Were John Brown or Charles Guiteau crazy?

I’m trying to sort this mess out. It has gone way off course from what I can see. It has gotten too personal. Basically little to salvage as a GD thread.

When a GD thread goes from debating John Brown to talking about Jewish & Moslem holidays, the thread is pretty broken. As the OP is a big part of this, closure seems best.

@slicedalone, please PM me if you want this reopened in the Pit. Otherwise I’m going to leave this closed.


To all, especially slicedalone, avoid insulting others outside the Pit. Attack the post and not the poster.