[QUOTE=Chronos]
I’m amazed it’s taken so long for anyone to mention it, but you absolutely must have Holst’s “Mars”. Yeah, it’s all instrumental, but at the same time, there’s no doubt at all what it’s about.
[/QUOTE]
If you like “And the Band Played Waltzing Matilda” and similar somber songs, check out “Bomber’s Moon” and “Accrington Pals” by Mike Harding, and for a view from the home front, “Mothers, Daughters, Wives” by Judy Small, recorded by The Corries (there are other recordings, The Corries is the one I have).
Irish and Scottish traditional music are loaded with war songs, from rousing (“The Haughs of Cromdale”) to somber (“The Flowers of the Forest”). “The Rising of the Moon” and “Hey Johnnie Cope” have already been mentioned. There are entire album collections of Irish rebel songs. “The Minstrel Boy”, “The Foggy Dew” and “Scots Wha Hae” are just a few of the ones worth checking out.
Plenty of punk era songs. Two that I think transcend the genre:
War - DOA (Edwin Starr cover). Best cover made of this song by far and only version that I prefer over the original.
No Fucking War - The Dicks. Played live outside the DNC in San Francisco in 1984
lessee, just some off the cuff punk songs. Pretty much every recorded punk group had an appropriate song:
let’s have a war - Fear
Holiday in Cambodia - Dead Kennedy’s
Live fast die you - Circle Jerks
1945 -
Nagasaki Nightmare - Crass
Vietnam - Minutemen
[QUOTE=woodstockbirdybird]
And let’s not forget (or maybe we should) “The War Song” - Culture Club
[/QUOTE]
I wish I could, but it’s been running through my head ever since reading the thread title!
Actually, it’s really a better song than it sounds at first listen.
A couple other suggestions off the top of my head: The Kinks’ “Some Mother’s Son”
Sepultura - War Manowar - Call to Arms Manowar - Hail and Kill Crash Worship - Procession Crash Worship - You Light Up My Life
The most interesting is probably Crash Worship’s two. They are almost entirely instrumental, but sound essentially like if you were to take a war scene and then time up all the screams, gun shots, and whatnot to create a rhythm.
Well, as an Unreconstructed Yankee there’s the one I want to sing when the Confederate re-enactors go by in parades, “Marching Through Georgia” by anybody.
On the other hand, Country Joe also recorded an LP (can’t find it on CD) of Robert W Service’s poems written while he was an ambulance driver in WWI. “The Cremation of Sam McGee” they ain’t.
I tell you what, any list that includes the Gettysburg soundtrack, The Dead Kennedys, and Oingo Boingo is a good list. For some reason I forgot about Rage Against the Machine, so thanks for the reminder. Same for Toby Keith. ryobserver, some good suggestions as well. sage rat, I’m going to check out those Crash Worship songs.
I don’t care what everyone else says, Dopers are fine upstanding citizens with good musical taste.
Most of The Final Cut album by Pink Floyd and, I know it has been mentioned already but, When the Tigers Broke Free should be included in any war compilation.