Well there’s the end to a lot of pleasant speculation. I’m afraid everyone who said “apple family” will have to poke you with a stick to quell the disappointment 
How large a stick? We had better settle that right away.
Nope, nothing exotic on Long Island except the inhabitants.
So. . . who else has ordered a framed print of this for $46.99?
Well, it’s a pome, anyway. Which the sepals on the end indicated.
Does it taste like apple? Is the flesh woody? (Woody flesh is common to pears and crabapples but not domestic apples.) Could it be a quince?
I did take a picture of a leaf but once I opened it up there was no doubt it was some kind of apple. A translucent-skinned, grape tomato-shaped apple. I didn’t taste it but is sure smelled pretty apple-y.
Well, those do look like apple leaves.