And Middle Class is defined as what again? See the other thread on the topic. Your arguments demonstrate nothing but a class warrior mentality.
This argument reminds me of the people who claim not be smokers because they only smoke on the weekend or while they’re drinking. They’re still smokers. Transactions still occurred, purchases were made. Why do you continue to refute this? Take off the blinders.
Even if true, so what? Before you drudge up any other “explanation” you have to first overcome your “fixed-pie” mentality. Just face it, there are not a finite number of jobs out there. History has shown that there is not a fixed amount of wealth. There, you should be able to understand that argument.
Comparative Advantage. There is a lot to process there, be sure to click through all the links. And, before you tell me that “things are different now” or other such nonsense, to use one of your favorite arguments, for surely you will comprehend, “history has shown comparative advantage to work, since the 1870’s” (actually even before that as it was happening before people realized it was happening). To ignore comparative advantage irrefutably demonstrates a lack of knowledge of productivity.
Except, that’s what you said. Quote: “In that case who will they have for customers?” (in reference to business not hiring.)
That’s right because jobs will never come back. Resources will sit here idly until entropy. [/sarcasm]