What is the worst TV show decay you've seen?

4400, like Heroes, had an interesting premise about ordinary humans granted extraordinary abilities and how they would cope with them, seen through the eyes of a couple of feds. It started out as a case of the week kind of storyline but was also building to an overarching plot. Then the fed’s boss stabbed them in the back for some reason, then the baby grew up to be a sexy young lady who was getting married, something else happened, I dunno evil future dudes or something. Regular people hated the powered people, I think. Some were good and some were bad and the future people were bad or something because they wanted the future to happen. I think?

I couldn’t stand Billy Campbell in this and I forgot that I liked him in everything else. My wife and I watched Helix last month and I was like “Hey, I like Billy Campbell. I totally forgot.” This show squandered Garret Dillahunt, Jeffery Combs, and just about everyone else as well. Then it ended.

A bit of a thread that I started about the 4400 a while ago:

It got a lot harder for me to watch after she left after season three. Still made the effort, though…

Hated that stupid robot. Erin Gray was the only reason I watched!

Sorry, but the stupid in Season 4 burned my eyes. I stopped watching when the “you son has your memory of the wormhole” nonsense. I did watch the finale, but the “Instant Crighton – Just add water” cliffhanger was probably the worst in TV history.

Ray Donovan: first season was pretty good and showed some good potential. Then Jon Voight showed up.

I’m still enjoying Homeland, and I think Nurse Jackie probably went one season too long, but was okay for most of its run.

True Detective went from brilliant to disaster in record time.

The Office had quite a few good seasons, but they should have ended it when Carell left the show. Maybe even before then. Definitely before then.

Chevy Chase’s talk show went to shit in the first airing; maybe even before he came out on stage. It was given a mercy killing after five weeks.

I’m not sure what you mean. Please explain.

Yeah, Archer kind of baffles me. It sort of abruptly turned into a parody of itself, where the plots stopped being interesting and the humor has become 99% callbacks. It stopped inventing, and just started repeating itself. It went from “consistently so funny I had to pause it to finish laughing” to “sometimes I chuckle.”

It’s Always Sunny was always a little on the dark side, but Jesus Christ!, the recent episodes are damn near unwatchable. It has degenerated into some truly abhorrent shit.

Oh, I still watch it, and its funny as hell, but I can only imagine I’m the only one who still thinks so. :smiley:

Most of the Comedy Central original shows have a similar trajectory. Workaholics is unwatchable anymore.

Perhaps we have different understandings of the word “original”:

There are sharks in Lake Michigan? :open_mouth:

Sliders. It started out pretty good (though I wanted to throw something at the TV when they thought they were in an alternate reality because Quinn’s mother had oiled the squeaky front gate), but it turned into “All aliens in every timeline” and I was out, even before Jerry O’Connell’s brother showed up.

Peter Davison was the Fifth Doctor, in the original run. Not sure what your point is?

Great topic, and some excellent examples.

Personally I think Game of Thrones is in serious danger of joining this category. As Benioff and Weiss have run out of novels to adapt their shortcomings as writers have been cruelly exposed. I’m pretty much expecting the next season to be a total disaster.

Of course, the Prof. was only quoting Rygel’s epithet for her.

By your own definition, he was not the original Doctor. The original Doctor was William Hartnell.

Davison would be the original Doctor only if you ignored Hartnell, Patrick Troughton, Jon Pertwee, and Tom Baker.

When I said original Doctor Who, I was referring to the TV series that ran from 1963-89.

When I said New Doctor Who, I was referring to the TV series 2005-present.

I have no idea what you meant, or what you thought I meant, or what your actual objection is.

Oh, I see. But Sheldon would know that Doctor Who is the name of the show, not the character.

The others would then start arguing about The War Machines, and Bessie’s vanity plates.

http://wgntv.com/2014/08/14/is-that-a-shark-in-lake-michigan/ :eek:

How about Northern Exposure?

I don’t think the drop-off is a severe as other examples noted, it was a pretty great show that ended on a whimper in a similar manner to The Office.

I get it, I get it! :smack:

*Bewitched * begins with Samantha and Darrin’s honeymoon, if I recall aright. And all the comedic tension comes from the fact that they’re a mixed marriage; the addition of Tabitha just ups to ante.

I can see what you mean withGet Smart. But I never much cared for it anyway.