Okay, I’ve just scanned the thread. Sorry if I’m repeating.
I have a few Zippo lighters around. My favourite one is the plain (not brushed) finished silver one.
One complaint was that Zippos don’t ‘light every time’. Actually, it was Ronson whose slogan was that it lights ‘First time, Every time.’ (I’ve heard the Germans in WWII called the M-4 Sherman ‘Ronson’.)
The flame ‘lasts too long’? Uh… You could close the cover. That’s what it’s for.
They go out in a light wind? I’ve never had that problem with mine. I find my Zippo is much better at lighting in windy conditions than a disposable Bic.
Cigars should be lit with a wooden match.
I’ve lit pipes with my Zippo, and had no trouble. The flame of a Bic will rise just as a Zippo’s will. It’s in the nature of flames.
I don’t know how many Zippos I have. One is in a frame with my dad’s Navy ribbons, shoulder boards, 7th Fleet patch, etc. It was his, and has the 7th Fleet shield on it. Another is from a ship he was on – the USS Merrick, I think – and has an engraving of the ship. Another of dad’s Zippos has an aligator on it, from the logo of another ship.
As for my own, I have the plain silver one I got in the '80s. After I lost it, I got one with a brushed finished. I also got a black one. Then I found the first one. I have a grey one with a cartoon image on it that Rilchiam alerted me to and that I thought was neat. That’s the only one I haven’t lit.
I also have a pseudo-Zippo that a friend gave to me. Out of all of the lighters, this is the one that would not light except right after it was filled.
And yes, I’ve overfilled a Zippo and had it leak on my thigh. It was the time a guy jumped off a bridge over the Sepulveda Pass and backed up traffic for hours. I decided to turn around and RON at a friend’s place. So, I’ve burned my thigh with the fluid once. Once.