[QUOTE=msmith537]
I was under the impression we were talking about the whole package - album sales, concert sales, relevancy, longevity, etc. Whether you personally like or dislike him is irrelevant and is largely dependent on how likely you were to fit in with the late teen/20-something frat guy Abercrombie and J Crew crowd over the past 15 years. People who fit in with the crowd, it’s cool to like DMB. People who don’t, it’s cool to hate his music.
[/QUOTE]
I’m very split on Dave Matthews. I remember when he first became popular (I think I was in 5th grade) and I thought his music was funky as hell and very interesting. Tripping Billies and Ants Marching were, and still are, really cool songs, and I thought Under The Table And Dreaming was a funky-ass, sweet album.
Crash, too, I thought was awesome, and Dave still had his quirky instrumentation, the amazing bass playing of Stefan Lessard (I was just then starting to play bass) and everything else that made DMB extremely unique especially for the standards of the pop music at the time.
Then, boom, I’m in 8th grade and I have a fully active sex drive and an extremely romantic streak. Perfect timing for seductive songs like Stay (Wasting Time) and especially Crush which resonated with my newfound love of the opposite sex. Plus, the world-music influences of a lot of that album give it a lot of depth, and since I had sophisticated tastes for an 8th grader when it came to music (I listened to Deep Forest, for Christ’s sake,) I really liked that too.
When Everyday came out, that’s when I realized that DMB was going downhill and I stopped liking them. I was also snobbishly upset that DMB-fandom was being appropriated by seemingly uncouth young people (the frat-types that you mentioned) and not being appreciated for its subtle world-music influences and the genuine musicianship of Dave Matthews, and instead, as I saw it, just being thoughtlessly worshipped for being a “cool” “jam band.” It particularly peeved me that the DMB was being lumped together with Phish by this frat-stoner crowd, because I saw Phish as being a silly, overrated group who, despite the great bass playing of Mike Gordon, did not come close to Dave’s band musically. So I no longer liked DMB and in fact began actively hating them.
Then, during the summer of my Junior year in high school, Busted Stuff got a lot of radio play and all of a sudden I found myself liking Dave Matthews again. I especially liked Grace Is Gone. I appreciated the more folksy and smooth style of this album, in contrast to what I felt was an obnoxious effort in Everyday. Maybe Dave wasn’t so bad after all.
Then I heard the song American Baby.
Literally, within seconds, my estimation of Dave Matthews fucking plummeted. He was now completely blacklisted in my music book, and my onetime love for his music was replaced with venomous hatred. I couldn’t believe that he could produce such a shitty song. I was aghast, bewildered, repulsed and disgusted.
I’ve eased up a little lately, and I can appreciate the older Dave, particularly for its nostalgia value. I still respect the band’s musical talent. But I don’t think I will forgive Dave for American Baby. That song is just so bad, it really puts a black mark on the man’s soul.