, fewer, or the same number of units?

Alternatively, if tomorrow they set the price to $25000 do you think they would sell more, fewer, or the same number of units?

Is there a price where people would decide to stop buying an ipod touch?

Also note that [Best Buy](http://www.bestbuy.com/site/Apple%26%23174%3B+-+iPod+touch%26%23174%3B+32GB*+MP3+Player+%284th+Generation+-+Latest+Model%29+-+Black/9225411.p?id=1218062716107&skuId=9225411&st=ipod%20touch&contract_desc=null) is selling the same ipod for $274.

Given that they are both offering free shipping, who would you order from? Target at $295 or Best Buy at $274?

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![emacknight](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/e/3ec8ea/32.png) [@emacknight](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/emacknight)\
**Post date:** [December 31, 2010, 6:53pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/the-power-of-creative-destruction-in-1-picture/563387/162 "2010-12-31T18:53:04Z")

</div>

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> You seem to be unaware of the effect that rising wages has on rising prices. Another facet of basic economics.

No, he’s well aware. We all are, everyone except you.

If tomorrow we decided to add another zero to everyone’s wages, we’d still have 16million unemployed. But now everything we buy would have an extra zero attached.

You seem to forget the effect that rising wages has on prices.

Look, I’m sorry you lost your job, I get that it sucks, but what you’re suggesting won’t help you.

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> And if you keep putting people on unemployment to send their jobs overseas you won’t sell many, either.

Why? Couldn’t we just raise everyone else’s wages?

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> You know, at some point you gotta leave the boards and tell these knee-slappers you call arguments to the FACES of those unemployed people. Tell them to their faces how they win. Maybe even tell them what they won. Really, try not coming back here until you’ve told this to a few unemployed people. I know you never will, though. People who make the arguments you do, never tend to confront the jobless face to face with their “reasoning”.

Okay, I’m going to do that today. What I’d like you to do is buy something, then offer the cashier and extra $100. Tell him/her you are offering to pay more to make sure he/she has a higher salary.

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> Actually as I’ve also said before, I’m all for free trade with Japan, Europe and Canada. They don’t undercut with third world wages. I’m just all for blocking out China and their ilk until they can clean up their own shops.

Oh, cool. Can you get the US to end the tariffs on soft wood lumber now? It’s hurting Canadian jobs.

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> Everyone doesn’t win. We all lose. This offshoring thing has created a permanent employer’s market.

I’ve asked this before and have yet to get an answer: Why is that a bad thing? I am an employer, currently hiring, and am very happy to have multiple applicants to choose from.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Saint\_Cad](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/saint_cad/32/18907_2.png) [@Saint\_Cad](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Saint_Cad)\
**Post date:** [December 31, 2010, 10:09pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/the-power-of-creative-destruction-in-1-picture/563387/163 "2010-12-31T22:09:43Z")

</div>

> [@Maastricht](#):
>
> Am I the only one who sees these graphs and thinks:
> 
> People! The economy will be back to normal in a year or two, at most. In the meantime, those who have been laid off have T-I-M-E. You know, time?

And no money

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![mazinger\_z](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/m/5f9b8f/32.png) [@mazinger\_z](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/mazinger_z)\
**Post date:** [December 31, 2010, 10:27pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/the-power-of-creative-destruction-in-1-picture/563387/164 "2010-12-31T22:27:53Z")

</div>

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> First of all, who’s “everyone”? Opposition to offshoring is not exactly unpopular - in fact it is growing. **Because that tortured mess you call your logic is getting exposed for what it is - a tortured mess.**

_emphasis mine._ Pot. Kettle. Black. Let’s call that PKB for short, because I will be using this term many, many times. For someone who is accusing me and many others of “tortured logic” you are displaying this in spades. The highlighted portion above, for those of you playing from home, is called circular reasoning/logic. It’s not really logic, but rather, an example of faulty logic.

> [@](#):
>
> Ah, make that 102 times.

I keep pointing this out to you because you keep ignoring it. You hand-wave, for lack of a better term, the difference between the wealthy US and poor China like it doesn’t mean anything, when clearly, it does. The reason there is any growth in the US is because China has ample amounts of cheap labor (which you think is easily remedied by making them (whoever that is) pay more – but we’ll get to that later). The US does not have that same luxury.

> [@](#):
>
> And I will point out to you yet again that their protectionism has helped them grow.

And again, I will point out that labor is cheap, and that there is a lot of slack in their system, that despite the protectionism, the mainly cheap labor will not stop investment dollars. You acknowledge this point, but you act like it doesn’t matter. Do you even know how tariffs work? Serious question, because I shouldn’t have to explain this to you, but with all this hand-waving, I’m starting to think you don’t. So, here it is in a nutshell:

The costs of making a good largely fall into two categories (there are many others, but mentioning now will only confuse you): labor and raw materials. Raw materials: iron, coal, oil, wood, etc., especially in modern economies, roughly cost about the same. Why? There are these things called ‘markets’ or ‘exchanges’ in a modern economy that trade and set the price levels for them. Most of the raw materials fall under the heading of commodities. Oil has its own market. With me so far?

With the cost of raw materials largely fixed (meaning everyone pays the same for it), the only variable, and the routinely the largest cost to making a good, is labor. If the average Chinese worker is making $0.90/hr and the average US worker is making $10/hr then raising the tariff on a good still makes the Chinese product cheaper. But, let’s add in tariffs, like you say, because you say that protectionism benefits the economy.

Chinese products go from X+$0.90 to X+11, US products stay at X+10. Now, in order to buy this good, people have to spend more money. Congratulations, you have now made everyone poorer! The American’s hard earned dollars now do not buy as much as it has before. But, wait, there’s more! As prices increases for a good, less of it is bought. So now, the market for that good X has shrunk. People who were involved with bringing the Chinese product to market are now out of work. So now, the dollar doesn’t buy as much, and more people are out of work! Yeah protectionism! Oh wait, that’s a bad thing…and, yet you continue to advocate this.

> [@](#):
>
> As for your brutally tortured logic about how this won’t work for America, I’ll leave you to the previous discussions here about Germany and how they protect a number of their industries

Really, where do you get this information? Germany is a protected market? Really? From early 2010: [Germany’s Merkel: Protectionism ‘Greatest Danger’ To World Economy](http://online.wsj.com/article/BT-CO-20101108-717273.html) Here’s one from early 2007: [Merkel of Germany Says ‘Nein’ to Protectionism](http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2007/01/24/on-isolationism-germanys-merkel-says-no/) There’s more, but I hope you see that you’re wrong. Also consider that Germany is a member of the EU, GATT, and the WTO all of which encourage free trade. So, tell me again how Germany is protectionist? I do know that they are protecting their renewable energy infrastructure. Why? Because it is a nascent industry. But, tariffs are not enacted without costs. The German people are paying more for energy through higher costs and increased taxation, providing a measurable deterrence to economic growth. Seriously, you could not have picked a more worse example to prove your point.

> [@](#):
>
> Your blanket argument that protectionism is bad for a developed nation is little more than reciting platitudes.

I have shown, you, again, (please see above) that protectionism breaks down the overall wealth of the economy. I have also shown you how tariffs don’t matter too much to China, because the cost of their labor is so low. PKB, pal, PKB.You have not shown one counter example. Even with simple logic, you haven’t been able to disprove anything I have written.

> [@](#):
>
> None of what you said shows in any way that China isn’t at least whittling down on the number of poor in their country.

Do you know what else comes with super cheap labor? Super cheap cost of living. Subsistence farming coupled with foreign investment dollars really does show a lot of growth than subsistence farming on its own. Going from $0.10/hr to $1.00/hr shows 1000% growth, but really isn’t anything to write home about. Congratulations poor people of China, you can now afford a road. Oh, and the growth of the middle class ignores the other 900 million (I just read 245 million live in the coastal areas). The best tariffs and other protectionist policies can do is emulate that, protect the few workers that are employed in those protected industries and screw over everyone else. ‘Oh, but let’s protect all industries,’ you say. Yeah, that makes everything worse.

> [@](#):
>
> Meanwhile our middle class is disappearing.

I’m not ignoring it. Again, this thing called a recession happened. Would you be making these arguments in the summer of 2007, Mr. Hindsight? Automobile ownership, stock investments, home ownership, employment, just to name a few, and the overall standard of living were at an all time high. Death of the Middle Class has been happening since the 1970’s, yet even now, the standard of living is higher than that time period. I’m sure your myopic view of history will hand-wave all this evidence away with whatever you think happened in the past 10 years, despite the fact that automation, off-shoring, outsourcing have been happening since the invention of the wheel. Oh, but way, you say, this time it’s different – same tune, in the same, song, on the same old tired, broken record.

> [@](#):
>
> Not necessarily always false or true. History shows that much.

No, you know nothing about supply and demand. You know nothing of inflation or chained dollar average either. Show where this is false. Oh, wait, you mentioned cars. Another ridiculously poor example. Epic Fail.

> [@](#):
>
> Case in point: cars have gone up in price over time and they keep on selling like hotcakes. Why? Because wages also went up.

You fail to address **Sam Stone’s** salient points about inflation the value of what the dollar buys. You instead, for no other point for your convenience and inability to comprehend inflation, concentrate solely on nominal dollars. Cars cost less in terms of real dollars than they have ever done before.

> [@](#):
>
> I’ll leave you with a question of how much cars cost in 1950 versus now and how many sold back then versus now…

What is insulting is what you bring to this debate. And again, I have to point you to a dictionary to look up what “cussing” is. Pointing out one’s ignorance _[hint: yours]_ is often misunderstood as insults But, that’s just human nature and a sign of immaturity. But, please, continue to post with superfluous punctuation and capitalization. While you’re at it, also, please look up inflation and this other concept: ‘real vs. nominal value.’ Seriously. Oh, more cars are owned and produced than in 1950, really don’t want a cite for that do you?

> [@](#):
>
> Answer: His premise that higher prices will always kill demand is wrong.

Wrong. Again, this isn’t binary. Overall demand decreases. Kill may be too strong a word. The interaction between supply and demand is a real thing. Everything you call “analysis” (even by the loosest of definitions) ignores this. Why?

> [@](#):
>
> On the other hand, history does back up my retort: right this minute, demand is down on exactly the kinds of products you’re talking about (consumer electronics) because of all the high unemployment. [http://www.eetimes.com/electronics-n...adgets-in-2010](http://www.eetimes.com/electronics-n...adgets-in-2010)

PKB. In addition to recession, you might want to consider market saturation. And, holy cow, seriously, read your links. For the benefit of the doubt, I usually believe what other people think the link means. I can believe that demand is down overall as consumers spend more on non-luxury items. But, you’re a so dead wrong. Serious epic fail. Demand is down for Christmas shopping. A relatively small time frame. Again with your short-sightedness. Do you think electronics spending only happens during Xmas?I was wrong that demand would fell because consumers focused on non-luxury spending, but not so, according to the article. Luxury items are actually up. iPad and Kindle have demand off the charts. Is the world that binary to you? Or, is view of history so short-sighted that any change to a current trend is absolute evidence that the exact opposite is happening? I would hate to see you at a roulette table: It’s red, it’s always going to be red. Oh, no, it’s black, it’s always going to be black. No wait…whatever.

> [@](#):
>
> Wages and prices have risen in tandem since the 1950s… Although, despite all the price benefits of offshoring, wages have fallen BEHIND inflation for the last 10 years.

For someone who mentions inflation, you show a stunning ignorance of it. Again, with the last 10 years, I won’t even mention the recession this time. Even giving your arguments here the benefit of the doubt, the standard of living continues to increase and prices (that is real prices, mind you, look up inflation, please) continue to drop. To focus so much on wages belies your class warfare mentality.

> [@](#):
>
> You have failed to show, then how hiring unemployed Americans to build iPods at prevailing wages ($745 a week) will destroy demand for iPods, much less lower our nation’s standard of living.

I have, and see again, above. And, to sum up the argument like you just did in the quote immediately above is another demonstration of your inability to parse out logic, as that quoted text does not relate the argument at hand. The point is with tariffs, the price of iProducts increase. At $300, the Apple sells X number. At $1500, how many are they going to sell? Who is going to hire these unemployed people? Again, why are we not all millionaires, even in the nominal sense?

The argument is: As the price of any good increases, the less people will buy it. Less buying = less demand. Less demand means less materials resources, and especially labor are needed. Less labor = more unemployed. An increase in the unemployed is an increase in supply of labor. As the supply of anything increases, demand for it decreases, and correspondingly, the price of it decreases. Seriously, this is basic supply and demand theory. If you claim to have any knowledge of economics, even in the slightest, you would know this. But, countless posts you put on this forum show increasingly that you have no clue of these concepts. Back to the example: Employers have a larger pool of people to hire from, so they can offer lower wages because with the larger number of unemployed, the greater the propensity that someone will work for that lower wage. You know this. You constantly harp about the employer’s market. Why do you ignore it now?

Did you just see what I wrote up there? It’s called making an argument. You simply state conclusions with little (read none) logic or argument applied to it. Your evidence of conclusion stating continues below:

> [@](#):
>
> Wait, I thought you said China favored the coastal regions. So by your … _ahem_ _cough_ logic _cough_ _wheeze_ all you’re doing is giving the inward regions “equal time”.

China does, it doesn’t mean that local officials don’t favor bribes more. Deep down, I think China wants this to happen. But, that’s for another topic.

> [@](#):
>
> Once again history hates your line of “reasoning”.
> 
> Please explain here which direction China’s middle class is going. Is it increasing or decreasing? Go ahead… you can cuss at me some more now.

Yes, 250 million (I’m rounding up, and giving the benefit of the doubt that living in a coastal region automatically makes one middle class) are benefiting at the expense of 900 million otherwise poor poor people. Most people would think what you think of as middle class in China are also poor. And, how does History hate anything? Please explain, I could use more amusement. And, again, look up cussing. Wow, you have a lot of work on your hands. Let’s make a list:

1. Supply and Demand
2. real vs. nominal
3. Inflation
4. Cussing

> [@](#):
>
> Hardly. If you don’t have $11k on hand you’re screwed. Or did you not get that part? Oh I’m sure the unemployed have $11k lying around.

Epic Fail. You really should just let this part of the argument go. Are shovels cheap where you live? “Having” and “spending” are 2 different things. In fact, they are opposites. Do you honestly not understand that? Please add that to the list. Add, opposites (see also, antonyms), too.

> [@](#):
>
> You have not produced so much as one single challenging or well-made argument. Not even one.

PKB, big time. You are arguing from conclusions again. 0 analysis. Zero, nada, zilch, zip.

> [@](#):
>
> Someone has to hire a substantial portion of those 16 million jobless Americans at some point.

Wrong. No one has to hire anyone. Unless the government does so on its own, or forces businesses to do so. Uh oh, there’s that communism again… Demand is down remember? Why would demand increase? Remember, thanks to your tariffs, prices have increased. Prices go up, demand goes down, all things being equal. Is the economy suddenly getting better now that all these people are unemployed and prices are rising? Because that’s the situation we’re talking about here in this argument. Your one line of reasoning is: “Someone has to hire a substantial portion of those 16 million…” Really, where? How? Let me bring back that concept of supply and price, just in case you missed it earlier. With more unemployed, the wages offered are lower because more with more people unemployed the greater the propensity to work for a lower wage, wage stickiness only goes so far. With demand down, there is no need to increase production of iProducts or any good suffering less demand.

> [@](#):
>
> Going by your logic we should keep them jobless to keep prices down.

Ok, you’re going to have explain this comment. I have a feeling that you’re only concentrating on nominal dollars and cents and not on the actual things that it represents like value and wealth.

> [@](#):
>
> What other work? You guys can never seem to answer that. Can you answer that?

If anyone knew the answer to this, they would know the future. As I don’t advocate divination, you’re going to have find another dead horse to beat.

> [@](#):
>
> I’ve been pointing out that the recession was caused by stagnant wage growth and anemic job growth being covered up by rampant growth of debt which created the illusion of wealth and which fueled spending.

Right… Housing bubble, failure in the derivatives market, failure in the auto industry, massive reduction in confidence in the economy and banking system…none of this mattered? More things to add to the list.

> [@](#):
>
> LONG story short: I am the very last person on EARTH that you want to accuse of not seeing this mess.

Don’t twist your arm patting yourself on the back. Not that I care that you can prove this. But, you do realize that major, highly capitalized long-standing, banks failed (to mention several nations’ economies) from this recession that you claim to so have so accurately predicted. One man triumphs above the system! I see now why you come in here posting with such incredulous abandon. Of course, you’ve had it right all along! Go you! Have you picked out an island to buy? Charles Schwab and Warren Buffet have been getting advice from you all this time, haven’t they? Don’t be shy now…

> [@](#):
>
> Unless you’re one of the homeless. You know, those entire FAMILIES that got made homeless during this mess.

Well, the most recent statistics (2007) show that [homelessness in the US had declined by 30% between 2005 and 2007](http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homelessness_in_the_United_States#2000s), but I admit that this statistic is pretty weak, and my quick search hasn’t turned up anything more substantial than homeless in the US is a problem. But, yes, my point stands, overall level of wealth and standard of living has been and continues to increase, even in your vaunted 10 year period. In other words, you’ve got nothing.

> [@](#):
>
> Ah yes, I know, their standard of living is increasing, too. Dumpster diving in America being better than dumpster diving in China

And where would you rather be poor and homeless?

> [@](#):
>
> Your argument never seems to learn the lesson about putting on capes? You say they earn $0 but that is so woefully wrong. Their wages is the cost of the food they eat, at least. Plus where they live. Unless you’re willing to say that food is free in China.

Capes? Do you know what wages are? Add that to the list. Hint, they come from having a job. Subsistence farming isn’t a job, is what someone does to survive. It’s like scavenging. The last time I looked neither scavenger nor subsistence farmer are an occupation. Wages come from doing work for somebody, as in having an employer. Who is the employer in this situation? Don’t tell me they are self-employed. (Ironically, it is true, but not in the way you think it is). I asked my driver if these people paid taxes, and he just laughed at me.

> [@](#):
>
> The USSR laughed off the Great Depression, remember?

Did you really just drop the USSR? And, you say you know your history? Epic fail. What happened during that time period? Hint, it sounds like Stalin. The USSR was too busy with killing millions of its own people to make its great system work. And, what was the standard of living there vis-a-vis the US during that time period? Much, much worse than the comparison of the US and China now. \>cough\< Luddite. \>cough\<

> [@](#):
>
> And the American market has plenty of Government controls and management.

Yes, and there has been no true Scotsman either.

> [@](#):
>
> Employing 16 million unemployed people does more damage to the economy than setting them adrift in your universe? Really?
> 
> Do the terms “lost tax revenue due to 16 million people being unemployed” or “lost tax revenue due to a permanent state of 8% unemployment (see: Europe)” mean anything to you?

Your attributing arguments to me that I did not make. All I am asking is: who is hiring these people again? Why would they be hired? Just because? An argument would fit nicely here. And, Europe’s 8% unemployment wouldn’t have anything to do with its ridiculous trade unions and inability to fire people would it? During that same time period, US unemployment has been much lower than that.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Le\_Jacquelope](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/l/e0b2c6/32.png) [@Le\_Jacquelope](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Le_Jacquelope)\
**Post date:** [January 1, 2011, 9:15pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/the-power-of-creative-destruction-in-1-picture/563387/165 "2011-01-01T21:15:58Z")

</div>

> [@emacknight](#):
>
> No, he’s well aware. We all are, everyone except you.

You keep bringing up this word “everyone”. That word does not mean what you think it means.

> [@](#):
>
> If tomorrow we decided to add another zero to everyone’s wages, we’d still have 16million unemployed. But now everything we buy would have an extra zero attached.

Sigh. That has nothing to do with actually hiring those 16 million jobless.

> [@](#):
>
> You seem to forget the effect that rising wages has on prices.
> 
> Look, I’m sorry you lost your job, I get that it sucks, but what you’re suggesting won’t help you.

What makes you think I lost a job? Is this your way of making up things about someone to attack someone’s ideas? I’m a business owner. There’s a lot of us out there who oppose offshoring.

> [@](#):
>
> Why? Couldn’t we just raise everyone else’s wages?

Because it has less of a positive effect than putting jobless people to work.

One person earning $1 million isn’t going to buy more HDTVs. But 10 people earning $100,000 will most likely buy 10 times as many HDTVs.

> [@](#):
>
> Okay, I’m going to do that today. What I’d like you to do is buy something, then offer the cashier and extra $100. Tell him/her you are offering to pay more to make sure he/she has a higher salary.

Actually I pay my employees more so they’ll perform better. And give them bonuses.

> [@](#):
>
> Oh, cool. Can you get the US to end the tariffs on soft wood lumber now? It’s hurting Canadian jobs.

Would love to.

> [@](#):
>
> I’ve asked this before and have yet to get an answer: Why is that a bad thing? I am an employer, currently hiring, and am very happy to have multiple applicants to choose from.

And I’ve explained that this is a bad thing for workers.

But again, you don’t care about workers. So why should they care about you? You’re just as replaceable as they are.

> [@](#):
>
> Right now, Target is selling an Apple iPod touch® 32GB for $294.99.
> 
> If tomorrow Target had them on sale for $25, do you think they would sell more, fewer, or the same number of units?
> 
> Alternatively, if tomorrow they set the price to $25000 do you think they would sell more, fewer, or the same number of units?
> 
> Is there a price where people would decide to stop buying an ipod touch?
> 
> Also note that Best Buy is selling the same ipod for $274.
> 
> Given that they are both offering free shipping, who would you order from? Target at $295 or Best Buy at $274?

Going by your logic, if we laid off 16 million MORE Americans, say from retail, and replaced them with cheap immigrant labor, we could shave another what, $50 off the cost of the average iPod? Going by your “logic”, we could replace the delivery drivers with ultra cheap immigrant labor and … hell, if we displaced 64 million Americans with lower wage workers we could get the cost of an iPod down to what, $199?

Going by your logic, if we displaced ALL Americans with rock bottom immigrant labor and sent overseas everything that’s not nailed down, iPods would be $50 and everything else would be SUPER cheap!

Problem is, who would be around to buy anything?

Exactly. Because your argument stinks to high heaven and all these jobs we’re sending overseas is crippling the market here in the U.S.

You cannot buy an iPod if you’re earning $0.  
You cannot buy an iPod if you’re earning $0.  
_You cannot buy an iPod if you’re earning $0._

The more people who are earning $0, the fewer iPods you will be able to sell _at any price whatsoever_. This, you keep ignoring.

> [@mazinger\_z](#):
>
> _emphasis mine._ Pot. Kettle. Black. Let’s call that PKB for short, because I will be using this term many, many times.

And you’ll be using it incorrectly every single time.

> [@](#):
>
> I keep pointing this out to you because you keep ignoring it. You hand-wave, for lack of a better term, the difference between the wealthy US and poor China like it doesn’t mean anything, when clearly, it does.

And you handwave away the fact that the unemployed are not wealthy. Earning $0 an hour is not wealth. It is poverty, in the extreme.

> [@](#):
>
> The reason there is any growth in the US is because China has ample amounts of cheap labor

This load of garbage argument isn’t even worth bothering with. Except to tell you it is a load of bull.

> [@](#):
>
> And again, I will point out that labor is cheap, and that there is a lot of slack in their system, that despite the protectionism, the mainly cheap labor will not stop investment dollars. You acknowledge this point, but you act like it doesn’t matter. Do you even know how tariffs work? Serious question, because I shouldn’t have to explain this to you, but with all this hand-waving, I’m starting to think you don’t.

All I need to explain to you is we have 16 million people out of work and your arguments pretty much leave them stranded. Permanently.

We need tariffs to put them back to work.

It’s either that, or the dollar inevitably collapses and that creates a NATURAL tariff.

It is impossible for us to continue this course without another Depression. Which, if you know any history, we’ve had before.

> [@](#):
>
> Really, where do you get this information? Germany is a protected market? Really? From early 2010: [Germany’s Merkel: Protectionism ‘Greatest Danger’ To World Economy](http://online.wsj.com/article/BT-CO-20101108-717273.html) Here’s one from early 2007: [Merkel of Germany Says ‘Nein’ to Protectionism](http://dealbook.nytimes.com/2007/01/24/on-isolationism-germanys-merkel-says-no/) There’s more, but I hope you see that you’re wrong. Also consider that Germany is a member of the EU, GATT, and the WTO all of which encourage free trade. So, tell me again how Germany is protectionist? I do know that they are protecting their renewable energy infrastructure. Why? Because it is a nascent industry. But, tariffs are not enacted without costs. The German people are paying more for energy through higher costs and increased taxation, providing a measurable deterrence to economic growth. Seriously, you could not have picked a more worse example to prove your point.

Seriously, you could not have posted a more _ignorant_ argument if you tried.

[http://www.epi.org/economic\_snapshots/entry/snapshot\_20090624/](http://www.epi.org/economic_snapshots/entry/snapshot_20090624/)  
[http://www.wageindicator.org/main/collective-bargaining/2009/germany-siemens-protects-128-000-jobs-in-germany-september-22-2010](http://www.wageindicator.org/main/collective-bargaining/2009/germany-siemens-protects-128-000-jobs-in-germany-september-22-2010)

Now you go ahead and tell me how “job guarantees” is not protectionism.

What Merkel SAYS about protectionism and what she DOES is another matter.

Oh and one other thing: Germany’s unemployment is now LOWER than ours.

> [@](#):
>
> I have shown, you, again, (please see above) that protectionism breaks down the overall wealth of the economy.

No, you haven’t. You’ve only done a bunch of cherry picking.

> [@](#):
>
> Even with simple logic, you haven’t been able to disprove anything I have written.

Oooh, bluster. Getting frustrated?

> [@](#):
>
> Oh, and the growth of the middle class ignores the other 900 million (I just read 245 million live in the coastal areas). The best tariffs and other protectionist policies can do is emulate that, protect the few workers that are employed in those protected industries and screw over everyone else. ‘Oh, but let’s protect all industries,’ you say. Yeah, that makes everything worse.

You keep repeating that but that doesn’t make it true.

Going by your logic if we just let all the jobs in this country go to cheaper labor we’ll be even BETTER off.

All of your futile attempts at logic continually ignore one basic fact: the more people are out of work in America the smaller the market is for the companies who want to sell here.

> [@](#):
>
> I’m not ignoring it. Again, this thing called a recession happened.

_Sigh_ Must I educate you on everything?

The middle class was shrinking long before 2007, with more people going to the ranks of the poor than the ranks of the rich.

> [@](#):
>
> Would you be making these arguments in the summer of 2007, Mr. Hindsight?

Actually, I was. I said back then that the whole economy was based on BS: stagnating wages and anemic job growth made up for by spending based on skyrocketing consumer debt. In 2007-2008 fate called BS on the economy and the rest is history.

> [@](#):
>
> Automobile ownership, stock investments, home ownership, employment, just to name a few, and the overall standard of living were at an all time high.

No, they weren’t. It was all false, based upon an orgy of buying on margin, the use of credit cards and people using their homes as ATMs. Employment was flat, with new jobs not keeping up with new entrants to the workforce, and wages were falling behind inflation.

I’ve cited all of this repeatedly. At this point one can only assume you’re intentionally discounting it.

Just like you discounted it when I pointed out to you that innovation jobs were going overseas, too.

> [@](#):
>
> Death of the Middle Class has been happening since the 1970’s, yet even now, the standard of living is higher than that time period. I’m sure your myopic view of history will hand-wave all this evidence away with whatever you think happened in the past 10 years, despite the fact that automation, off-shoring, outsourcing have been happening since the invention of the wheel. Oh, but way, you say, this time it’s different – same tune, in the same, song, on the same old tired, broken record.

The standard of living has been increasing for whom? Certainly not the jobless.

> [@](#):
>
> No, you know nothing about supply and demand. You know nothing of inflation or chained dollar average either.

More temper tantrums. What you claim to know is clearly contradicted by what is currently going on.

> [@](#):
>
> You fail to address **Sam Stone’s** salient points about inflation the value of what the dollar buys. You instead, for no other point for your convenience and inability to comprehend inflation, concentrate solely on nominal dollars. Cars cost less in terms of real dollars than they have ever done before. What is insulting is what you bring to this debate. And again, I have to point you to a dictionary to look up what “cussing” is. Pointing out one’s ignorance _[hint: yours]_ is often misunderstood as insults

Neither you nor Sam Stone have any salient points. What you have are temper tantrums and cookie cutter arguments that reek of desperation.

> [@](#):
>
> Wrong. Again, this isn’t binary. Overall demand decreases. Kill may be too strong a word.

Ah, now you’re backpedaling.

> [@](#):
>
> The interaction between supply and demand is a real thing. Everything you call “analysis” (even by the loosest of definitions) ignores this. Why?

LOL! Does your _ahem_ understanding of supply and demand address what happens to a market when you put 16 million people out of work? What happens to demand when a bunch of people are earning $0? Ah yes, you have zero idea of the answer to that - this you have already shown. In spades.

Oh yeah I know - we’re in a recession. Exactly when do you think those people will find jobs again? Ah yes, that’s where your knowledge of economics plays the “somewhere over the rainbow” card.

> [@](#):
>
> Serious epic fail.

Wow, you learned a new word sometime this last week.

> [@](#):
>
> Luxury items are actually up. iPad and Kindle have demand off the charts.

At the expense of other consumer electronics. Did you miss that part?

> [@](#):
>
> I have, and see again, above. And, to sum up the argument like you just did in the quote immediately above is another demonstration of your inability to parse out logic, as that quoted text does not relate the argument at hand. The point is with tariffs, the price of iProducts increase. At $300, the Apple sells X number. At $1500, how many are they going to sell? Who is going to hire these unemployed people? Again, why are we not all millionaires, even in the nominal sense?

And you have the inability to understand this:

Going by your logic, if we laid off 16 million MORE Americans, say from retail, and replaced them with cheap immigrant labor, we could shave another what, $50 off the cost of the average iPod? Going by your “logic”, we could replace the delivery drivers with ultra cheap immigrant labor and … hell, if we displaced 64 million Americans with lower wage workers we could get the cost of an iPod down to what, $199?

Going by your logic, if we displaced ALL Americans with rock bottom immigrant labor and sent overseas everything that’s not nailed down, iPods would be $50 and everything else would be SUPER cheap!

Problem is, who would be around to buy anything?

When you send jobs overseas you’re not replacing them with anything here. Except maybe lower-paying cashier jobs. In essence you’re shrinking the market of people who can afford iPods - and if they can buy iPods they’re not buying much else.

> [@](#):
>
> The argument is: As the price of any good increases, the less people will buy it.

That’s only part of the argument. You’ve intentionally left out what happens to demand when you have more and more people who have no jobs, and wages that are stagnating. You probably left this out because it completely undermines your _laugh_ argument.

> [@](#):
>
> Did you just see what I wrote up there? It’s called making an argument.

Uh, what you do is not commonly called making an argument. Well, maybe it is called that here but in the real world it’s called burying your case under a mile of concrete.

> [@](#):
>
> Wrong. No one has to hire anyone.

In that case who will they have for customers?

There goes your ENTIRE argument in its own mushroom cloud.

> [@](#):
>
> Right… Housing bubble, failure in the derivatives market, failure in the auto industry, massive reduction in confidence in the economy and banking system…none of this mattered?

_sigh_ Once again… this was CAUSED by the problem of stagnating wages and anemic job growth.

> [@](#):
>
> And where would you rather be poor and homeless?

False dichotomy. Most people would rather not be poor or homeless anywhere.

> [@](#):
>
> Capes? Do you know what wages are? Add that to the list. Hint, they come from having a job. Subsistence farming isn’t a job, is what someone does to survive. It’s like scavenging.

Subsistence farming is like scavenging. Ohkay, that wins the prize for first uber clueless comment of the year. I’m sure you’ll post more to top that soon.

> [@](#):
>
> Don’t tell me they are self-employed. (Ironically, it is true, but not in the way you think it is).

You just contradicted yourself. And then hung a lampshade on it!

> [@](#):
>
> Did you really just drop the USSR? And, you say you know your history? Epic fail. What happened during that time period? Hint, it sounds like Stalin. The USSR was too busy with killing millions of its own people to make its great system work. And, what was the standard of living there vis-a-vis the US during that time period? Much, much worse than the comparison of the US and China now.

You’re confusing their economics with their human rights issues. The two are not the same. Again, your “arguments” have no resemblance to analysis whatsoever. However it does have a great resemblance to propaganda.

> [@](#):
>
> Your attributing arguments to me that I did not make. All I am asking is: who is hiring these people again? Why would they be hired? Just because? An argument would fit nicely here.

And I’ll be pleased when you actually make one.

Why should we hire those 16 million Americans? What else are we going to do with them? What’s to stop those 16 million people from growing? Oh wait, they are. We STILL don’t have enough jobs being produced to serve the new entrants to the workforce.

Those 16 million people can drag our entire economy into the dirt. Unless you suggest we just cut off services to them in which case you’re looking at a revolution. Which’ll cost America even more.

Your entire “argument” fails to look at anything from the perspective of those 16 million people.

> [@](#):
>
> And, Europe’s 8% unemployment wouldn’t have anything to do with its ridiculous trade unions and inability to fire people would it? During that same time period, US unemployment has been much lower than that.

You epic fail once again. US unemployment wasn’t much lower - we go by the U3 standard while Europe goes by the U6. Going by U6 standards the U.S. and Europe had quite similar numbers.

_sigh_

> [@](#):
>
> But, yes, my point stands, overall level of wealth and standard of living has been and continues to increase, even in your vaunted 10 year period.

Your point stands much in the same way that Ronald Reagan is still standing.

First you counter my claim that homelessness has been on the rise since the start of this subprime crash with the claim that homelessness was down in the years before?

Well hell, I can respond with the fact that homelessness was up before that, as recently as 2003:  
[http://www.usatoday.com/money/economy/2003-08-11-homeless\_x.htm](http://www.usatoday.com/money/economy/2003-08-11-homeless_x.htm)

And it’s been up since at least 2009:  
[http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2009-04-05-homeless\_N.htm](http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2009-04-05-homeless_N.htm)

Okay so in closing, let me give you the list of things you need to learn:  
History  
Logic  
Reasoning  
Supply & Demand  
English  
Mathematics  
Cause & Effect

That’s for starters.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Le\_Jacquelope](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/l/e0b2c6/32.png) [@Le\_Jacquelope](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Le_Jacquelope)\
**Post date:** [January 1, 2011, 9:35pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/the-power-of-creative-destruction-in-1-picture/563387/166 "2011-01-01T21:35:24Z")

</div>

The death of the coming “innovation” economy, thanks to offshoring:

This is where our knowledge-based jobs are about to go:

> **[Intel announces $2.5b chip project in China](http://www.chinadaily.com.cn/china/2007-03/26/content_836383.htm)**
>
> US chip giant Intel Corp will build a US2.5-billion plant in Dalian, a port city in northeast China's Liaoning Province.

> [@](#):
>
> “This project confirms and further enhances the strategic importance of China in our global strategy and in the IT industry around the world,” Otellini said.
> 
> “Our goal in China is to support a transition from ‘manufactured in China’ to 'innovated in China,”’ he said.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Le\_Jacquelope](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/l/e0b2c6/32.png) [@Le\_Jacquelope](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Le_Jacquelope)\
**Post date:** [January 1, 2011, 9:37pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/the-power-of-creative-destruction-in-1-picture/563387/167 "2011-01-01T21:37:59Z")

</div>

> **[The Innovation Delusion](https://www.huffpost.com/entry/the-innovation-delusion_b_480794)**
>
> Pundits like Thomas Friedman are wrong to think that we can simply scale up R&D to a degree where it can be equally traded for the huge quantity of things we need but don't make in this country.

> [@](#):
>
> But the chasm-sized flaw in this otherwise alluring proposition is scale. Balancing trade on ideas and R&D simply cannot be done. The most elementary analysis shows that the scale is entirely wrong. As one who spent many years as the head of research of a large corporation, I know how much R&D matters; I also know how small it is. Eight percent is a very large percent of revenue to spend on R&D. Even in manufacturing, which is relatively R&D intensive, 4 to 5 percent is typical. It is really wrong to think that you can scale up R&D to be big enough so we can trade it for the huge quantity of things we need but don’t make in this country.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![emacknight](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/e/3ec8ea/32.png) [@emacknight](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/emacknight)\
**Post date:** [January 1, 2011, 10:20pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/the-power-of-creative-destruction-in-1-picture/563387/168 "2011-01-01T22:20:27Z")

</div>

I saw a lot or words, but didn’t see an answer to my question, so I’ll ask again.

Right now, Target is selling an Apple iPod touch® 32GB for $294.99.

If tomorrow Target had them on sale for $25, do you think they would sell more, fewer, or the same number of units?

Alternatively, if tomorrow they set the price to $25000 do you think they would sell more, fewer, or the same number of units?

Is there a price where people would decide to stop buying an ipod touch?

Prove that you understand the law of supply and demand, then we can move on to more complex topics like tariffs.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![emacknight](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/e/3ec8ea/32.png) [@emacknight](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/emacknight)\
**Post date:** [January 1, 2011, 10:34pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/the-power-of-creative-destruction-in-1-picture/563387/169 "2011-01-01T22:34:34Z")

</div>

> [@Le Jacquelope](#):
>
> All of your futile attempts at logic continually ignore one basic fact: the more people are out of work in America the smaller the market is for the companies who want to sell here.

I’m quoting this hear so you can see again what you wrote. Start from the end of your statement and work backwards: If you want people to be employed, you need a larger market for companies to sell in.

Now you need to apply your logic or your facts, and try to figure out how tariffs are going to help increase the size of markets in the US.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Le\_Jacquelope](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/l/e0b2c6/32.png) [@Le\_Jacquelope](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Le_Jacquelope)\
**Post date:** [January 3, 2011, 11:45am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/the-power-of-creative-destruction-in-1-picture/563387/170 "2011-01-03T11:45:13Z")

</div>

1. 

When you lay people off and they’re earning $0 will you sell  
a) more  
b) less  
c) the same

number of goods?  
2)

If we send all those iPod jobs overseas and Foxconn workers ask for a raise, and their wages approach ours, and iPod production moves to Vietnam where their workers eventually ask for raises, then it moves to Africa, then India, then Eastern Europe…

At some point the whole world is going to be asking for normal wages and you’re going to run out of places to offshore. At that time you might as well bring production back here.

Of course this’ll be 50 years and an entire ruined American working class later, but iPods will then go back to $1500 apiece because you’ve run out of cheap labor!

Hear that buzzing sound, black knight? It’s the sound of your argument short circuiting.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Le\_Jacquelope](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/l/e0b2c6/32.png) [@Le\_Jacquelope](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Le_Jacquelope)\
**Post date:** [January 4, 2011, 8:04am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/the-power-of-creative-destruction-in-1-picture/563387/171 "2011-01-04T08:04:36Z")

</div>

A look at the structural / creative destruction effect on middle-class jobs…  
[http://www.pittsburghlive.com/x/pittsburghtrib/business/s\_698351.html](http://www.pittsburghlive.com/x/pittsburghtrib/business/s_698351.html)

> [@](#):
>
> Mid-level jobs disappearing  
> By The Associated Press  
> Wednesday, September 8, 2010
> 
> Whenever companies start hiring freely again, job-seekers with specialized skills and education will have plenty of good opportunities. Others will face a choice: Take a job with low pay – or none at all.
> 
> Job creation will likely remain weak for months or even years. But once employers do step up hiring, some economists expect job openings to fall mainly into two categories of roughly equal numbers:
> 
> •Professional fields with higher pay. Think lawyers, research scientists and software engineers.
> 
> •Lower-skill and lower-paying jobs, like home health care aides and store clerks.
> 
> And those in between? Their outlook is bleaker. Economists foresee fewer moderately paid factory supervisors, postal workers and office administrators.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Le\_Jacquelope](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/l/e0b2c6/32.png) [@Le\_Jacquelope](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Le_Jacquelope)\
**Post date:** [January 5, 2011, 4:40pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/the-power-of-creative-destruction-in-1-picture/563387/172 "2011-01-05T16:40:01Z")

</div>

The other big glaring error in emacknight’s repeatedly-asked iPod scenario question is that American labor would produce more iPods per work-hour. Their productivity levels would push iPods back down from $1500 to $300 simply because their production levels would flood the market with iPods if Apple didn’t artifically slow them down.

American workers are known for their superior productivity. Or maybe not anymore, since I pointed it out. 😃

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Marley23](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/m/45deac/32.png) [@Marley23](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Marley23)\
**Post date:** [January 5, 2011, 4:54pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/the-power-of-creative-destruction-in-1-picture/563387/173 "2011-01-05T16:54:10Z")

</div>

**Le Jacquelope** , DO NOT repost entire news articles or long excerpts of copyrighted material. Use a short quote and a link. [This is the second time I’m reminding you about this,](http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showthread.php?p=12968518#post12968518) so don’t do it again.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![mazinger\_z](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/m/5f9b8f/32.png) [@mazinger\_z](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/mazinger_z)\
**Post date:** [January 5, 2011, 8:45pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/the-power-of-creative-destruction-in-1-picture/563387/174 "2011-01-05T20:45:34Z")

</div>

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> And you handwave away the fact that the unemployed are not wealthy. Earning $0 an hour is not wealth. It is poverty, in the extreme.

Dodge. What kind of reply is this? The comparison is the wealthy US and poor China. There will always be unemployed. Even 4% (some say 5%) unemployment is start undue inflationary pressures (you can research that on your own).

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> This load of garbage argument isn’t even worth bothering with. Except to tell you it is a load of bull.

In other words, you got Jack (sorry, I couldn’t resist). If it is so much bull, where is your analysis? Like the rest of your posts, you have none. Oh, and China is importing our inflation, too. I already know what you’re going to reply with (i.e. Apple Ipod production), so save it. You’re wrong there too, which I will point out soon enough.

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> All I need to explain to you is we have 16 million people out of work and your arguments pretty much leave them stranded. Permanently.
> 
> We need tariffs to put them back to work.
> 
> It’s either that, or the dollar inevitably collapses and that creates a NATURAL tariff.
> 
> It is impossible for us to continue this course without another Depression. Which, if you know any history, we’ve had before.

What 1929? Arguably 2008? Even assuming what you say is true, I will gladly take a 70 year depression cycle, and I would even be more glad to live through two of them (mainly because I’d rather not be dead). I’ve seen to have done fine so far (2008 - present) so I must be doing something right. Regardless, you are dodging the argument again. Claiming that there is any unemployed pretty much any argument, even your one-note analysis.

‘Free markets should be pursued.’  
‘No, there are X number unemployed, it proves such a strategy doesn’t work.’

‘We should pursue large protective tariffs..’  
‘No, there are X number of unemployed, it proves such a strategy doesn’t work.’

‘We should pray to god Kali, he will make our economy better…’  
‘No, there are X number of unemployed, it proves such a strategy doesn’t work.’

Oh, and add “history proves right” to all of those to complete the argument, i.e. simple conclusion statements without any analysis. Seriously, with every point in history, the sheer progression of wealth and the standard of living since Adam Smith proves your arguments wrong.

And your coining of the term “natural tariff” demonstrates that you know little to nothing of the very thing you advocate.

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> [http://www.epi.org/economic\_snapshots/entry/snapshot\_20090624/](http://www.epi.org/economic_snapshots/entry/snapshot_20090624/)  
> [http://www.wageindicator.org/main/collective-bargaining/2009/germany-siemens-protects-128-000-jobs-in-germany-september-22-2010](http://www.wageindicator.org/main/collective-bargaining/2009/germany-siemens-protects-128-000-jobs-in-germany-september-22-2010)
> 
> Now you go ahead and tell me how “job guarantees” is not protectionism.

Not that this is a surprise to anyone, but these quotes do not mean what you think they mean. Because the word “protect” is used, does not mean actual protectionism, at least not in the economic sense, not vis-a-vis another country. The word you are looking for is subsidization. The connection between subsidization and actual protectionism is a tenuous connection at best, and complete fails in this argument. Notice, that these jobs programs do not put a higher price on imported goods. Notice again, that these actions are not in conflict with the EU, GATT or WTO all of which advocate free trade amongst its members. This is like saying any country that engages in minimum wage is a protectionist economy. Good luck on finding that true Scotsman.

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> Going by your logic if we just let all the jobs in this country go to cheaper labor we’ll be even BETTER off.
> 
> All of your futile attempts at logic continually ignore one basic fact: the more people are out of work in America the smaller the market is for the companies who want to sell here.

What you fail to do is distinguish low-skilled, button-pushing labor vs. actual labor that people compete for. Before you post any more snapshots of the economy, do factor in the recession which far outweighs any trade imbalance, or economic re-adjustment. Otherwise, your arguments are only centered on the view that there is a fixed pie of economic wealth, jobs, wages, earnings, etc. Clearly, you must be aware you are wrong in that thinking.

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> _Sigh_ Must I educate you on everything?

The only thing you are educating anyone on anything is your own ignorance.

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> The middle class was shrinking long before 2007, with more people going to the ranks of the poor than the ranks of the rich.

I’ve already posted my cites against this. Before you post your cherry picking site from axe-grinding liberal and hippie web sites, do note that there isn’t a universally accepted definition of the middle class. All you’re really doing is arguing income inequality.

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> No, they weren’t. It was all false, based upon an orgy of buying on margin, the use of credit cards and people using their homes as ATMs. Employment was flat, with new jobs not keeping up with new entrants to the workforce, and wages were falling behind inflation.

Right, my parents, my best friend, and HR manager didn’t buy new cars in 2007. I didn’t buy a new house in 2007. My sister didn’t expand her portfolio, the DOW wasn’t trading at 14k? Are you sure about that? All these people still have their cars. I still live in my house. I can find statistics that stocks were trading at the 14k mark in 2007. None of this happened? Am I dreaming? Of all the times to step out of your binary thinking, this isn’t one of them. Clearly these transactions took place. Whether they were wise decisions, is the subject of another matter, but does not mean that they did not take place.

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> I’ve cited all of this repeatedly. At this point one can only assume you’re intentionally discounting it.

To be fair, I didn’t start double-checking your cites until I started finding false ones (see my last post). You’re 0-for-2 so far.

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> Just like you discounted it when I pointed out to you that innovation jobs were going overseas, too.

You didn’t point it out to me specifically. But, others have already refuted your notion. Your snapshots into the economy are much like your arguments, devoid of context, logic and reasoning. I don’t need to repeat what others have said and what you are failing to grasp.

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> The standard of living has been increasing for whom? Certainly not the jobless.

Keep moving the goal posts. It does so much to bolster your arguments [/sarcasm].

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> More temper tantrums. What you claim to know is clearly contradicted by what is currently going on.

So, you know nothing about inflation, chained dollar averages, supply and demand? Because, you haven’t answered the question. Because when a call drops, disconnects, I have to press the on button on my tv twice, turn my ignition key again, Outlook crashes, these all mean that these various systems have failed…because fluctuations or variance don’t exist in your world, does it Captain Binary?

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> Neither you nor Sam Stone have any salient points. What you have are temper tantrums and cookie cutter arguments that reek of desperation.

More dodging. There are calculators out there you know, that price a car (or any good) at any given year compared to now (or other time frames) you know. Just admit you’re wrong. Of course, you would have to admit then you know nothing about inflation either, real vs. nominal…etc…

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> LOL! Does your _ahem_ understanding of supply and demand address what happens to a market when you put 16 million people out of work? What happens to demand when a bunch of people are earning $0? Ah yes, you have zero idea of the answer to that - this you have already shown. In spades.

Another dodge. So, you don’t know the interaction between supply and demand? Again you belabor X million out of work, when there is always people out of work. The price of tea in China is what again? In this particular example, all things being equal is that demand drops. Just like what happens when you raise the price of anything. Except now, you’ve affected 300 million people with your tariffs, whereas only 16 million were affected before. Does that sound rational to you, making everything more painful for everyone else is more desirable than limiting it to only a few in the first place?

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> Oh yeah I know - we’re in a recession. Exactly when do you think those people will find jobs again? Ah yes, that’s where your knowledge of economics plays the “somewhere over the rainbow” card.

In short, yes, that’s what happens. To claim anything else would imply one had a crystal ball. The long answer involves the setting of a new lower equilibrium and the destruction of wealth and earning capacity, which is exactly the road we will be on if we continue protectionist policies. I won’t even bother explaining this to you, since you are routinely failing to grasp even the most basic of other concepts involved in this discussion.

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> At the expense of other consumer electronics. Did you miss that part?

No surprise, but you did miss the part that it only covered the Christmas season. Electronics have no season. I won’t bother repeating what you intentionally deleted.

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> Going by your logic, if we laid off 16 million MORE Americans, say from retail, and replaced them with cheap immigrant labor, we could shave another what, $50 off the cost of the average iPod? Going by your “logic”, we could replace the delivery drivers with ultra cheap immigrant labor and … hell, if we displaced 64 million Americans with lower wage workers we could get the cost of an iPod down to what, $199?  
> Going by your logic, if we displaced ALL Americans with rock bottom immigrant labor and sent overseas everything that’s not nailed down, iPods would be $50 and everything else would be SUPER cheap!

_sigh_ (for real) This isn’t what is happening and it isn’t what is being argued. Additionally, it fails to comprehend the overall wealth generation from the trade. The short answer is that obviously this is a good trade as more and more iProducts continue to be sold, new products continue to be sold, innovation continues to happen.

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> Problem is, who would be around to buy anything?

And, yet, the same can be said about raising tariffs. Funny that…

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> When you send jobs overseas you’re not replacing them with anything here. Except maybe lower-paying cashier jobs. In essence you’re shrinking the market of people who can afford iPods - and if they can buy iPods they’re not buying much else.

Except that isn’t what is happening. More products are being created, demand is up. Business, even my department, are talking about giving iPads to its workers. If the market were truly shrinking, then there wouldn’t be any more iProducts. Apple wouldn’t waste their time and move on to something else.

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> That’s only part of the argument. You’ve intentionally left out what happens to demand when you have more and more people who have no jobs, and wages that are stagnating. You probably left this out because it completely undermines your _laugh_ argument.

Really, when I said “all things being equal” is leaving it out? Even with your misunderstanding, the lower price point does not impact the overall wealth from the parties or from the wealth created by the trade. Hyperbole does not a good argument make.

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> In that case who will they have for customers?
> 
> There goes your ENTIRE argument in its own mushroom cloud.

Do you even know what you’re writing? You are saying that business hire people to have customers. Do you really believe that? Is this really worth addressing? Do you not see anything wrong with that business model?

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> False dichotomy. Most people would rather not be poor or homeless anywhere.

Dodge.

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> Subsistence farming is like scavenging. Ohkay, that wins the prize for first uber clueless comment of the year. I’m sure you’ll post more to top that soon.

Both subsistence farming and scavenging earn no wages. Your idea of wage representation for effort only matters in your world.

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> You just contradicted yourself. And then hung a lampshade on it!

If you could only reason, you would have realized that I said that wages mean that you are earning dollars (or whatever currency you want to use) for your efforts. Since we are not in a barter economy, you are hard pressed to find any actual wages being paid. Who is paying them? Oh, that’s right, nobody. Self-employed implies that you are earning wages through your own efforts, that still means actually getting paid from someone. See, I told you wouldn’t get it.

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> You’re confusing their economics with their human rights issues. The two are not the same. Again, your “arguments” have no resemblance to analysis whatsoever. However it does have a great resemblance to propaganda.

Do you not have a creative bone in your body? Are you going to turn around everything I write? Whatever… Again, look at the standard of living and GDP between the two. It’s a small snapshot because mass murder makes it hard to be productive. Just in case you’re curious, you would comparing a largely 19th century agrarian society against an industrialized, automated, mass-manufacturing economy, even with the depression, the USSR was a poor choice. But, I know you are looking at the issue way too literally. You might have well said the Aboriginal people.

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> And I’ll be pleased when you actually make one.
> 
> Why should we hire those 16 million Americans? What else are we going to do with them? What’s to stop those 16 million people from growing? Oh wait, they are. We STILL don’t have enough jobs being produced to serve the new entrants to the workforce.
> 
> Those 16 million people can drag our entire economy into the dirt. Unless you suggest we just cut off services to them in which case you’re looking at a revolution. Which’ll cost America even more.
> 
> Your entire “argument” fails to look at anything from the perspective of those 16 million people.

Really, more hyperbole? The unemployment rate just didn’t drop again? And, why are we concentrating on 16 million? We just threw how many billions at the banks and the auto industry? 16 million is not going to ‘drag the economy into the dirt.’

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> You epic fail once again. US unemployment wasn’t much lower - we go by the U3 standard while Europe goes by the U6. Going by U6 standards the U.S. and Europe had quite similar numbers.

U3 is the ILO standard, and used in comparison between countries (yes, including European nations).

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> Your point stands much in the same way that Ronald Reagan is still standing.
> 
> First you counter my claim that homelessness has been on the rise since the start of this subprime crash with the claim that homelessness was down in the years before?
> 
> Well hell, I can respond with the fact that homelessness was up before that, as recently as 2003:  
> [http://www.usatoday.com/money/economy/2003-08-11-homeless\_x.htm](http://www.usatoday.com/money/economy/2003-08-11-homeless_x.htm)

Yes, fluctuations don’t matter in your world.

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> And it’s been up since at least 2009:  
> [http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2009-04-05-homeless\_N.htm](http://www.usatoday.com/news/nation/2009-04-05-homeless_N.htm)

Recession.

Keep moving the goal posts. You can still use the “What about the children?” argument. Yet, it will do nothing to explain that protectionism is terrible for any economy.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Le\_Jacquelope](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/l/e0b2c6/32.png) [@Le\_Jacquelope](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Le_Jacquelope)\
**Post date:** [January 5, 2011, 9:38pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/the-power-of-creative-destruction-in-1-picture/563387/175 "2011-01-05T21:38:51Z")

</div>

After going well over the 20,000 character limit taking snapshots of where your argument rigorously deconstructs itself, I’m just going to trim this down to the TOP 5-ranked deluded arguments that you posted here. That being the 5 most hilarious among all the failed cartoonish points you tried to make.

> [@mazinger\_z](#):
>
> I’ve already posted my cites against this. Before you post your cherry picking site from axe-grinding liberal and hippie web sites,

Such as? [Factcheck.org](http://Factcheck.org) even explains the middle class is shrinking.

While you’re at it, go look up “plutocracy” while you’re at it.

> [@](#):
>
> Right, my parents, my best friend, and HR manager didn’t buy new cars in 2007. I didn’t buy a new house in 2007. My sister didn’t expand her portfolio, the DOW wasn’t trading at 14k? Are you sure about that?

It happened because the economy was lying to itself. Ever heard of a house of cards?

> [@](#):
>
> You didn’t point it out to me specifically. But, others have already refuted your notion.

No one anywhere on here has ever refuted the fact that we’re bleeding research jobs overseas. Show where that has happened. Go look up biotech offshoring if you believe it is untrue.

> [@](#):
>
> Another dodge. So, you don’t know the interaction between supply and demand? Again you belabor X million out of work, when there is always people out of work. The price of tea in China is what again? In this particular example, all things being equal is that demand drops. Just like what happens when you raise the price of anything. Except now, you’ve affected 300 million people with your tariffs, whereas only 16 million were affected before.

Wrong. AGAIN. In manufacturing, American productivity outsizes China’s by a factor of 9 to 1. (cite: [http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/20572828/](http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/20572828/)) Bringing the work back here would mean a 5x increase in labor price and a 9 to 1 drop in work hours needed to produce the goods. The cost of iPods (originally $300) would be multiplied by 5/9, depending on how well worker productivity interacts with the machinery.

I’m amazed that you don’t understand the basic concept of productivity and its relationship with wages when calculating the price of goods. Oh no, wait, I’m not surprised.

Let’s start with the simple stuff.  
Factory A: Johnny is working for $5 an hour and he produces 9 iPods an hour.  
Factory B: Richard is working for $1 an hour and he produces 1 iPod an hour.

Which factory produces iPods at the cheapest cost?

> [@](#):
>
> Do you even know what you’re writing? You are saying that business hire people to have customers. Do you really believe that? Is this really worth addressing? Do you not see anything wrong with that business model?

That isn’t even what I’m saying. If one company lays off its staff and moves overseas, that doesn’t hurt the overall economy. But when thousands of companies do this and MILLIONS of jobs are lost as a result, that’s a lot of people who are earning $0 and will not be able to afford goods at any price. The more workers get laid off the more won’t be able to afford anything. It’s like pissing in a big pool: one swimmer won’t be a problem but get 100 people on the side taking a whizz and you’ve got problems for everyone in the pool.

Furthermore you have yet to show how sending jobs offshore creates jobs in other areas. A lot of companies simply pocket the profits. Case in point: the ginormous cash reserves corporations are amassing right now.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Shodan](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/s/9f8e36/32.png) [@Shodan](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Shodan)\
**Post date:** [January 5, 2011, 11:28pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/the-power-of-creative-destruction-in-1-picture/563387/176 "2011-01-05T23:28:31Z")

</div>

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> [Factcheck.org](http://Factcheck.org) even explains the middle class is shrinking.

[According to the census, the proportion of U.S. families in that category, after adjustment for inflation, shrank from 65.1% in 1970 to 58.2% in 1985 (see chart). The trend is far from being a completely odious phenomenon, though. The statistics show that more families departing the middle class have moved up than down.](http://www.time.com/time/magazine/article/0,9171,962753,00.html)

> [@](#):
>
> Wrong. AGAIN. In manufacturing, American productivity outsizes China’s by a factor of 9 to 1. (cite: [http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/20572828/](http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/20572828/)) Bringing the work back here would mean a 5x increase in labor price and a 9 to 1 drop in work hours needed to produce the goods. The cost of iPods (originally $300) would be multiplied by 5/9, depending on how well worker productivity interacts with the machinery.

So, not only do we need tariffs to prevent free trade from benefiting our economy and that of the Third World, we also need tariffs because our workers are so productive that we can out-produce everyone else.

> [@](#):
>
> Let’s start with the simple stuff.  
> Factory A: Johnny is working for $5 an hour and he produces 9 iPods an hour.  
> Factory B: Richard is working for $1 an hour and he produces 1 iPod an hour.
> 
> Which factory produces iPods at the cheapest cost?

If this “analysis” were at all valid, one would wonder why anyone ever outsourced at all.

I realize you are denying yourself the benefit of my posts, but you cannot deny me the pleasure of pointing out the awe-inspiring foolishness of your posts.

Regards,  
Shodan

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![msmith537](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/m/d9b06d/32.png) [@msmith537](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/msmith537)\
**Post date:** [January 5, 2011, 11:57pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/the-power-of-creative-destruction-in-1-picture/563387/177 "2011-01-05T23:57:46Z")

</div>

> [@Le\_Jacquelope](#):
>
> Such as? [Factcheck.org](http://Factcheck.org) even explains the middle class is shrinking.

[http://www.factcheck.org/askfactcheck/is\_there\_a\_standard\_accepted\_definition\_of.html](http://www.factcheck.org/askfactcheck/is_there_a_standard_accepted_definition_of.html)

"There is no standard definition, and in fact, an overwhelming majority of Americans say they are “middle class” or “upper-middle class” or “working class” in public opinion polls. Hardly anybody considers themselves “lower class” or “upper class” in America…

…  
So what do politicians mean when they say “the middle class”? … Each politician may be talking about a different group of Americans, but the message many voters hear is that the politician is talking about them."

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Le\_Jacquelope](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/l/e0b2c6/32.png) [@Le\_Jacquelope](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Le_Jacquelope)\
**Post date:** [January 6, 2011, 11:03am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/the-power-of-creative-destruction-in-1-picture/563387/178 "2011-01-06T11:03:24Z")

</div>

> [@msmith537](#):
>
> [http://www.factcheck.org/askfactcheck/is\_there\_a\_standard\_accepted\_definition\_of.html](http://www.factcheck.org/askfactcheck/is_there_a_standard_accepted_definition_of.html)
> 
> "There is no standard definition, and in fact, an overwhelming majority of Americans say they are “middle class” or “upper-middle class” or “working class” in public opinion polls. Hardly anybody considers themselves “lower class” or “upper class” in America…
> 
> …  
> So what do politicians mean when they say “the middle class”? … Each politician may be talking about a different group of Americans, but the message many voters hear is that the politician is talking about them."

But yet at the same time the latest Factcheck study confirms that by any possible definition ($25,000-75,000), they were shrinking as of 2003.

[http://www.factcheck.org/article249.html](http://www.factcheck.org/article249.html)

The \<$25,000 group increased faster than the \>$75,000 group. Twice as fast, no less.

It’s unlikely that this trend changed from 2004-2007.

Is $25,000-$75,000 broad enough for you?

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Mijin](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/mijin/32/9369_2.png) [@Mijin](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Mijin)\
**Post date:** [January 6, 2011, 7:45pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/the-power-of-creative-destruction-in-1-picture/563387/179 "2011-01-06T19:45:05Z")

</div>

nm

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![treis](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/t/bc79bd/32.png) [@treis](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/treis)\
**Post date:** [January 6, 2011, 9:13pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/the-power-of-creative-destruction-in-1-picture/563387/180 "2011-01-06T21:13:52Z")

</div>

> [@Raskolnikov](#):
>
> very ignorant, when you graduate college in Germany or Sweden I guarantee you nobody has 30,000 in school loans to pay off, no med school grad has 175,000 in debt to pay (the avg. for US med school grads)
> 
> there isn’t one citizen in Germany or Sweden who has a 3,000 or 5,000 or 8,000 yearly deductible on their health insurance premium either.
> 
> and when the price of gas skyrockets , guess what, they have a well developed public transportation system to choose from if they don’t want to drive. (New yorkers and selected residents of a few large metropolises in the US aside)

There are certainly some advantages to the European system, but on the flip side, the taxes in the U.S. are much less, unemployment is lower, and the purchasing power of the population is much greater. So yeah, an engineer in the U.S. might have 30gs in loans after school, but he is more likely to find a job, have a higher salary, and pay less of his income in taxes.

I think there is some confusion as to why we don’t have a great public transportation system in the U.S. The first reason is a simple matter of geography. Our country is bigger, and it’s population is more spread out. As you note, when the population density reaches that of Europe, we have a similar level of public transportation. The second reason is that the reality is that most people want to live in the suburbs and drive their own car. The reason that we lack much public transportation is because the demand is low due to the fact that most people are rich enough to afford the cars they need.

I mean, look at what you said. You said when the price of gas sky rockets they can choose public transportation if they don’t want to drive. The reality of that situation is that the people still do want to drive, they just can’t afford it.

> [@Raskolnikov](#):
>
> I’ll let you in on a little secret, euros do pay higher taxes (although the highest tax bracket in germany is only 45% compared to 35% here) but they aren’t nickled and dimed on every other little aspect of thier lives.
> 
> guess who really needs to catch up?

_shrug_. You run on the “cut GDP by 1/4 and raise taxes” platform, and see how it works. Not that I don’t agree with the health care bit, but the regulations on the job market in Europe and the taxes do a number on employment and wages.

[Previous page](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/the-power-of-creative-destruction-in-1-picture/563387.md?page=8)

[Next page](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/the-power-of-creative-destruction-in-1-picture/563387.md?page=10)
