Turn off the Internet

IMO, shutting down the internet (for, let’s say, 95% of the population) is not a technical challenge, but a political/legal one – which fast becomes irrelevant when the country is ruled by a dictatorship which would presumably be capable of enforcing its will with efficient deadly force (it did take over the US, after all).

Talking about shutting down DNS servers is missing the point; there are a variety of methods of stopping internet access to the masses, and most of them depend on the unfortunate fact that today’s Internet is not the highly-redundant web of peer-to-peer interconnections that the military envisioned. (See Stathtol’s post)

The Internet, as it is known to most Americans today, is primarily run by large advertising, telecom, and electronics companies: Google, Verizon, AT&T, Comcast, the various backbone providers, Apple, Microsoft, etc. Any one of these giant, centralized corporations is easy pickings for a dictatorship; a few beheadings later, you can bet that the rest will fall in line. Whether you do it by switching off servers or power plants, cutting trunk lines, destroying satellites, software updates that cripple equipment, etc. is of little consequence, because sooner or later, without popular armed resistance, you will disable enough equipment simply because there’s nobody powerful enough to stop you.

The point is that no matter how resilient the equipment may or may not be, their flesh-and-blood operators are infinitely more vulnerable. Were the OP’s question “How resilient is the Internet against non-physical cyber attacks (only)”, the situation would be vastly different. Under the proposed dictatorship scenario, little of that matters: How many people would really risk execution/torture/labor camp/etc. for daring to implement technical workarounds even when they’re possible?

The Chinese firewall is a different beast altogether because they must leave parts of the Internet alive while filtering other parts, which is a much, much harder challenge than blocking it altogether.

If you had control of the military you wouldn’t need to execute or torture anyone to shut it all down…you’d need to basically seize a dozen or so key sites to start off with and then work your way down, depending on how disconnected you wanted things to be. If you were going for zero connectivity for everyone in the US to even local, dis-contiguous networks then that would take some time, but if you just wanted to shut off ‘internet’ connectivity outside the US it would be fairly simple to do. I could probably do it pretty much off the top of my head and just from memory, if I had legions of furry minions to do my bidding…and if I didn’t care about the massive amount of financial (and other) havoc I’d be wreaking by doing it.

-XT

(Missed edit)

And as for the idea that regional networks could continue to exist, that’s technically true, but ultimately of little practical value. Content and interconnectivity are what make the Internet valuable, and independent regional networks will have much less of both.

At best, you’d get a few semi-interconnected darknets floating around the country powered by off-grid generators and communicating through secret lines, but that’s not the Internet as you and I know it today; that’s a glorified LAN party run by hairy, paranoid geeks. Potentially useful for an underground resistance movement, but mostly useless for the masses because trying to get access to one would firstly be difficult without the right social connections, and secondly, would presumably be an illegal (and therefore potentially lethal) activity in and of itself. And even if you get on, there will be a much smaller amount of content: maybe a few pre-dictatorship mirrors, a few slow connections to the rest of the global Internet, a lot of self-published trash, and porn. But there won’t be uncontrolled American publishers and distributors of content anymore, and any information originating from within the country will be highly suspicious. And, again, without a pool of useful, trustworthy content, why bother trying to get on at all?