Shows that missed their moment (shows that came out too early or too late to hit the mark)
Cafe Americain
In 1992, Valerie Bertinelli is still riding fame from One Day at a Time, and plays a divorced American woman who reinvents herself by moving to Paris and getting a job in a cafe. It’s Obviously inspired by the recent sleeper hit Shirley Valentine. It throws caution to the wind, spoofing international characters before there were so many news channels and cable news feeds for people to watch, and uses subtitles to have people authentically speaking French sometimes, before opened-caption YouTube has conditioned people to accept that. Nearly every critic who praises the acting and writing criticizes the subtitles. This is also back when nearly anything not from the US appears on PBS, and that is a strike against it, I think. I liked it, though.
Aired 18 eps. While reception was mixed, people seemed to be happy to see Bertinelli again.
Oh, as the OP, my proposal is that when adding to the list, a good explanation is given for each show’s inclusion, but the explanations are cut from list reproductions, so that each list has only the explanation of the bottom item.
Shows that missed their moment (shows that came out too early or too late to hit the mark)
Cafe Americain
Police Squad!
Created by the writer-director team that made Airplane!, this was a stone-faced parody that threw absolutely everything at the wall: sight gags, puns, wordplay, absurdism, non sequiturs, you name it. You couldn’t look away from the screen for more than a few seconds without missing a gag, and the fact that you had to pay such close attention was thought to be the chief reason it didn’t catch on, getting canceled after just six episodes. (That and the fact there was no laugh track, unheard of for any comedy other than MASH in 1982, though a laugh track would have completely ruined it.) Attention spans haven’t exactly gotten longer since then, but it’s easy to see a show like this becoming a hit today on a streamer like Hulu and getting a much longer run than it originally got.