No, only the consensus of this thread that seems to have settled on that, which I politely disagree with.
(Just to clarify, in case necessary, the thing I was doubting was Max the Immortal’s claim that “Standard American” refers to so-called Mid-Atlantic English, rather than referring to what is known as General American. I think everyone understood this, but just making sure.)
Right. I have the same doubt. But since your question was in reply to my post, I thought you were doubting my doubt.
Ah. I suspected that may have led to misinterpretation. Well, then, it was good of me to clarify.
Right you are. Let’s keep this sparkling back and forth going indefinitely, shall we? I’m typing in MidAtlantic, old sock.
Jolly well, old bean. I’m game. Care for a cup of tea?
Well, I would first like to say that I don’t mean to criticise Jane Leeves’ performance in Frasier. I think she’s very good in it, and it is one my favourite TV shows.
But her accent, the first time you watch the show as a Brit you’re thinking “where the hell is she supposed to be from”? She adopts this sort of stereotypical “ecky thump” northern accent that alamagates everything you’ve heard in bad British sitcoms. It sounds more Leeds than Manchester to me, but not a very convincing Leeds either. Manchester has a distinctive accent, nothing like Daphne’s. She could have tried a Lancashire accent (like another British actor Jane Horrocks, if you’ve heard her natural accent), because Manchester is historically part of Lancashire and you do hear the Lancashire accent there.
Interesting, thanks!
Not to toot my own horn, here, but I think I’ve done a pretty convincing job of proving your “doubt” already.
Actually, to clarify; your cites support my contention, that the OP-referred accent is called Mid Atlantic, *not *Standard; that Standard refers to the “CNN” accent. This is what I’ve been saying, and this is what your cites back up.
I must concede that I cannot prove my assertions by SDMB standards.
If you’re willing to take my word on it, bear in mind that David Smukler, author of Speaking North American Naturally and prolific dialect coach, as well as his colleagues at Canada’s National Voice Intensive, all refer to the accent in question as Standard American.
The comprehensive Accents: A Manual for Actors by Robert Blumenfeld refers to CNN English as General American, not Standard.
The term Mid-Atlantic is not specific to the constructed theatre dialect. For example, the Wikipedia article on English-language dialects lists the Tidewater accent as a mid-atlantic accent, and is quite different from the dialect we are discussing.
Unless the rumors about Kelsey Grammer being a doper are true, I don’t think we’ll be able to find more specific information.
I was hoping it would be a link to that video.
Dialect coaches hold no authority compared to linguists, who butter their bread by researching languages and dialects, and who have shown repeatedly that the rest of the civilized world reserves the name “Standard American” for the dialect that is actually Standard in America.
General American is another accepted term for the same thing, yes.
I’m not sure how that’s particularly relevant.
I’m certainly willing to accept that within the theatre in-group, Standard American is the accepted name for the constructed stage dialect. But using that term to refer to that dialect can only lead to confusion in any other context or with any other group of people, the way I see it. Outside of the theatre context–where it is the standard American dialect–the fact that Standard American English means CNN English (an excellent coinage, thank you) is as fundamental to linguistics as 2+2=4 is to calculus. Part of me finds it irritating that theatre folks are using such a confusing term, but (1) another part of me must admit that conflicts like these are part of what makes English such a colorful and expressive language and (2) a lot of the theatre people probably hate that I use the British spelling, and they can sod off.
My first paragraph in that last post was a little dickish. Sorry, I’m a little snippy after being disappointed by my navel this morning.
Just read my last paragraph, then. That’s the trick.