# Trans HS students - access to locker rooms

**URL:** <https://boards.straightdope.com/t/trans-hs-students-access-to-locker-rooms/734540>\
**Category:** Great Debates\
**Created:** [October 13, 2015, 12:28pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/trans-hs-students-access-to-locker-rooms/734540 "2015-10-13T12:28:44Z")\
**Posts on this page:** 20\
**Page:** 12

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Shodan](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/s/9f8e36/32.png) [@Shodan](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Shodan)\
**Post date:** [October 16, 2015, 2:08pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/trans-hs-students-access-to-locker-rooms/734540/221 "2015-10-16T14:08:01Z")

</div>

> [@andros](#):
>
> Why are you so resistant to answering the question? I honestly don’t understand the point of the game-playing.

Because it’s not going to help anything to answer the question. **even sven** and others would like it if I accepted _their_ definitions.

Nonetheless -

> [@](#):
>
> Do you believe that transwomen, as you understand the term, are women, as you understand the term?

Okay, then Yes. But it’s not going to help, because the student in the OP is not a transwoman as I understand the term, and therefore is not a woman. And the question remains why I should accept his/her definition instead of the generally accepted notion that a woman doesn’t have a penis.

Regards,  
Shodan

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Czarcasm](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/czarcasm/32/4050_2.png) [@Czarcasm](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Czarcasm)\
**Post date:** [October 16, 2015, 2:13pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/trans-hs-students-access-to-locker-rooms/734540/222 "2015-10-16T14:13:14Z")

</div>

> [@Shodan](#):
>
> Because it’s not going to help anything to answer the question. **even sven** and others would like it if I accepted _their_ definitions.
> 
> Nonetheless -  
> Okay, then Yes. But it’s not going to help, because the student in the OP is not a transwoman as I understand the term, and therefore is not a woman. And the question remains why I should accept his/her definition instead of the generally accepted notion that a woman doesn’t have a penis.
> 
> Regards,  
> Shodan

So, just to clarify, what _is_ a “transwoman” as you understand the term? I would like to know why the student in the OP doesn’t qualify.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![andros](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/a/e480ec/32.png) [@andros](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/andros)\
**Post date:** [October 16, 2015, 3:28pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/trans-hs-students-access-to-locker-rooms/734540/223 "2015-10-16T15:28:47Z")

</div>

> [@Shodan](#):
>
> Because it’s not going to help anything to answer the question. **even sven** and others would like it if I accepted _their_ definitions.
> 
> Nonetheless -  
> Okay, then Yes. But it’s not going to help, because the student in the OP is not a transwoman as I understand the term, and therefore is not a woman.

Cheers, mate, thank you.

> [@](#):
>
> And the question remains why I should accept his/her definition instead of the generally accepted notion that a woman doesn’t have a penis.

I think that’s a problematic definition on many levels.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Una\_Persson](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/una_persson/32/346_2.png) [@Una\_Persson](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Una_Persson)\
**Post date:** [October 16, 2015, 4:08pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/trans-hs-students-access-to-locker-rooms/734540/224 "2015-10-16T16:08:22Z")

</div>

> [@Czarcasm](#):
>
> So, just to clarify, what _is_ a “transwoman” as you understand the term? I would like to know why the student in the OP doesn’t qualify.

I’m suspecting that he’s focused upon the penis, and nothing but. Which if true, is an unfortunately ignorant of the realities of the transition process and the quality of life issues.

Back in the bad-old-days, the standard practice was the “real-life trial” before any hormones or surgery were approved. Generally speaking, the transgender person would have to upend their life and start dressing and working and playing and everything else as a woman. After this trial (which some psychiatrists demanded encompass years) then hormones would be prescribed, and surgery would come later. But it was traditional that one must live as a woman for a very long time without treatment.

In the late 1960’s the trends changed, and hormones were now available as part of the real-life trial on occasion. And as time has passed, psychologists have determined that early hormone use yields much better mental and physical results, especially when it comes to quality of live. This has helped things tremendously, as it allowed the transgender person to begin to experience the positive effects of having the correct hormone balance for them, both in mind and body. Surgery might come 2-4 years later. Nowadays, we have stricter counseling and even better understanding, and some can receive a letter for surgery in a year - and if they have a diagnosed intersex condition, almost immediately (raises hand).

Surgery has always been a high barrier, mostly due to the cost and the toll on one’s body. And the availability of SRS surgeons who could give good results was quite small, until the so-called “Biber revolution,” where Dr. Stanley Biber in the 1980’s started to introduce other doctors to new techniques and to actively train them.

So traditionally it was normal for transgender persons to have their penis for some time after transition. If one is solely focused upon penii, then they could say in their mind that a transgender woman is not a woman. Unfortunately, the medical establishment disagrees with their laypersons phallocentric idealism.

Even in 2015 most health plans don’t cover transgender surgery, or if they do, there is a waiting period of years involved sometimes. I’m incredibly lucky, in that I am upper-middle-class and kept my career after transition. My surgeries were no financial burden to me. But a very large percentage of the transgender community is desperately poor, unemployed or underemployed, and for them even a $17k Thailand option is as unlikely as buying a new Ferrari. In the US and Canada, fees run from $22k - $40k for transgender women (depending upon what they need done). For transgender men…I’ve met some who spent over $70k in total - out of pocket - for their phalloplasties.

And some women and men are prohibited from surgery due to health reasons. I know several for whom no surgeon will work on them due to poor physical health. The surgeries take a lot out of you.

Defining a woman as “she who shall not haveth a penis” has historical basis; it would be ignorant to not admit that. But we need not be slaves to history. Recognizing that a transgender person may have financial or health reasons for being prohibited from sex reassignment surgery, to set the bar of womanhood as having a vagina is cruel, almost vindictive.

So the WPATH standards today do not require surgery for a woman or man to be considered “transsexual,” and they certainly don’t require it for a the broader term of “transgender.” This is not even a matter for debate, and I believe the APA, AMA, and others back this up. Some transgender women change their names, their gender markers, work, play, love, and live while still keeping a few ounces of flesh - which for many of us stopped working sexually after a couple of years on hormones anyhow - until they have the resources to get rid of it.

And yes, not all transgender women do get rid of it, even those with money and in good health. Some keep it simply because their mental status is so much better, they can ignore their genitals and just get on with life. A significant number of us are asexual, and would never be in a position to display their genitals to anyone other than a doctor. Said one transgender person to me, “I’ve been transitioned socially and legally for 5 years. I have a great job. Everyone treats me as a woman. My spouse doesn’t care what genitals I have. I have lots of friends and my family backs me. Why would I want to spend $28k for surgery, undergo a lengthy and painful recovery, and then have daily maintenance? I can ignore what’s down there for now.”

If some would like all transgender women to no longer have penii, guess what, that’s what most (but not all) of us want too. It’s also a position not backed in WPATH and other transgender standard practice. The reality of the situation is that in order to have a greatly improved assimilation into society, a transgender woman needs to have some significant length of time living as a woman while on hormones, so they can be certain surgery is what they need. In fact, I recall being debated in other threads where some claimed surgery was such an extreme step that it should be prohibited for transgender persons. It’s sort of damned-if-you-do, damned-if-you-don’t.

And as I’ve expressed before, I would reckon that most people who are skeptical, uneasy, or even hate people like me have never actually met one of us and spent some time talking with us face to face, nor actually looked hard at the numerous barriers society has placed in our way. Paraphrasing Julia Serano, I had the entire weight of my family, peer groups, schools, churches, employers, and even Society itself cracking down on me, every hour of the day, trying to force this round peg into a square hole. And despite all that crushing pressure to conform, my gender identity stayed constant and led me to this place. A place I would rather die than leave.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Smapti](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/smapti/32/17938_2.png) [@Smapti](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Smapti)\
**Post date:** [October 16, 2015, 4:22pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/trans-hs-students-access-to-locker-rooms/734540/225 "2015-10-16T16:22:40Z")

</div>

So, just so we’re clear here, the anti-discrimination laws, as they have been enacted/proposed thus far, would _not_ allow a male who was born male and has historically identified as a male to loiter in a women’s restroom/locker/etc. for prurient purposes and exempt himself from punishment by claiming at the time of arrest that he was transgender, right?

Because if this is a situation that the proposed laws wouldn’t even permit in the first place, then it seems that a great big chunk of this argument is moot to begin with.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Una\_Persson](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/una_persson/32/346_2.png) [@Una\_Persson](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Una_Persson)\
**Post date:** [October 16, 2015, 5:23pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/trans-hs-students-access-to-locker-rooms/734540/226 "2015-10-16T17:23:56Z")

</div>

> [@Smapti](#):
>
> So, just so we’re clear here, the anti-discrimination laws, as they have been enacted/proposed thus far, would _not_ allow a male who was born male and has historically identified as a male to loiter in a women’s restroom/locker/etc. for prurient purposes and exempt himself from punishment by claiming at the time of arrest that he was transgender, right?

Some states have laws explicitly stating that female facilities are only meant for women. However, in most (all that I’ve seen or researched?) cases no mention whatsoever is made for transgender or transsexual women, nor intersex persons. Normally, the authorities are supposed to go by what the gender marker on your state-issued or federal-issued ID says.

In most states, you only get that gender marker via proof of surgery or proof of being a transsexual, or a court order (which requires the aforementioned proof be shown to a judge), or both. However, some states place such a high bar to changing gender markers that even transsexuals who have had full surgery have difficulty changing their marker. But it’s getting better, and quite rapidly.

I know of no laws on the books nor proposed which allow a male who identifies as a male to present a defense that they are suddenly transgender and should use a women’s bathroom or locker room. I would imagine the first thing the prosecutor would ask for is the name of the psychologist they worked with, a carry letter, or some other clearly compelling evidence that shows they in fact were honestly transgender. Obviously, if they’re not, then they should be subject to the penalties of law. IANA prosecutor, but I have worked with several who have said that is exactly what they would do.

But here we’re sort of speculating.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![jimbuff314](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/j/c57346/32.png) [@jimbuff314](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/jimbuff314)\
**Post date:** [October 16, 2015, 6:04pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/trans-hs-students-access-to-locker-rooms/734540/227 "2015-10-16T18:04:16Z")

</div>

> [@tomndebb](#):
>
> Alkash, you have had your fun. Now it stops.  
> […] [/Moderating]

_::sad face::_ \<—!

About the reason you give for having to edit your post. I hear you, my hermaphroditic overlord. I got jumped on a couple of days ago by a trigger-happy grammar Nazi when my iPhone auto-corrected “rein” to “reign” and I failed to notice it. Would that I were a Mod, and such jumping-on would have the kindness and humour of **Frank** ’s.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![YogSothoth](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/y/8edcca/32.png) [@YogSothoth](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/YogSothoth)\
**Post date:** [October 16, 2015, 9:50pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/trans-hs-students-access-to-locker-rooms/734540/228 "2015-10-16T21:50:07Z")

</div>

> [@Bricker](#):
>
> In my view, this is a good example of the kind of easily refutable absolute statements that I spoke of earlier. While it is sometimes true that forcing a woman to use facilities that single her out is a violation of her rights, it’s by no means always true. The law regards sex-based and gender-based classification as subject to only _intermediate scrutiny_. Further, the law is not yet at the point that pre-operative trans women are unambiguously regarded as women for the purposes of civil rights analysis. The law differs between jurisdictions; within a single state a large city may have ordinances that provide robust protection but leave similarly situated rural women’s rights unclear.
> 
> When you argue like this, you invite your opponents to focus on your easily refuted absolute statements. In my opinion, you are better served focusing on the desired social policy than on declarations of fact that aren’t always accurate.

I’m not a lawyer so I will get some areas of the law wrong. That said, I’ll qualify my statements to read that _I believe_ that what the school is doing by singling her out would be fodder for a lawyer because I believe that the case is similar enough to the whole separate-but-equal fiasco that an easy case can be made. Looking at how far and fast gay rights has progressed, I’ve no doubt that public perception is rapidly moving towards inclusion rather than exclusion, and soon, if not now a case can be won for transgender rights that will force the school not to single anyone out for transgender reasons. I don’t think what I’ve said is easily refutable as I’m mostly arrogantly speculating on the ease of which a case can be won, with good reason I think, based on how fast we were able to get gay marriage legalized since it became a hot button issue.

> [@brickbacon](#):
>
> You are assuming a lot more than that.

Perhaps. But what is not an assumption is that the school offered to accommodate. Its reasonable to assume that since they did that, they do not outright reject her identifying as a transgendered female. My response is based on that acknowledgement.

> [@brickbacon](#):
>
> Wrong. An outhouse is not at all equal to an indoor bathroom. Further the law makes PLENTY of exceptions to the ADA regarding accommodations so the idea that a building manager HAS to build a wheelchair bathroom is false. In many cases, it just comes down to money. I would think other people’s comfort and perceived safety would be regarded with at least as much regard.

So too can they accommodate her by allowing her to use the girls’ locker. As you said, sometimes it comes down to money. It will cost the school nothing to allow her to use an existing locker room. And where rights are concerned, comfort and _perceived_ safety mean little. White people’s discomfort towards blacks doesn’t mean it wasn’t a violation of their rights to make blacks use different water fountains. The outhouse example was a bit hyperbole I admit. But nobody’s being asked to build anything new. Given that we have examples in the past where such things have been deemed civil rights violations, I’m confident it will be here as well

> [@brickbacon](#):
>
> Why do you think that? Cases have gone to court already. Here is [one](http://dailycaller.com/2015/04/05/sanity-federal-court-rules-taxpayer-funded-college-can-bar-woman-from-mens-locker-room/) where your side lost. To quote the judge:

First of all, don’t trust a rag like the Daily Caller. They can’t even be arsed to call him by the correct pronoun. Second, I did some research on [that case](http://thinkprogress.org/lgbt/2015/04/02/3642054/university-of-pittsburg-transgender-suit/). It seems that Seamus Johnston had not yet met the qualification of transitioning in the state when he decided to request access to the men’s locker room. Despite what people who don’t want transgendered people to have rights believe, people who support them also do not like or want instances where false claims are enabled in the name of rights. If Johnston did not meet the standards of transition, then I would be more hesitant to grant him full rights. In the post by the OP, I assume the girl has done enough. Find me a source that says she hasn’t and I’ll change my position.

> [@brickbacon](#):
>
> Wrong. See above.

Not wrong. This case hasn’t gone to trial. If and when it does, I predict an easy victory.

> [@brickbacon](#):
>
> It is in every meaningful way.

Are different schools for black and white kids equal?

> [@brickbacon](#):
>
> Perhaps, but I think it’s clear women would feel more uncomfortable around male anatomies that male brains. Do you disagree? If you agree that is the crux of the matter, then why are you arguing gender is the issue?

Do you mean “that have” male brains? I don’t understand.

> [@brickbacon](#):
>
> Depends on the circumstances. Generally I have no issue with it if the people involved don’t.

And if there are people who have an issue with that, who do you side with?

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Miller](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/miller/32/481_2.png) [@Miller](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Miller)\
**Post date:** [October 17, 2015, 12:06am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/trans-hs-students-access-to-locker-rooms/734540/229 "2015-10-17T00:06:29Z")

</div>

> [@YogSosoth](#):
>
> Do you mean “that have” male brains? I don’t understand.

I think he meant “women would feel more uncomfortable around male anatomies _than_ male brains.” Which is patently ridiculous. You leave a male brain lying around a women’s locker room, _nobody_ is going to want to go in there.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Bricker](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/b/977dab/32.png) [@Bricker](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Bricker)\
**Post date:** [October 17, 2015, 12:24am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/trans-hs-students-access-to-locker-rooms/734540/230 "2015-10-17T00:24:35Z")

</div>

> [@YogSosoth](#):
>
> I’m not a lawyer so I will get some areas of the law wrong.  
> .  
> .  
> .  
> It seems that Seamus Johnston had not yet met the qualification of transitioning in the state when he decided to request access to the men’s locker room. Despite what people who don’t want transgendered people to have rights believe, people who support them also do not like or want instances where false claims are enabled in the name of rights. If Johnston did not meet the standards of transition, then I would be more hesitant to grant him full rights. In the post by the OP, I assume the girl has done enough. Find me a source that says she hasn’t and I’ll change my position.

I’m not sure what basis that assumption has.

The girl in the OP attends school in Cook County, Illinois.

Like Pennsylvania, Illinois requires [gender reassignment surgery](http://www.idph.state.il.us/vitalrecords/births/Pages/gender-reassignment.htm) in order to legally change gender:

> [@](#):
>
> An individual born in Illinois, with an existing Illinois birth certificate, may submit an Application for Gender Reassignment to the Department requesting to have the gender changed on his or her own birth certificate after undergoing an operation(s) having the effect of reflecting, enhancing, changing, reassigning or otherwise affecting gender.

This is virtually identical to the Pennsylvania law which governed the Seamus Johnston case.

The two cases are not, however, factually similar. Johnston is a legal adult, and perhaps some justification can be assigned to the requirement for surgery (although as an aside I will note that it is a hugely expensive undertaking and seems manifestly unfair to place such an obstacle in the way – but that’s another post’s discussion). For now, the fact is that both Pennsylvania and Illinois law require similar predicates, but even the bare justification that one might argue for Johnston’s case isn’t available here: as a minor, the girl is simply not in a position to procure gender reassignment surgery in the same way an adult might. She can’t. To require that she does is to place an insurmountable obstacle in her way.

So returning to your assumption: I doubt that she’s legally transitioned, under Illinois law, inasmuch as that legal transition requires surgery. Therefore, I doubt your conclusion that she has.

More tellingly, though, I doubt that the current state of the law in Illinois is the right one – by requiring gender reassignment surgery, whatever the marginal merits of such a rule might be for adults, effectively blocks minors from gender reassignment recognition.

I know, **YogSosoth** , that you’re in agreement with that last point – you don’t think the law should hinge on surgery, I’m almost certain. But you rested your argument on her legal status in Illinois.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![brickbacon](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/b/898d66/32.png) [@brickbacon](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/brickbacon)\
**Post date:** [October 17, 2015, 1:48am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/trans-hs-students-access-to-locker-rooms/734540/231 "2015-10-17T01:48:31Z")

</div>

> [@Kimstu](#):
>
> Again, you seem to imagine that establishing a personal and social transgender identity consists of nothing more than suddenly announcing “Hey, I’m transgender!” and everybody else immediately has to go along with it. That’s not how this works.

I have quoted a supposed expert in this field stating she thinks that is essentially how this should work. So you if you want to have some detailed, explicit framework that is more complex and nuanced, please present it. Otherwise, stop saying such a thing cannot be a sudden pronouncement because that’s exactly the minimum standard that exists if all you require is self-identification. Yes, in the vast majority of cases people will do more to transition, but if it’s not required, then your critique is moot.

> [@Kimstu](#):
>
> It just doesn’t make sense to worry that we’re going to see significant numbers of non-transgender boys spending years of their lives demanding to wear skirts and constantly faking severe gender dysphoria, including during multiple counseling sessions and evaluations with psychologists, just in the hopes of eventually being falsely assessed as transgender so they can get into girls’ restrooms to ogle undressed girls. As others have pointed out, there are **way** easier methods of ogling undressed girls nowadays.

Point out where ANYONE said this was a huge worry ASSUMING you have significant barriers of entry and sufficient scrutiny? The issue is that multiple people KEEP arguing all that should be required is a sincere conviction and perhaps a doctor’s note. That’s nonsense. And that’s only addressing the more straightforward case of someone transitioning from one gender to another. What should be done about bigender people who sincerely feel they should be able to use whatever facilities they choose based on their sincerely felt gender at the time? Now since I have asked this question at least twice before and your side has chosen to ignore it, please don’t bother responding without answering it with a proposed solution that makes sense.

> [@Kimstu](#):
>
> Wait, are you saying that you don’t consider Caitlyn Jenner’s self-identification as a transgender woman to be genuine?

I have a fairly hard time considering anything that family does as completely genuine, but I fully believe Jenner is sincere generally speaking. I don’t think it’s some kind of stunt or ruse if that is what you are asking. However, I think Jenner’s conduct is such that it, at least in her case, radically undercuts this idea that identifying as your former gender is always an act of abject cruelty as you seem to be suggesting. She has no problem [applying](http://www.dailymail.co.uk/tvshowbiz/article-3221423/Caitlyn-Jenner-applies-golf-club-Bruce-latest-clip-Cait.html) to a country club as Bruce, which strikes me as a bit disingenuous given the stakes you guys suggest are ALWAYS at play.

> [@](#):
>
> The 65-year-old insists on using her old name when applying for new memberships, she revealed in a teaser for I Am Cait.  
> The reality star has revealed she hasn’t quite figured out which locker room she’s going to use next time she tees off.
> 
> While the course at Sherwood Country Club, was closed for renovations, a separate par three course opened, but members must make a separate application to play there.  
> In the latest clip for I Am Cait, her friend Ronda Kamihira is helping her fill in the forms and quizzes her on why she won’t apply using her new name.
> 
> ‘I don’t understand why you’re putting Bruce down, as opposed to Caitlyn,’ she says. ‘Why can’t you go in fresh as Caitlyn?’ ‘My membership is under Bruce,’ an uncomfortable Caitlyn replies. ‘That’s just not going to work.’
> 
> When Kamihira asks if she’s going to ‘wear a hoodie and pretend,’ Caitlyn titters, ‘Probably…and then once I get onto the course I’ll take that off.’
> 
> ‘Are you going to wear a skirt and shorts?’ her friend continues to press, as the former Olympian squirms.  
> ‘No, no, no, no, not right now,’ she brushes it off. ‘I just want to get in and do the thing! So let’s just put Bruce down, it’s fine.’

A women who has no issue using her former male identity when it suits her is, in my opinion, less than completely sincere. No necessarily about the desire to become a woman, but at least in the need to live as a women all the time as a matter of mental and physical well being. I wouldn’t extrapolate her behavior to include every transgender person obviously, but her case highlights why accommodation in my mind cannot just be based on a personal declaration and a doctor’s note.

> [@Kimstu](#):
>
> In any case, the name-change issue is a complete red herring. Of course you should call somebody Caitlyn if they change their name to Caitlyn. If a happily cisgender man named Bruce decided to change his name to Caitlyn just because he liked the name Caitlyn and didn’t see anything wrong with a man using a traditionally feminine name, you should call him Caitlyn too.

You missed the point. The point is that IME, when transgender people transition, they usually switch to a gender typical name in accordance with tradition despite doing something completely nontraditional. It’s not a knock on Caitlyn. I just find it mildly humorous that many people would be more comfortable with accepting someone changing genders than calling a woman Bruce.

> [@Kimstu](#):
>
> I don’t understand what you mean by “multiple genders”. There is indeed plenty of biological evidence that the conventional social two-gender model, in which every individual is either male or female determined solely in accordance with whether they were born with a penis or a vagina, isn’t adequate to the reality of human gender diversity.

That is a wild oversimplification of the “model”. Intersex people and those with ambiguous genitalia have existed for a long time, so you are wildly overstating your case. The only revelation has been the mounting evidence that, to put it succinctly, some biological women/men have typically male/female brains. That’s hardly support for your claim, particularly if you expand it to include the dozens of gender identities there apparently are. The latter conclusion which you have just assumed to be true is that maleness and femaleness colloquially speaking as based on the brain rather than anything else.

> [@Kimstu](#):
>
> I don’t understand what you mean by “universal sense”.

I mean that outside of a closed environment like a high school, almost no scrutiny is made on a situation to situation basis. As I said before, if Caitlyn Jenner, RuPaul, and Jon Hamm walk into a woman’s gym locker room naked, how would some bystander know only one of them potentially belonged? What should some woman who is uncomfortable do in any of those three scenarios? Should we ask transgender people to identify themselves? That hardly seems fair. It also doesn’t seem fair to discourage anyone from asking why someone is in a place they don’t seem to belong. What is that balance in a situation like that?

> [@Kimstu](#):
>
> Of course it’s relevant. Genetic (ethnic) heritage is the biological component of socially constructed racial categories

No, it’s not. They are correlated and generally overlap, but that is far from a given. For example, see this [family](https://thenypost.files.wordpress.com/2015/03/twins1.jpg). Same heritage, almost certainly different perceived racial categories.

> [@Kimstu](#):
>
> Anatomical sex is determined by body parts such as penises and vaginas, which don’t know or care which restroom they use.

Why then are restrooms designed around anatomical sex? Do you see any urinals in women’s bathrooms?

> [@Kimstu](#):
>
> Gender, on the other hand, is determined by people. It makes far more sense (as well as being more respectful and humane) to determine restroom use according to which gender an individual person identifies with than to insist that all the penises have to be in one restroom and all the vaginas in the other.

Even if you grant that accommodation given most bathroom usage is in the relative privacy of a stall, the same is not true for most locker rooms.

> [@YogSosoth](#):
>
> I’m not a lawyer so I will get some areas of the law wrong. That said, I’ll qualify my statements to read that _I believe_ that what the school is doing by singling her out would be fodder for a lawyer because I believe that the case is similar enough to the whole separate-but-equal fiasco that an easy case can be made.

And you would likely be wrong. Did you read the comments of the judge?

> [@YogSosoth](#):
>
> Perhaps. But what is not an assumption is that the school offered to accommodate. Its reasonable to assume that since they did that, they do not outright reject her identifying as a transgendered female. My response is based on that acknowledgement.

Okay, but why are you anchored to complete accommodation as the most desirable or fair outcome when the only side seemingly willing to compromise?

> [@YogSosoth](#):
>
> So too can they accommodate her by allowing her to use the girls’ locker. As you said, sometimes it comes down to money. It will cost the school nothing to allow her to use an existing locker room.And where rights are concerned, comfort and _perceived_ safety mean little.

Hah! You realize you are basically saying, “hey if we have to trample on someone’s right because of money, that makes sense, but real people’s concerns, comfort, and perceived safety mean nothing”. You have a very odd way of valuing money and human emotions.

> [@YogSosoth](#):
>
> White people’s discomfort towards blacks doesn’t mean it wasn’t a violation of their rights to make blacks use different water fountains.

Again, this issue and race have little overlap despite you sadly clinging to it.

> [@YogSosoth](#):
>
> Given that we have examples in the past where such things have been deemed civil rights violations, I’m confident it will be here as well

Your confidence is largely misplaced and based on very little.

> [@YogSosoth](#):
>
> First of all, don’t trust a rag like the Daily Caller.

Nor do I , but the content seems accurate based on other cites I read.

> [@YogSosoth](#):
>
> If Johnston did not meet the standards of transition, then I would be more hesitant to grant him full rights. In the post by the OP, I assume the girl has done enough. Find me a source that says she hasn’t and I’ll change my position.

Actually, I think the prudent thing would be to demand or find proof she has rather than asking for proof of a negative.

> [@YogSosoth](#):
>
> Not wrong. This case hasn’t gone to trial. If and when it does, I predict an easy victory.

Are you dense? The case was rejected. Easy victories don’t generally arise from cases that can’t even make it to trial. Further, read what the judge said:

> [@](#):
>
> Gibson determined “separating students by sex based on biological considerations – which involves the physical differences between men and women – for restroom and locker room use simply does not violate the Equal Protection Clause.”

So basically as I argued before that the basis for segregation is both sex and gender. She continued:

> [@](#):
>
> With regard to the equal-protection clause, Gibson writes that transgender status is not a “suspect class” under equal-protection review, so Pitt can prevail as long as is shows a “rational basis” for its actions. **The university “explained that its policy is based on the need to ensure the privacy of its students to disrobe and shower outside of the presence of members of the opposite sex. This justification has been repeatedly upheld by courts”**

Note the basis for segregation based on SEX has been repeatedly upheld by the courts. Now if you want to argue that will change based on whatever, so be it. However, I think this will be an issue in the vast majority of cases where transgender people have not undergone SRS.

> [@YogSosoth](#):
>
> Are different schools for black and white kids equal?

Historically no. That’s WHY they were outlawed. It’s also why, single sex schools are often legal.

> [@YogSosoth](#):
>
> Do you mean “that have” male brains? I don’t understand.

A minor typo really hindered your understanding of the point?

> [@YogSosoth](#):
>
> And if there are people who have an issue with that, who do you side with?

Depends on the circumstances. That has been my issue all along. Everyone deserves to be heard in a case like this. That doesn’t mean some genuine bigot’s opinion is held in the same regard as a doctor’s or the student’s, but it does mean the process should be a meeting of the minds to determine what the best solution is. Furthermore, that solution needn’t always be a complete acquiescence to the preference of the student appealing for relief in order to be just or humane.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![kaylasdad99](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/kaylasdad99/32/3398_2.png) [@kaylasdad99](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/kaylasdad99)\
**Post date:** [October 17, 2015, 7:08am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/trans-hs-students-access-to-locker-rooms/734540/232 "2015-10-17T07:08:28Z")

</div>

> [@jimbuff314](#):
>
> _::sad face::_ \<—!
> 
> About the reason you give for having to edit your post. I hear you, my hermaphroditic overlord. I got jumped on a couple of days ago by a trigger-happy grammar Nazi when my iPhone auto-corrected “rein” to “reign” and I failed to notice it. Would that I were a Mod, and such jumping-on would have the kindness and humour of **Frank** ’s.

My apologies. Please forgive me. :smack:

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Kimstu](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/k/ecd19e/32.png) [@Kimstu](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Kimstu)\
**Post date:** [October 17, 2015, 10:49am UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/trans-hs-students-access-to-locker-rooms/734540/233 "2015-10-17T10:49:28Z")

</div>

> [@Bricker](#):
>
> So, to be clear: your use of “self-identification,” does not literally begin and end with a declaration by the person, correct?

Correct. I expect, and advocate, that school administrators informed of a transgender student’s request to start using a different restroom take the requisite steps to confirm that the student’s transgender status is being professed both sincerely and accurately. **Una** has already given us a detailed description of the quite rigorous evaluations transgender people generally have to go through before getting a diagnosis of transgender identity, and I have no problem with school administrators requiring some such formal diagnosis before agreeing to change a student’s official gender classification and designated restroom.

Mind you, **I also hold that there are many other social circumstances in which a mere declaration by the individual _is_ all that’s required to establish the individual’s transgender status, _as far as those particular circumstances are concerned_**.

For instance, if (generic) you happen to meet in a casual social or professional setting a person you used to know some time ago, and they are presenting as a different gender from when you previously knew them, it’s your duty as a civilized human being to treat them as the gender they’re currently presenting, simply because they claim to be that gender. It would be extremely rude and intrusive to demand any kind of corroborative evidence or official diagnosis of their transgender status in those circumstances.

> [@brickbacon](#):
>
> The issue is that multiple people KEEP arguing all that should be required is a sincere conviction and perhaps a doctor’s note.

**Una Persson** already explained to you in detail why your trivializing and misleading interpretation of what constitutes a “doctor’s note” in the case of evaluating and diagnosing transgender status is inaccurate. If you keep insisting on that misleading interpretation in preference to the actual facts, there’s not really anything I can do to change your mind.

> [@brickbacon](#):
>
> They are correlated and generally overlap, but that is far from a given.

You apparently misunderstood, again. Just because I noted that genetic heritage is the biological component of socially constructed racial categories doesn’t mean I’m claiming that racial category is always a reliable indicator of genetic heritage. In fact, as you point out, there are many cases where two people with similar genetic heritage will fall into different racial categories.

Analogously, the fact that anatomical/chromosomal sex is the biological component of socially constructed gender categories doesn’t mean that gender category is always a reliable indicator of anatomical/chromosomal sex. In fact, there are numerous cases where two people with the same anatomical/chromosomal sex will fall into different gender categories.

> [@brickbacon](#):
>
> Why then are restrooms designed around anatomical sex? Do you see any urinals in women’s bathrooms?

I don’t see any one-foot-high toilets in (western) women’s bathrooms, either. Does that mean that, say, a woman with extreme dwarfism who has difficulty using standard toilets shouldn’t be considered a woman, or shouldn’t be allowed to use the women’s restroom? How can she claim to be entitled to use a women’s restroom when women’s restroom design is obviously unsuited to her anatomy in a very significant way?

The thing is, see, **standardized restroom facilities are designed and calibrated for the convenience of the _typical_ user, not to serve as some kind of universal criterion that must be applied to _all_ users**.

There are no super-low toilets in women’s bathrooms because the vast majority of women are not super-short, just as there are no urinals in women’s bathrooms because the vast majority of women don’t have penises. **But that unremarkable fact is NOT a valid justification for trying to disqualify the rare women who ARE super-short, or who DO have penises, from using the women’s restroom along with other, more anatomically typical women.**

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Bricker](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/b/977dab/32.png) [@Bricker](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Bricker)\
**Post date:** [October 17, 2015, 12:12pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/trans-hs-students-access-to-locker-rooms/734540/234 "2015-10-17T12:12:59Z")

</div>

> [@brickbacon](#):
>
> I have quoted a supposed expert in this field stating she thinks that is essentially how this should work. So you if you want to have some detailed, explicit framework that is more complex and nuanced, please present it. Otherwise, stop saying such a thing cannot be a sudden pronouncement because that’s exactly the minimum standard that exists if all you require is self-identification. Yes, in the vast majority of cases people will do more to transition, but if it’s not required, then your critique is moot.

The detailed framework was laid out in post 161. My own prior posts explained why **Una** ’s prior concededly overboard statements were indefensible as written (as well as speculating on why she may have done so); she responded by more clearly and defensibly laying out the argument.

You have chosen to continue to focus on those prior statements, which now represent a strawman argument: no one in this thread is claiming that high school locker room use should be conditioned on mere self-identification, with no further corroboration. To the extent that anyone did, they have modified that position.

Do you acknowledge this?

To aid in your recollection, here is post 161:

> [@Una\_Persson](#):
>
> Part of the problem is I’m very close to this issue and I’ve explained some things, like this process, in great detail on this message board multiple times. There’s only so many times I can keep reposting the same information because some folks want to weigh in on a subject without using “Search.”
> 
> If I implied that a simple note from a doctor was all that was needed, that implication was incorrect. What I’ve done was the mistake of assuming that some prior people I debated were referring to the same thing I was thinking of. Meaning that they had done even a Wikipedia-level of research before weighing in on the SDMB. So to avoid further confusion, let me repost some details.
> 
> The actual WPATH-accepted (or recommended) process involves a significant period of counseling, which may include both individual and group sessions, sessions with parents and even friends involved. For our clinics, these sessions explore the roots of the gender identity development in the patient, mitigating factors of social environment, whether the patient has other possibly confusing or compounding psychological issues or problems, and most importantly, a search to discover if their gender identity is persistent, consistent, and insistent. Substance and alcohol abuse are considered, as is the possibility that other legal (prescribed) or illegal drugs might be altering the gender identity of the patient on a temporary basis. Parents, spouses, friends, and other may be interviewed to gain further information. They may also be tested for intersex conditions (like I was) if there is evidence of such.
> 
> Of the people who come into the office I work with, I was told that about 1 in 4 have some other compounding factor which renders a diagnosis of transgender impossible. Another 1 in 4 are diagnosed as transgender, but not to the degree where it’s recommended that they actually start a transition process (meaning, they don’t get a letter). Some unknown but small number of transgender persons receive their letter but choose not to transition at that time, due mostly to second thoughts about becoming unemployed and possibly homeless (like my friend I spoke with last night, who had her letter for 6 years before coming out).
> 
> Of those patients remaining, there is also the decision that a psychologist must make, which is “will the patient prosper at the current time with transition, or will it be a net negative? Are they strong enough to survive this, emotionally? Do they have any support network at all?”
> 
> I’m not a licensed psychologist. I’ve been through the process and I’m an unpaid adjunct for several licensed psychologists. I participate in these sessions (more patients than I can remember), with the prior approval of the patient, to assist in the assessments and to provide a sounding board for them. Outside of the office visits I mentor them, meet with and help their families and friends and peers, and work with them in social settings, and report back to the psychologists how the patient is handling certain social challenges and barriers, and how their attitude towards their gender identity and expression is being upheld. Again, this is done with the patient’s permission and knowledge.
> 
> This process can take as little as a couple of months, to years.
> 
> At the end of it all there is a letter, from the psychologist, stating the gender identity of the patient and requesting that all possible accommodation be made for them. It’s often brief, maybe 2 paragraphs plus an intro and closing. This is what I refer to as the “doctor’s note.” There will also be a letter to a physician talking about the patient and recommending hormone therapy, but that is (normally) sent directly to the physician to avoid the possibility of forgery.
> 
> If I gave the impression that one could just go to a doctor, they’d check them over, and write out a note, that impression I gave is incorrect. It was based on my summarizing a process which I’ve already posted about many times before.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Irishman](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/i/b487fb/32.png) [@Irishman](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Irishman)\
**Post date:** [October 17, 2015, 12:27pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/trans-hs-students-access-to-locker-rooms/734540/235 "2015-10-17T12:27:15Z")

</div>

> [@SpoilerVirgin](#):
>
> I can’t speak to the boys’ locker room, but why in the world would you think that girls with small chests or who are overweight are safe from humiliation in a room full of teenage girls?

That was not stated. What was stated is that the humiliation would likely be worse if they were exposed in front of boys and subject to the same harassment.

> [@](#):
>
> You do realize that you’re talking here about a boy being humiliated because the person he’s sweet on - _who is a transgender boy_ - sees him naked. How is this different from the gay boy in the locker room who is seen by another boy he likes?

No, this specific statement was about the hypothetical case of unisex bathrooms.

> [@Una\_Persson](#):
>
> There’s also the possibility that she was more afraid of being forced to use the boy’s lockers than any taunting or abuse she might receive from the other girls.

Did you read the article? She was offered the use of private restroom and showers. She wants to change with the other girls on her team, not alone. That’s a different issue. Doesn’t make it right or wrong, just a different issue.

> [@Una\_Persson](#):
>
> Another issue is “what is the greater good?” Here is where reasonable people will also disagree. Forcing a transgender girl to change in the locker room and use the boy’s bathrooms will often be devastating for her. It was for me, and it is for most (not all) of the kids I work with or talk to. Here’s something else - when I undressed in front of boys for gym, I felt like I was a girl being forced to expose myself to boys, a large, noisy, close group of them. The feeling was horrible. I almost ran away from home several times to avoid it, and even self-harmed to get excuses to miss gym.
> 
> So for the few girls who might be uncomfortable, within a large group of their peers to shield them partially, is accommodating their discomfort the better option than sending the transgirl to the boys?

Isn’t this a false dichotomy? You are only considering the girl change with boys because she has a penis or with girls. But what about the option of her changing in the separately provided teacher’s lounge showers? Not ideal, but it is a third option. And if your argument is “the greater good”, then it serves the greater good by protecting this girl from all kinds of embarrassment by not looking like a boy or a girl. And it protects the other girls from being around a penis. (Because apparently penises are scary. I know I don’t want to be around any others.)

> [@Bricker](#):
>
> Shodan,
> 
> You ever see the algebra puzzle that “proves” 1=2 ?
> 
> [snip]
> 
> In your exegesis above, the “divide by zero” step is “my gender is ‘person with a penis who should use the girls’ locker room.'” That’s not really an option on the table, and it’s the result of the fallacy of equivocation you offered when you said, “Everyone can decide for him/her/it/themselves what his/her/its/their gender is.”
> 
> Taken one way, yes, that’s a true statement. But this framework is limited, not infinite. It supports a person whose body does not match his perception of what he is; it does not allow me to be a “person with a penis who doesn’t have to pay sales tax,” any more than it allows me to be a “person with a penis who should use the girls’ locker room.”
> 
> There may well be some legitimate parade of horribles associated with permitting trans girls from using the girls’ locker room in high school. I agree, for example, that we cannot necessarily order the crowd of cis girls who are uncomfortable with the prospect to simply shut up and deal with it. But your argument is off the rails. It’s unfair. Cut it out, please, and address the points your opponents are making.
> 
> This is obviously nothing more than a request.

Excellent post.

> [@Shodan](#):
>
> In what way is the transgender student in the OP not claiming a gender of “person with a penis who should be allowed to use the girls’ locker room”? What, specifically, is it about that student’s claim that makes it legitimate, but not anyone else’s?

Is the other person claiming to be a girl, or a boy?

> [@brickbacon](#):
>
> Not really. Let’s unpack this a bit. Why is a man whose skin changes from what would typically considered Black to what would typically be considered White via a skin disease or something else NOT White? Why isn’t this person considered White if he looks White and has White skin? Now, I would imagine you would argue something like skin pigment is not the sole basis of racial categorization.

Yes. While the racial terms are “White” and “Black”, skin pigmentation is only part of the attribution that determines the race.

> [@](#):
>
> I would counter by arguing many people don’t think self-declared gender identity is the sole basis for deciding who is male or female, or more clearly, who should be able to use which locker room. That doesn’t mean self-declared gender identity isn’t real or isn’t valid; it just means it isn’t the ONLY concern in every circumstance.

Agreed, self determined gender identity may not be the only basis for a fair social decision. But it takes more than just saying so to be convincing.  
At a bare minimum. Doctor’s diagnosis, school administrative consultation, and the handful of other things typically required to make a legal transition in the eyes of the state.  
[/QUOTE]

> [@Kimstu](#):
>
> Logically, that’s not really a counterargument to the previous point; it’s more of a tangent. But you are correct that there are indeed many people who think that gender self-identification should not be the sole basis for deciding who should use which locker room.
> 
> [snip]
> 
> So the fact that many people nowadays think that genital anatomy as well as gender self-identification should be included in the basis for deciding who should use which locker room doesn’t automatically mean that their opinions should be considered valid as far as the rights of locker-room users are concerned.

Right, but it takes more than just saying so to be convincing.

> [@](#):
>
> But the position I’m arguing for here is that **self-declared gender identity _is_ the only legitimate concern in the particular circumstance of deciding who’s entitled to use what restroom or locker room.**

Why? That is your position, but if you’re trying to convince others to accept it, you have to actually give arguments, not just state your position.

> [@](#):
>
> Because merely having white skin doesn’t automatically mean that he’s racially white. Just as having a penis doesn’t automatically mean that somebody has a male gender identity or should be automatically considered male.

Okay, but that doesn’t address the argument that part of the reason for segregated bathrooms and changing rooms is sex organ determined.

> [@Kimstu](#):
>
> Likewise, as I already said, there are indeed some circumstances where transgender people need to take into account their biological sex/anatomy as well as their personal gender self-identification. But when it comes to everyday social interactions including restroom use, **personal gender self-identification is all we need to consider**.

Why? Your stating it doesn’t make it true by fiat.

> [@](#):
>
> But whether you like it or not, this issue **is** fundamentally based on the fact that “things change”. Specifically, nowadays we understand more about the science of gender identity, its biological basis in brain structure as well as genital anatomy, and its social construction, than we did back when the two-gender model of human society was originally developed. (And it’s worth pointing out that the two-gender model has not been universal even in all pre-modern societies: consider, e.g., the acknowledgement of “third sex” people in traditional South Asian cultures.)
> 
> Just because it’s admittedly difficult for a lot of people to wrap their heads around this new fuller understanding of gender identity doesn’t mean that we should throw away the things we’ve learned to avoid offending or shocking their traditional two-gender preconceptions.

Now you’re getting somewhere.

> [@](#):
>
> And my answer is, “sure, if she wanted to mention it”. But it’s not something she was in any way obligated to mention if she didn’t want to. I do think that if she’s explicitly asked about it, she’s ethically obligated either to tell the truth or just refuse to answer the question, but it’s not her responsibility to “warn” potential dates about it in advance.
> 
> The medico-social fact is that there are some women who have penises and some men who have vaginas (and there are some people, women or men or nonbinary, who have some genital configuration not quite corresponding to either category). That’s just one of the things about men and women that people who go on dating sites should be aware of.

Not bringing it up before the initial meeting is fine, but I sure hope it’s something that comes up before clothing comes off.

> [@](#):
>
> Once again, what I’m saying is this: **Gender classification criteria, like racial classification criteria, are dependent on the circumstances in which the classification is happening. And for the particular circumstance of deciding who gets to use what restroom, we don’t need, and shouldn’t impose, any criteria other than individual gender self-identification.**

This is definitely a case where our social structures and culture are not in synch with the growing modern understanding of sexual identity and gender. Perhaps it is time reevaluate as a society what we are trying to accomplish by gender segregating our bathrooms and changing facilities. Unfortunately, it seems we are going about this in a haphazard drunken stumble rather than a reasoned consideration of the issues. But that’s par for the course of being human, I guess.

> [@brickbacon](#):
>
> It’s not silly. I assure you it will happen just as people have pretended to be disabled to win competitions. It will happen even sooner if the only prerequisite is having a doctor’s note as Una suggested.

Una has already posted in this thread a clarification of her remark about what she means by a “doctor’s note”. Your continuing to represent her statement in this manner is flat out wrong, and it appears deliberately so.

> [@](#):
>
> No, that is EXACTLY what you are doing re gender. Oh the irony. You expect every claim to be treated as worthy of full scale accommodation and respect. Your side expects people to address Caitlyn Jenner as Caitlyn when she herself feels perfectly fine applying to country clubs as Bruce.

So Caitlyn has complicated identity issues. Why is that an indictment of people arguing for transgendered rights?

> [@](#):
>
> That’s even ignoring the funny fact that all of this new thinking is supposed to erase gender stereotypes, yet transgender people still feel the need to take gender stereotypical names when they transition. Why can’t we call female Bruce Jenner Bruce Jenner?

I’m no expert, but I imagine it comes with carving out a new identity that they are this new person with a new gender. It’s not just so others will think of them as changed, but to acknowledge the change to themselves, finding their new identity and embracing it.

Una has also written that there is a strong urge to write off and distance themselves from their past, to be taken as fully woman or fully man, which is hard when everyone sees them as the gender they were. Even after operation and hormones, there’s a stigma to being trans that they wish to distance themselves from.

> [@](#):
>
> Please cite some evidence that the above is true in any universal sense?

Una has already provided such in this thread.

> [@brickbacon](#):
>
> I have quoted a supposed expert in this field stating she thinks that is essentially how this should work.

False. Una has clarified her position in this thread. Your continued statement to this effect is complete misrepresentation of Una’s position. It’s hard to take you seriously when you continue to repeat this in the face of Una’s posts [161](http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showpost.php?p=18776648&postcount=161) and [162](http://boards.straightdope.com/sdmb/showpost.php?p=18776667&postcount=162).

> [@](#):
>
> I mean that outside of a closed environment like a high school, almost no scrutiny is made on a situation to situation basis. As I said before, if Caitlyn Jenner, RuPaul, and Jon Hamm walk into a woman’s gym locker room naked, how would some bystander know only one of them potentially belonged? What should some woman who is uncomfortable do in any of those three scenarios? Should we ask transgender people to identify themselves? That hardly seems fair. It also doesn’t seem fair to discourage anyone from asking why someone is in a place they don’t seem to belong. What is that balance in a situation like that?

This is not just hypothetical. Houston is currently debating an [equal rights ordinance](http://ballotpedia.org/City_of_Houston_Anti-Discrimination_HERO_Veto_Referendum,_Proposition_1_(November_2015)) that is currently on the November ballot. One strong item for opponents of the equal rights ordinance is the fear this ordinance will allow sexual predators to dress up as women to go into restrooms. [Similar ordinances in Austin, Dallas, and El Paso have provided no such upturn in sexual predators in restrooms.](http://news.google.com/news/url?sa=t&fd=R&ct2=us&usg=AFQjCNGpiVpAXjCHZopD4NcljVErLiI-Ug&clid=c3a7d30bb8a4878e06b80cf16b898331&cid=52778970411051&ei=iDEiVqD9NISJ3AGaqIyoCg&url=http://mediamatters.org/research/2015/10/15/texas-experts-debunk-the-transgender-bathroom-p/206178)

And [12 more states](http://equalitymatters.org/factcheck/201403200001) with the same response, there is no uptake in sexual predators or rape from equal rights ordinances that protect gender identity.

> [@](#):
>
> Actually, I think the prudent thing would be to demand or find proof she has rather than asking for proof of a negative.

The school has already acknowledged her status by letting her participate on female athletic teams. That is part of the justification for use of the female locker rooms - so she will be with her teammates, who already accept her as a female since she participates in athletics with them.

> [@](#):
>
> Are you dense? The case was rejected.

The two of you are discussing different cases. You are discussing the one that went to trial, **YogSosoth** is talking about the case from the OP.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Kimstu](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/k/ecd19e/32.png) [@Kimstu](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Kimstu)\
**Post date:** [October 17, 2015, 1:01pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/trans-hs-students-access-to-locker-rooms/734540/236 "2015-10-17T13:01:14Z")

</div>

> [@Irishman](#):
>
> Not bringing it up before the initial meeting is fine, but I sure hope it’s something that comes up before clothing comes off.

I think it’s the responsibility of any man who doesn’t want to be intimate with a transwoman to make his preference clear at some point “before clothing comes off”. It’s not a transwoman’s responsibility to volunteer information about her transgender status unasked.

I do agree, though, that if a transgender woman is dating a guy who makes it clear that he doesn’t want to be intimate with a transgender woman, she should immediately dump the dude, rather than hiding or denying her transgender status in the hope that he’ll change his mind. He almost certainly won’t, and she deserves better than a guy who’s only dating her because he believes something about her that isn’t true.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Una\_Persson](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/una_persson/32/346_2.png) [@Una\_Persson](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Una_Persson)\
**Post date:** [October 17, 2015, 1:37pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/trans-hs-students-access-to-locker-rooms/734540/237 "2015-10-17T13:37:27Z")

</div>

> [@Irishman](#):
>
> Did you read the article? She was offered the use of private restroom and showers. She wants to change with the other girls on her team, not alone. That’s a different issue. Doesn’t make it right or wrong, just a different issue.

…

> [@](#):
>
> Isn’t this a false dichotomy? You are only considering the girl change with boys because she has a penis or with girls. But what about the option of her changing in the separately provided teacher’s lounge showers? Not ideal, but it is a third option. And if your argument is “the greater good”, then it serves the greater good by protecting this girl from all kinds of embarrassment by not looking like a boy or a girl. And it protects the other girls from being around a penis. (Because apparently penises are scary. I know I don’t want to be around any others.)

I guess I didn’t really address that in my prior reply because I didn’t really consider it a great alternative. One of the goals of transition among youth is to try to integrate them (I call it “mainstream” them) into peer groups of their gender. And having been in the position to be forced to use a “separate but equal” bathroom on a couple of occasions, it felt…really not very good.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Una\_Persson](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/una_persson/32/346_2.png) [@Una\_Persson](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Una_Persson)\
**Post date:** [October 17, 2015, 1:53pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/trans-hs-students-access-to-locker-rooms/734540/238 "2015-10-17T13:53:04Z")

</div>

> [@Kimstu](#):
>
> I think it’s the responsibility of any man who doesn’t want to be intimate with a transwoman to make his preference clear at some point “before clothing comes off”. It’s not a transwoman’s responsibility to volunteer information about her transgender status unasked.
> 
> I do agree, though, that if a transgender woman is dating a guy who makes it clear that he doesn’t want to be intimate with a transgender woman, she should immediately dump the dude, rather than hiding or denying her transgender status in the hope that he’ll change his mind. He almost certainly won’t, and she deserves better than a guy who’s only dating her because he believes something about her that isn’t true.

Transgender dating is a huge can of worms. I’ve posted about it before, but to summarize some of the issues and my opinion…in my opinion, in perfect Una Land, every transgender woman would voluntarily mention it on the first date to any cisgender person who they do not already know is trans-accepting.

This opinion of mine is at odds with many in my community, but it is driven solely by the fact of violence. I’ve seen the results, up close and personal, of what cisgender men can do to a transgender woman when they find out the girl they were dating wasn’t raised a girl - or worse, hasn’t undergone full transition. A significant number of transgender murders are the result of a revelation of transgender after dating has been in progress.

I’ve posted before about the despair which drives some in my community - transgirls who desperately need someone to love and someone to love them, who are willing to take the risk and hide their past in the hopes that if they can get their proverbial foot in the door, then they could overcome any bigotry in the man. IME, that just isn’t the way it works out.

But it’s getting better. I cannot pin down why, but I suspect that just in the last 5 years there seems to have been a much greater “pool” of cisgender straight men and women who are willing to date a transgender person with full knowledge of their history. It’s just my opinion and not a scientific poll, but I do think it is slowly getting better.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Lamia](https://avatars.discourse-cdn.com/v4/letter/l/8e7dd6/32.png) [@Lamia](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Lamia)\
**Post date:** [October 17, 2015, 2:29pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/trans-hs-students-access-to-locker-rooms/734540/239 "2015-10-17T14:29:19Z")

</div>

> [@brickbacon](#):
>
> Why then are restrooms designed around anatomical sex? Do you see any urinals in women’s bathrooms?

I have. They’re not common (at least not in the US), but I used to work in a building that had “[female urinals](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Female_urination_device#Female_urinals)” in one of the women’s bathrooms.

---

<div class="post-metadata">

**Author:** ![Una\_Persson](https://sea3.discourse-cdn.com/straightdope/user_avatar/boards.straightdope.com/una_persson/32/346_2.png) [@Una\_Persson](https://boards.straightdope.com/u/Una_Persson)\
**Post date:** [October 17, 2015, 2:38pm UTC](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/trans-hs-students-access-to-locker-rooms/734540/240 "2015-10-17T14:38:06Z")

</div>

> [@Irishman](#):
>
> > [@](#):
> >
> > That’s even ignoring the funny fact that all of this new thinking is supposed to erase gender stereotypes, yet transgender people still feel the need to take gender stereotypical names when they transition. Why can’t we call female Bruce Jenner Bruce Jenner?
> 
> I’m no expert, but I imagine it comes with carving out a new identity that they are this new person with a new gender. It’s not just so others will think of them as changed, but to acknowledge the change to themselves, finding their new identity and embracing it.
> 
> Una has also written that there is a strong urge to write off and distance themselves from their past, to be taken as fully woman or fully man, which is hard when everyone sees them as the gender they were. Even after operation and hormones, there’s a stigma to being trans that they wish to distance themselves from.

Yeah, I’m a little confused by his strategy in this thread. Seemingly positing acceptance and sympathy while at the same time not so much.

And yes, you have it correct. There is a very strong urge to move past the, well, past, which was filled with pain and angst, and start over. And this doesn’t just stay with the individual - several times I’ve been taken aside by well-meaning transgender people who “advise” me that I should stop being so open about being a transsexual woman.

The new girl I met last night wouldn’t even tell me her boy name (sometimes referred to in the community as “slave name,” a term I do not condone). Not even to me, she was so ashamed of even admitting she was anything other than a girl. I had to drag it out of her because I’m trying to find a job for her and I needed to see her resume (job placement is another one of my side jobs for my community, which is another reason I sleep about 4 hours a night…), but she didn’t make it easy. She was willing to lie on her resume and risk being turned down by pretty much any employer, rather than write that offensive boy name. I leveled with her, transperson to transperson, and convinced her that it was OK, it’s just temporary, and I was there for her. And when she gave me her boy name, she cried because it was so painful. ☹

[Previous page](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/trans-hs-students-access-to-locker-rooms/734540.md?page=11)

[Next page](https://boards.straightdope.com/t/trans-hs-students-access-to-locker-rooms/734540.md?page=13)
