Songs by bands that lost at least 60% of their original members and stayed successful
Me and Sarah Jane - Genesis
Refuse/Resist - Sepultura
Red, White, & Blue - Lynyrd Skynyrd
For My Broken Heart - Reba McEntire
McEntire lost most of her touring band in a plane crash in 91. Her next album, For My Broken Heart, was dedicated to them and is also the name of the first track.
Songs by bands that lost at least 60% of their original members and stayed successful
Me and Sarah Jane - Genesis
Refuse/Resist - Sepultura
Red, White, & Blue - Lynyrd Skynyrd
For My Broken Heart - Reba McEntire
I Just Can’t Take It Anymore - The Lemonheads
Wondrous Stories - Yes
Yes has had a huge number of different lineups, though many of their well-known songs have at least 3 of the original 5 members. “Wondrous Stories,” from 1977’s “Going for the One,” has only Jon Anderson and Chris Squire. The current lineup, in fact, has no original members.
Songs by bands that lost at least 60% of their original members and stayed successful
Me and Sarah Jane - Genesis
Refuse/Resist - Sepultura
Red, White, & Blue - Lynyrd Skynyrd
For My Broken Heart - Reba McEntire
I Just Can’t Take It Anymore - The Lemonheads
Wondrous Stories - Yes
Minute by Minute - The Doobie Brothers
We Built This City - Starship
Grace Slick retired not long after this. She was not an original member, and I don’t think any original members were left at this point. Most of them were gone by the time they renamed themselves Starship.