The mention of Shelley Winters reminded me of another villain in a Shelley Winters movie: the Reverend Harry Powell in The Night of the Hunter. And, huh, I didn’t realize he was based on a real person, Harry Powers, who murdered two widows and three children and was hanged for it.
Harry Powell/Robert Mitchum is terrifying in the film, but I can never help laughing at the moment when he’s watching a burlesque act and glowering at the brazen hussy on stage, and he flicks open his switchblade through his pocket.
And then of course: “There are too many of them. Can’t kill the world.”
I agree that she’s utterly without concience rather than actively sadistic, but I think much of her “greater good” talk (when she finally comes clean to Claudius near the end of her life) was self-serving justification - what she really wanted was not the greater good, but to ensure that her line takes the throne. She has zero respect or liking for Tiberius, but he is her child, so she manuvers and murders to ensure he takes the throne.
Mr. Ripley from The Talented Mr. Ripley.
Murdstone and his sister from David Copperfield. I found them much more chilling and repellant than Uriah Heep, who was merely a hypocrite and a thief.
Kirk Douglas said in an interview that when he was playing McMurphy on Broadway he actually wanted his character to rape her when he attacks her toward the end, and for Ratched to enjoy it. I can only imagine the (completely justifiable) outcry this would have brought about, but- per Kirk- “it felt right”. He believed there was sexual chemistry between the two.
Speaking of the already mentioned Max Cady from Cape Fear, I saw the remake first and the original years later and couldn’t believe how much scarier Mitchum was than DeNiro. This with Night of the Hunter cements him as one of the great villain players of all time.
:dubious: Hate-fucking the most sinister character in all of fiction history might ‘feel right’ but it would have destroyed her mystique of terror.
In that setting, in a mental ward, she has complete power and authority, she knows it and uses it ruthlessly. THAT is why she terrifying. Your life and mental cognition are perpetually at the sadistic whim of a control freak with unlimited power.
That she exerts her power with impunity over those that can leave at any time makes it even more perverse.
I remembered another one - not as genocidal as most of these, but Police Chief Dudley Smith from LA Confidential was PF evil. In a movie full of “bad guy” actors, James Cromwell stood out as a bad guy. I can’t believe the same actor who played Farmer Hoggett in Babe could also play Chief Dudley. Dudley’s eyes were COLD.
Rolo Thomassi
I’m a bit surprised no one’s mentioned Dolores Umbridge from Harry Potter. Voldemort was a pretty fucked-up individual, but you could see the factors that led to his madness. Umbridge was just a snake, pure and simple. There’s no indication that she was just following orders–someone (I think it was on TVTropes, but I can’t remember) suggested that she could produce a decent patronus in the Ministry courtroom at the muggle-born trials because THAT was something she derived happiness from. She was exactly where she wanted to be. A truly chilling thought.
Voldemort was someone I loved to hate. But Umbridge? I just hated her.